Don't lock away your savings for five years

Ed Bowsher
by Lovemoney Staff Ed Bowsher on 21 January 2013  |  Comments 4 comments

Rates are so poor on savings accounts these days, there's little point locking away your money for long periods, certainly not for five years.

Don't lock away your savings for five years

When I write an article about savings accounts, my normal line is that instant access accounts are all very well, but you’ll get a much better return if you’re prepared to lock away your money for several years. Usually in a fixed rate bond.

But interest rates on savings accounts are so low these days, I’m not sure that’s true anymore.

Look at the following tables which show the top-paying easy access accounts right now and top-paying five year bonds:

Easy access accounts 

Account

Interest rate

Minimum deposit

Notes

West Brom WebSave Plus 3

2.3%

£1,000

Online only

West Brom Easy Access Saver Issue 3

2.26%

£1,000

Branch

Ulster Bank Loyalty Saver

2.25%

£2,000

Online, phone or branch

Post Office Instant Saver

2.1% (includes 2% bonus for 12 months)

£500

Online, phone, branch or post

Nationwide Loyalty Saver Issue 3

2.1%

£1,000

Online or branch

Five-year bonds

Account

Interest rate

Minimum deposit

Notes

FirstSave five year Fixed Rate Bond 1st issue

3.05%

£1,000

Online

Vanquis Bank High Yield (Five years)

3.01%

£1,000

Online only

Wesleyan Fixed Rate Deposit (Five years)

3%

£1,000

Online only

So the best five-year account pays 3.05% while the best easy access account pays 2.3% - a tiny difference of just 0.75%. To put it another way, if you had a spare £1,000 to put in a savings account, you’d only earn an extra £7.50 a year if you locked away your money in the FirstSave five-year bond rather than the easy access West Brom WebSave Plus 3.

Now you could argue that £7.50 is still worth going for if you’re sure that you won’t need the money at any point in the next five years. But my concern is that interest rates might rise during that time and you’d feel rather fed up as rates on many accounts rose while you remained stuck on 3.05% until 2018.

Higher rates on savings accounts could be triggered by three possible factors:

- Increases in the Bank of England’s base rate

- Rising yields on gilts (government bonds) which would particularly affect fixed rate bonds

- The winding up of the Government’s Funding for Lending scheme next year

In fairness, I suspect that only one of those factors will kick in within the next two years – the wind-up of Funding for Lending. So interest rates probably won’t rise that much before 2015 and you could just about make a case for going for a two- or three-year bond.

Three-year bonds or less

Account

Interest rate

Minimum deposit

Notes

Vanquis Bank High Yield (3 years)

2.96%

£1,000

Online

FirstSave Three Year Fixed Rate Bond 5th Issue

2.95%

£1,000

Online

Wesleyan Fixed Rate Deposit (Three years)

2.85%

£1,000

Online

Islamic Bank of Britain Fixed Term Deposit (2 years)

2.83%

£1,000

Online, phone, branch or post. This account is sharia compliant, so you’re paid ‘profit’ not ‘interest.’

FirstSave Two Year Fixed Rate Bond 14th Issue

2.75%

£1,000

Online

Wesleyan Fixed Rate Deposit (Two years)

2.75%

£1,000

Online

Vanquis Bank High Yield (2 years)

2.51%

£1,000

Online

Santander 18-Month Fixed Rate Bond

2.5%

£500

Phone or Branch

Metro Bank Fixed Term Savings (18-month bond)

2.5%

£500

Phone or Branch

Wesleyan Fixed Rate Deposit (One year)

2.5%

£1,000

Online

But even then, if you went for the Vanquis Bank High Yield three-year account, you’d only get an extra 0.66% a year compared to the top easy access account. That’s not much of a return for losing control of your money for three years as well as the risk that interest rates rise more quickly than I expect.

Alternatives

So are there any alternatives out there?

Well one option is to lend to your money to other people via the peer-to-peer lending sites such as Zopa and Ratesetter.

You could earn as much as 6% on your money if you’re prepared to lock away your money for five years. (6% is the kind of return that makes locking away your money a much more attractive proposition.) Read more in What is peer-to-peer (P2P) lending?

Or you could switch your current account to the Santander 123 current account where you could earn 3% on any balances between £3,000 and £20,000. You will, however, have to pay in at least £500 a month and you’ll also have to pay a £2 monthly fee for the account.

For many people, I think the best option will be to go down the peer-to-peer route. But whatever you do, don’t go for a five-year bond. There’s just no point!

More on savings accounts:

Building societies restrict savings accounts to local residents only

Bank of England admits Funding for Lending to blame for dismal savings rates

The top fixed-rate savings bonds

The best instant access savings accounts

Enjoyed this? Show it some love

Twitter
General

Comments (4)

  • BGM
    Love rating 9
    BGM said

    my cash ISA is 3.05%... and not a promo rate i found out the other day!

    Report on 22 January 2013  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • urgetosplurge
    Love rating 0
    urgetosplurge said

    I have been using Funding Circle for the last year, and I have to say that I am very disappointed with the performance of the loans on that platform. Despite a headline average return of 9.4%, the effective return after bad debts is only 3.5%. And factoring in additional potential losses from late repayments makes it even worse: just 0.6%.

    I don't know if I've just been unlucky, but this has been a very poor investment: I'm not convinced that its management has been adequately assessing the risk profile of the businesses using the platform to borrow.

    Report on 23 January 2013  |  Love thisLove  0 loves

Post a comment

Sign in or register to post a reply.

Our top deals

Provider & account name AER/Gross Interest paid Apply
now

GE Capital Direct
GE Saver Issue 6

1.10% /
1.10%
Anniversary Apply

Scottish Widows Bank
Direct Transfer Account 2

1.00% /
1.00%
Anniversary Apply

NatWest
Instant Saver

0.50% /
0.50%
Quarterly Apply
W3C  Thank you for using Three Kings