Amazing inventions dismissed as fads that wouldn’t last
Jonathan Elderfield/Getty
Game-changing innovations that were savagely mocked
Haters gonna hate, and many of humanity's most important inventions were ridiculed when they were first invented, dismissed as ludicrous fads that would never catch on. From the fork to the laptop, click or scroll through to find out about 15 ingenious innovations that ultimately proved the naysayers very wrong indeed.
István Bóna [Public domain], via Wikimedia Commons
Fork
Exactly when the fork was invented is open to question, but this essential piece of cutlery is thought to have been introduced to the Western world in the 10th century by Byzantine princess, Theophano Skleraina (pictured), the wife of Holy Roman Emperor Otto II. Although some historians credit its arrival in Europe to another Byzantine princess, Maria Argyropoulaina, who married the Doge of Venice's son in 1004.
Metropolitan Museum of Art [Public domain], via Wikimedia Commons
Fork
Both princesses were roundly ridiculed for their use of the curious pronged implement, and the fork only made inroads in the 16th century when it became fashionable in Venice, before spreading throughout Italy. Still, the cutlery piece continued to be sneered at elsewhere in Europe and wasn't widely adopted on the continent until the late 18th century.
Internet Archive Book Images/No restrictions [Public domain], via Wikimedia Commons
Printing press
Though woodblock printing emerged in China during the 7th century, the first bona fide printing press was invented around 1440 in Mainz, Germany by Johannes Gutenberg, changing humanity forever and ushering in the modern era. But like many revolutionary inventions, the contraption had plenty of critics.
NYC Wanderer/Flickr CC (CC BY-SA 2.0)
Printing press
Bizarrely German Benedictine abbot Johannes Trithemius thought that printed materials wouldn't last and believed writings inscribed on parchment were better suited to standing the test of time. Other critics complained that printed books would lead to everything from information overload to political chaos, and would put Europe's monks out of work, harming their spiritual development.
Arthur Devis [Public domain], via Wikimedia Commons
Umbrella
Today the umbrella is an essential accessory in rainy England. In fact, the average person in the country owns two of the things. Yet the first man to carry an umbrella in the nation was bombarded with insults, pelted with rubbish and almost run over and killed by a coach. Jonas Hanway shocked fellow Londoners in the 1750s when he took to using an umbrella in the city's streets.
Umbrella
An import from Persia via France, the accessory was considered taboo for men to carry and thought of as a sign of a weak, effeminate character. Hanway also drew the ire of coach drivers (behind two-wheeled, horse-drawn carriages) who feared the accessory would steal away their business, which flourished on wet days. Stubborn, Hanway ignored the haters even when one coach driver went as far as trying to run him over. Within decades the stigma attached to umbrellas vanished and they have come to be ubiquitous across the country.
Wellcome Library/CC BY (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0)
Vaccines
In 1796 English country doctor Edward Jenner pulled off a sensational medical breakthrough when he inoculated an eight-year-old boy with cowpox to protect against the far more deadly smallpox after noticing milkmaids, who were routinely exposed to the more benign bovine pathogen, seemed immune to the devastating human disease. The experiment was an unmitigated success. Jenner coined the term vaccine from the Latin word 'vacca' meaning cow and published his findings in 1798.
Library of Congress, Prints & Photographs Division [Public domain], via Wikimedia Commons
Vaccines
Instead of being lauded for his discovery, Jenner was lampooned, particularly by religious leaders, who were horrified the physician was going against the will of God and using pus from diseased animals to inoculate people. The press also poured scorn on Jenner as you can see from this satirical cartoon by James Gillray, which shows vaccinated individuals growing grotesque cow's heads. Thankfully the disdain for Jenner's discovery dissipated and vaccination eventually become commonplace.
Gilbert H. Grosvenor Collection, Prints and Photographs Division, Library of Congress [Public domain], via Wikimedia Commons
Telephone
Father of the telephone Alexander Graham Bell was awarded the first patent for the device in 1876 and is credited with creating the first practical incarnation of the trailblazing technology. Few saw its tremendous potential however. After Bell tried to sell his telecoms business to Western Union, its president William Orton exclaimed, “what use could this company make of an electrical toy?”
Archive of the Marconi Company Ltd. [Public domain], via Wikimedia Commons
Telephone
People even thought an American mayor was being overly optimistic about the future of the telephone when he predicted that “one day, there will be one in every city”. The reception was similarly cool in the UK. Sir William Preece, the chief engineer of the British Post Office (pictured), was convinced the technology would never go mainstream in England: “the Americans have need of the telephone, but we do not. We have plenty of messenger boys”, he is quoted as saying.
Electric light bulb
Thomas Edison patented the world's first commercially viable electric light bulb in 1879. Despite its ingenuity, the technology had more than its fair share of influential critics, most notably Professor Henry Morton of the Stevens Institute of Technology, who slammed the invention, calling it a conspicuous failure trumpeted as a wonderful success.
Electric light bulb
As was the case with the telephone, experts over in the UK were even more contemptuous of Edison's innovation. A British parliamentary committee snootily concluded that the American invention was “good enough for our transatlantic friends... but unworthy of the attention of practical or scientific men”, while Sir William Preece, who was clearly no stranger to bad predictions, called it an “absolute ignis fatuus ['foolish fire']” – basically a will-o'-the-wisp or false hope.
Now read about accidental inventions that made a fortune
Royal Society of New Zealand [Public domain], via Wikimedia Commons
Daylight saving time (DST)
Most countries these days move their clocks forward an hour in the spring and back every autumn to make the most of natural daylight. The practice was first suggested in 1895 by British-born New Zealand scientist George Vernon Hudson in a paper submitted to the Wellington Philosophical Society. Hudson's suggestion was lambasted by his peers.
Rutrus [Public domain], via Wikimedia Commons
Daylight saving time (DST)
Indeed the very notion of playing around with time was thought of as preposterous. One member complained that it was “out of the question to think of altering a system that had been in use for thousands of years”, while another rubbished the concept as unscientific and impractical. Hudson had the last laugh of course when DST was adopted in Ontario, Canada in 1908, with countries around the world soon following suit.
Popular Science [Public domain], via Wikimedia Commons
Bicycle
The earliest bicycle was invented in Germany in the 1810s but the pedal-driven vehicle didn't enter the mainstream until the 1890s with the introduction of the so-called safety bike. Regarded at the time as a frivolous pastime for the aspirational middle and decadent upper classes, the innovation was mercilessly panned.
Punch magazine/Public domain
Bicycle
Female cyclists in particular were the objects of ridicule as you can see from this Punch magazine cartoon from 1898, and journalists were quick to dismiss the bicycle as a silly short-lived craze. In 1902 The Washington Post declared the activity a passing fancy, while the New York Sun confidently proclaimed the death of the pastime in 1906.
La Vie au Grand Air [Public domain], via Wikimedia Commons
Automobile
Cynics rushed to disparage the automobile too. Literary Digest weighed in on the technology in 1899, concluding that “the ordinary 'horseless carriage' is at present a luxury for the wealthy; and although its price will probably fall in the future, it will never, of course, come into as common use as the bicycle”.
Transcendental Graphics/Getty
Automobile
The New York Times agreed, stating in 1902 that the price of automobiles “will never be sufficiently low to make them as widely popular as were bicycles,” while the following year the President of the Michigan Savings Bank warned Henry Ford's lawyer Horace Rackham not to invest in the Ford Motor Company on the grounds that “the horse is here to stay, but the automobile is only a novelty – a fad”. Ford didn't take any notice of this warning and his investment in the mass production of cars was a key driver behind the great future success of cars.
Discover the tech and inventions that show why China is the best in the world
Warner Bros. [Public domain], via Wikimedia Commons
Sound film
The first 'talkies' were actually produced by pioneering French director Alice Guy-Blaché in the early 1900s. But movies incorporating synchronised dialogue didn't take off until 1927 with the release of Hollywood blockbuster The Jazz Singer, which spelled the end of the silent movie era. That said, despite the film's huge success, early sound movies had plenty of powerful detractors.
Hollywood Magazine/Public domain
Sound film
United Artists president Joseph Schenck surmised in 1928 that “talking doesn't belong in pictures”, while across the pond British film studio boss John Maxwell dismissed the talkie as “a costly fad”. Hollywood stars were equally disdainful of the newfangled technology. Actress Mary Astor wrote in the 1960s that many artists of the era considered The Jazz Singer a box-office gimmick and reckoned that sound movies would “drive audiences from the theaters”.
Library of Congress's Prints and Photographs division [Public domain], via Wikimedia Commons Television
Television
Scottish inventor John Logie Baird introduced the TV to the world in 1926, attracting sceptics from the start. When Baird turned up at UK newspaper the Daily Express' offices to showcase his creation, the newspaper's editor ordered a staff member to “go down to reception and get rid of the lunatic... He says he's got a machine for seeing by wireless. Watch him – he may have a razor on him". That same year radio pioneer Lee DeForest judged TV to be “commercially and financially... an impossibility”.
Radio Corporation of America [Public domain], via Wikimedia Commons
Television
In 1939 the New York Times stressed that "TV will never be a serious competitor for radio because people must sit and keep their eyes glued on a screen; the average American family hasn't time for it.” While 20th Century Fox boss Darryl Zanuck claimed in 1946 that “TV won't be able to hold on to any market it captures after the first six months. People will soon get tired of staring at a plywood box every night." And in 1948 BBC radio exec Mary Somerville called the technology “a flash in the pan".
Mobile phone
Back in the early 1980s mobile phones were heavy brick-like devices, expensive to purchase and use and the sole preserve of rich business people. No wonder the future of the technology appeared bleak to some experts. A 1980 report by McKinsey for AT&T predicted that the mobile phone would be a strictly niche device with just 900,000 users in the US by 2000. In reality the total number of users that year hit 108 million.
Rico Shen/CC BY-SA (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/)
Mobile phone
In 1981 telecoms consultant Jan David Jubon was unconvinced the technology had any traction: “But who, today, will say I'm going to ditch the wires in my house and carry the phone around?” And Marty Cooper (pictured), the engineer that led the team that built the first mobile phone, was himself pretty lukewarm about the technology, telling the newspaper, “Cellular phones will absolutely not replace local wire systems. Even if you project it beyond our lifetimes, it won't be cheap enough."
Bilby/CC BY (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0)
Laptop
A slew of historians consider the Osbourne 1, which was released in 1981, the first truly portable computer. Hot on its heels, the Compaq Portable, the first PC-compatible laptop, was launched in 1983. While super-innovative, early laptops were cumbersome, limited in what they could do and outrageously expensive to boot, with some retailing for the equivalent of $17,000 (£13k) in today's money.
Laptop
Given these drawbacks it comes as no surprise that some experts dismissed the laptop as a fad. For instance New York Times tech writer Erik Sandberg-Diment penned an article in 1985 deriding the innovation and predicting its sad demise. The journalist believed the average user would never want to lug around a laptop and compute on the move, and thought the gizmo had little chance of catching on widely.
ARPANET [Public domain], via Wikimedia Commons
Email
Electronic mail was invented way back in 1965 at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT) and the first message from computer to computer (the two devices are pictured here) was sent in 1969 via the US Department of Defense's Advanced Research Projects Agency Network (ARPANET). Interestingly, the agency initially dismissed the technology, stating that sending messages between users “was not an important motivation for a network of scientific computers”.
Jonathan Elderfield/Getty
Email
Even during the mid 1990s when email was going mainstream naysayers were dismissive of the technology. In 1994 UK government officials mulling over whether to set up an email account for the then-prime minister John Major claimed that the new method of exchanging messages would likely never catch on.
Internet
Back in the mid 1990s a number of experts were less than keen on the internet, which they viewed as a nerdy fad that would end up going nowhere. By way of example, a now-infamous article penned by scientist Clifford Stoll in 1995 for Newsweek entitled 'The Internet? Bah!' slammed the innovation and predicted it would crash and burn.
Internet
Also in 1995, Ethernet inventor Bob Metcalfe (pictured) wrote in an opinion piece for InfoWorld magazine that “the internet will soon go spectacularly supernova and in 1996 catastrophically collapse”. Metcalfe vowed to eat is words if he was wrong, and did just that at the World Wide Web Conference in 1997 when he blended a copy of the article with some water and wasted no time downing the concoction.
Now read about the famous inventions their creators regretted