Top reward and cashback cards

We take you through the best credit cards that reward your shopping habits...
I've had an American Express Platinum Cashback credit card for a while now.
Owning one has served me well. In my first year, I managed to earn £140 in cashback, and this year, I managed to rack up £25.
But it doesn't take a genius to work out £25 isn't as good as £140, and I've started to look for alternatives.
During the first three months when Amex Platinum offered a generous 5% on all purchases, I paid for everything on my card, from my travel season ticket to a pint of milk at the supermarket.
This heavy spending at the beginning allowed me to take advantage of the higher rate of cashback, and I reaped the rewards.
Now, as my third year approaches, the news that old Amex Platinum customers like me need to spend £4,250 every year just to qualify for cashback at all is starting to put me off.
After all, £4,250 is a lot of pints of milk.
Here's a quick look at the cashback cards on offer:
Card and provider | APR (typical) | Cashback offered | Other |
American Express Platinum Cashback | 19.9% | 5% for first three months (up to £100), then 0.5% on the first £3,500 of spend, 1% from £3,501 to £7,500, and 1.25% from £7,501 upwards. | Minimum income £30,000. No cashback paid for new customers if less than £3,000 is spent in one year. No cashback for existing customers (before August) if less than £4,250 is spent. |
Egg Money | 17.8% | 1% cashback | £1 per month fee. No cashback paid on amounts less than £5 |
Bank of Ireland Moneyback Gold | 17.9% | 0.5% cashback | Maximum cashback £75. |
There are three big players in the cashback market: Amex, Egg and Bank of Ireland, which offer very different deals.
Last year, my article New top cashback card - for some of you, offered a detailed comparison of the Amex and Egg offerings.
But some points are worth re-stressing. The rules have changed for existing and new Amex customers, so it's important to know where you stand.
If you got your card before mid-August last year, after your first anniversary, you'll need to spend £4,250 a year - that's an average of £350 a month - in order to qualify for any cashback at all.
With Egg, the catches are slightly different. As an Egg Money MasterCard holder, you have to spend a minimum of £500 each year in order to qualify for any cashback, and a minimum of £1,200 each year to break even with the £1 fee.
However, unless you spend around £1,000 a month or more Egg is still better than the American Express card outside the promotional period, not to mention it is accepted in more places.
A richer reward?
If you're looking for something different, you might want to consider a reward card instead. But with so many cards on offer, finding the right reward card can quickly become a needle and haystack dilemma.
Take Amex's new offering, the American Express Rewards Credit Card, which gives you up to three points for every £1 spent at major UK supermarkets, two points for every £1 at UK department stores and one point for every £1 spent elsewhere.
You’ll also receive 6,000 bonus points (worth £30) when you spend £500 in the first three months, and can redeem these points at popular retailers like Amazon, Boots and Marks and Spencer.
Jane Baker's thorough review put the card through its paces, and she found that you could earn up to £200 while you shop with the card. However, she also found that if you used Amex's cashback card, you'd earn £279.
One of my favourite reward cards is the Airmiles Duo credit card from Lloyds TSB. Unlike most air miles credit cards, Airmiles does not charge taxes, fees and charges on top of miles you redeem.
With taxes and fees making up the bulk of the most of today's airfares, this can make a significant difference to the savings you'll make. Plus, if you don't have enough miles, you can top them up with cash.
Airmiles is offering a free 1,500 Airmiles voucher if you take out a card through the Airmiles website by January 31 and spend at least £10 by March 31. This is enough for two return flights to Paris or Amsterdam.
Another rewards credit card I like is the Amex Nectar card. The card offers two points for every pound spent at Nectar partners, and one point for every pound spent elsewhere. In addition, you get double points for the first three months
But that's not all. Nectar are now giving away points faster than the Bank of England is printing money, and it couldn't be a better time to cash in.
Now, every month you spend £500 or more on the Nectar credit card, you'll get 500 Nectar points on top of what you've already earned.
You can also earn more points at Nectar eStores, an online portal that works in the same way as cashback sites, except instead of pounds, you get paid in points. It's a good alternative to cashback if you shop regularly at Nectar partners, and the rewards can quickly stack up.
More: Five easy ways to borrow money quickly | Clean up your credit rating
Most Recent
Comments
-
I use an Amex card where I can but as we are regular Sainsburys shoppers we use the Utility Warehouse (UW) mastercard as it pays an unbelievable ongoing 5% cashback on grocery/fuel purchases. Importantly this is NOT a credit card but a pre-payment card - no jumping through hoops to get it, no credit check etc and therefore no chance of getting into debt. We throughly researched this and our research revealed that the best way to use this card is to take one service from UW as there are definitely cheaper deals to be had elsewhere on each of their products if you don't mind long tie-ins and cancellation charges. We take our gas from them and have managed to reduce it down to approx £330 for the year taking into account the cashback earned (which unusually is credited onto our account monthly). Cheapest gas for our usage (19000, Yorkshire area) is EDF online saver 4 at £584/yr. UW price (pre-cashback) is £717 but our annual spend on the UW card looks like it is going to be £8000+ (mostly at Sainsburys but there are other major retailers like B&Q, Homebase, Boots, Comet etc etc). Retailers that aren't included on the UW 5% list we use the Amex card at. I think it's called maximising money saving. For instance, if we ditched the UW card and took our gas from the cheapest supplier we would 'save' £133 a year. Then we would use the Amex card for shopping at Sainsburys. Only problem being the cashback on our spend would amount to a rather disappointing (in comparison) £67.50 as opposed to a net £383 with the UW card. In effect we would be taking out £133 cheaper gas but paying approx £183 MORE for it! Go figure.
REPORT This comment has been reported. -
Horses for courses. I use a Partnership (John Lewis) card that pays vouchers for use in John Lewis and Waitrose shops. I get vouchers every 3 months of £40 to £50 a time. That may not be the best deal but, it suits my needs as that's where I shop. Which ever card you use, make sure you pay the full amount each month or any benefit is lost.
REPORT This comment has been reported. -
I have a Capital One Cashback Mastercard, paying 1%. I think they discontinued it, but fortunately they haven't stopped it for existing customers. I also have an Amex, which I use where I can. If it pays 0.5% for the first £3500, then compared to cards that give a flat 1%, you lose out £17.50. However, the Egg card costs you £12 a year, reducing the difference to £5.50, and it's not worth it to me to switch for £5.50 (especially since Capital One's cashback is as good as Egg's, plus it has no fee). Additionally, if I spend more than £7500 on Amex then it starts to pay back more, and above £9700 it's the best again. I don't have the time of day for Nectar, etc. Not only do they pay out in phoney "points" rather than cold hard cash, but the points are only worth half a penny (designed, no doubt, to make doing the mental maths more difficult and to give the illusion that they are worth twice what they really are), so these cards are really only paying out 0.5% - half of what you can get elsewhere. In fact, with Boots and Tescos paying out up to 4% (effectively) via their points scheme, Nectar is positively stingey in its returns.
REPORT This comment has been reported.
Do you want to comment on this article? You need to be signed in for this feature
02 February 2010