Follow this topicFollow this topic Q&A » Pensions

my husband is about to retire, is it best to take a lump sum and lower pension?

blackhole
by blackhole 20 April 2012  |  Comments 6 comments  |  Love Love  0 loves

Report

Enjoyed this? Show it some love

Twitter
General

Comments (6)

  • MikeGG1
    Love rating 879
    MikeGG1 posted

    Is this a Final Salary (Defined Benefit) pension or a Money Purchase (Defined Contribution) pension? If it is Money Purchase then take the cash because it is tax free.

    If it is Final Salary, divide the cash sum by the pension surrendered and tell us the result. Also say what guaranteed increases are built into the pension and whether spouse's benefit is also surrendered. His age at retirement is also needed aqs his his top tax rate once retired

    Although there is a tax advantage for taking cash, many Final Salary schemes do not give full value for money on pension surrendered. The rates are often years out of date and the factors could date back to 1970 and/or ignore the increases.

    Mike

    Posted on 20 April 2012 | Love Love  0 loves Report
  • blackhole
    Love rating 0
    blackhole posted

    defined benefit with about 10k a year less pension in return for 190k tax free cash, 50% pension for spouse on death

    Posted on 20 April 2012 | Love Love  0 loves Report
  • MikeGG1
    Love rating 879
    MikeGG1 posted

    As previously requested, we would need his age at retirement, the rate of escalation of pension and whether spouse's benefit is reduced by the cash, plus his top tax rate after he retires (that could be lower than he is currently on)..

    Mike

    Posted on 20 April 2012 | Love Love  0 loves Report
  • blackhole
    Love rating 0
    blackhole posted

    Age is 62, rate of escalation is cpi and his rate of tax would be lower if he took the tax free amount, 40% if took higher pension

    Posted on 20 April 2012 | Love Love  0 loves Report
  • MikeGG1
    Love rating 879
    MikeGG1 posted

    You still haven't said whether any spouse's pension would be lost as a result of taking the cash.

    On the assumption that it isn't, the conversion factor is 19:1 and some pension would be at 40% and some at 20%, so if the average was 30%, the conversion factor would effectively be 19/0.7=27.14.

    You can do your own calculation if you can work out your actual average.

    Currently the cost of a single life pension for a Male 62 increasing at RPI would be about 30:1 but RPI would be more expensive than CPI.

    However, some cash could be very handy.

    Mike

    Posted on 21 April 2012 | Love Love  0 loves Report
  • OorWullie
    Love rating 38
    OorWullie posted

    Not having the mind of a banker, mathematician, nor actuary, it seemed to me that offers like this are obviously a gamble as it would depend on how long one might live but as the extra cash was needed I opted for the lump sum. Now 25 years later I think the choice was the right one yet, paradoxically, I have no way of actually knowing. Maybe it was not the right option, however, ignorance is, indeed, bliss!

    Posted on 21 April 2012 | Love Love  0 loves Report

Post an answer

Sign in or register to post an answer.

Something you're dying to ask... or answer?

Register with lovemoney.com to start asking and answering questions on Q&A.

Get started now

Sign in for a better Q&A

Registered already? Great! You can just sign in to ask and answer questions.

Sign in
W3C  Thank you for using CGWEBLIV3