The best- and worst-paying university degrees

Editor's note: since this article was published, the Government published a comprehensive report on how choice of degree and university affect your earnings. You can find our report and guide here.

Think going to university is expensive now? 

Well, starting in autumn 2017, universities in England will increase tuition fees above £9,000.

It means many students will be facing an even bigger debt mountain once they start working.

Which begs the question: is it actually worth it? Do degrees always pay off in the long run, despite the costs associated with them?

The answer, obviously, is it very much depends which degree you study.

Subject matters

Job search site Adzuna has revealed the degrees that can secure you the highest-paying jobs in the UK. It used analysis of job vacancies which specified the need for a certain type of degree.

Here are the top 17 best paying degrees which can get you an average salary above £30,000.

Source: Adzuna 2016

As you can see, Accounting Business Finance is by far the most lucrative, with the average salary nearly double the second-highest-paying degree.

Here are the worst paying degrees paying under £30,000 according to Adzuna’s research.

Source: Adzuna 2016

Of course averages can be misleading to say the least. There will be massive variations within each field. One graduate working in the same field or even the same job as another can easily earn one-third less than some colleagues.

Career paths

Earning potential for different degree subjects is also influenced by the industries graduates enter.

In the table below, salary comparison site Emolument.com has set out the most likely career paths for each degree subject. This is based on data from 2015.

Source: Emolument.com June 2015

Degrees in Economics, Finance, Mathematics and Statistics are shown to be the best route into lucrative careers in the financial services industry.

In contrast, students of humanities like Geography, History and Politics are the most likely to follow careers in charities, not-for-profit organisations and the public sector.

The annual rate of return on your degree

One way to determine whether your chosen subject will be good value is to look at the rate of return, which you can determine from the amount you invest compared to earnings.

The London Economics on behalf of the Department for Business Innovation & Skills took a look at this for undergraduates in June 2011, in a paper called The Returns to Higher Education Qualifications, just before the tuition fee cap was lifted.

It found the average rate of return for an individual with an undergraduate degree was 15.6% for men and 14.8% for women, which trumps the stock market or property over the long term.

Medicine, Mathematics and Computing as well as Law provided the greatest rate of return for both sexes. You can check out how the different subjects stack up on page 59 of the report.

Unfortunately, these figures are from 2011 and there hasn't been a similar study carried out since, so they are likely a touch out of date. The rates of return quotes are almost certainly lower now that the cost of university has gone up.  

How much are you worth? Get a digital snapshot with Plans

Graduate vs. non-graduate earnings

While graduates often start off earning a similar amount to non-graduates, this changes quickly over the years.

Figures from the latest Department for Business Innovation & Skills Graduate Labour Market report for 2015 shows younger graduates (aged 21-30) had a median salary of £24,000 compared to a median salary of £18,000 for non-graduates in the same age range.

But the median salary of working-age (aged 16-64) graduates is £31,500 compared to £22,000 for non-graduates, suggesting salary differences jump later on in your career as a graduate and stall for non-graduates.

That said the graduate premium has narrowed in the last nine years from around 55% to 48% higher than non-graduate earnings between 2006 and 2015.

The latest analysis from the Department for Business Innovation & Skills in a 2013 paper called The Impact of University Degrees on the Lifecycle of Earnings says on average female graduates will earn an extra £252,000 and male graduates an extra £168,000 over their lifetime compared to non-graduates.

Degrees more beneficial for women

On average, research shows that women gain greater financial benefits from a university education than men do.

Women who don't go to university tend to earn a great deal less than men who don't go to university. However, women's incomes, on average, are boosted more by a degree to make it a more level playing field.

Similarly, men from poorer backgrounds also benefit more from university than men from affluent ones. Discrimination, it seems, is more difficult for employers when you've got a degree.

However, there is still a big difference in average earnings between male and female graduates.

According to the latest figures from the Higher Educational Statistics Agency latest Destinations of Leavers from Higher Education 2014/15 report the average salary for female leavers was £21,000 compared to £22,00 for males.

The postgrad premium

Some - but far from all - employers offer a premium for those who go beyond a Bachelor's degree.

Figures from the Department for Business Innovation & Skills Graduate Labour Market report  show the median annual salary of young postgraduates (21-30) was £28,000 in 2015, £4,000 more compared to graduates in the same age range.

According to 2011 The Returns to Higher Education Qualifications paper from the Department for Business Innovation & Skills, men with a Master’s degrees earn an extra £59,000, while women go on to earn an extra £42,000 over their lifetime.

Do degrees always pay off?

No, not always.

A degree is a gamble unless you have a guaranteed job waiting for you at the end of it. Otherwise it depends on the job market and the economy.

And it’s an expensive gamble. The average student leaves university with debts totalling £44,000 (Sutton Trust report) and the current average graduate starting salary is £22,500 (HESA).

Even if your salary goes up every year by almost 5%, it will still take you at least a decade to pay off your debt, which will cost you even more than you think.

It's true that, without a degree, you can still earn more than the average graduate. Those taking training places from one of the big accountancy or law firms, for example, can circumvent the need and cost of a degree.

However, graduates are less likely to be unemployed.

The current employment rate for working age (aged 16-64) graduates is 87.1% compared to 69.8% for non-graduates. (Department for Business Innovation & Skills Graduate Labour Market report 2015).

Finally, it's worth bearing in mind that around 6% of students drop out of university (HESA 2014/15) in their first year and over half of graduates end up with non-graduate jobs (Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development).

That's a lot of statistics. You may need a degree just to take them all in!

This is a classic loveMONEY article that has been updated