Follow this topicFollow this topic Q&A » Current accounts

Why do Banks allow personal accountsd to go overdrawn

mike1blade
by mike1blade 16 November 2010  |  Comments 6 comments  |  Love Love  0 loves

I asked my bank, HSBC., to withdraw my overdraft facility, they then allowed my account to go overdrawn and charged me their maximum fee to doing so. It took them a year to finally come up with "no" (that they would not refund their charges, on some occasions they didn't even answer my complaints.

Report

Enjoyed this? Show it some love

Twitter
General

Comments (6)

  • MissingOz
    Love rating 8
    MissingOz posted

    Banks will claim that they do it as a convenience for you...(so you won't

    feel embarrassed while making a purchase and be denied), but the real

    reason is...so they can charge you overdraft fees!

    Posted on 16 November 2010 | Love Love  1 love Report
  • JoeEasedale
    Love rating 159
    JoeEasedale posted

    It is costly to take staff time to familiarise themselves with your account, and then more costly to return an item unpaid.

    In many cases such decisions are made by computer based upon the operation of your account.

    If you don't want charges - don't go overdrawn. It is a simple matter to keep track of an account and to keep a small reserve there in case of need. In over 40 years of operating a current account, I have never gone overdrawn.

    There is a mechanism that you agreed to when you opened the account to determine what happens if you do. In each occasion the item taking the account overdrawn was one you had authorised and therefore it is not unreasonable for the bank to assume, wanted paid.

    Posted on 16 November 2010 | Love Love  0 loves Report
  • MikeGG1
    Love rating 824
    MikeGG1 posted

    Which would you prefer?

    To be charged an overdraft fee/interest for payments that you obviously wanted to make.

    Or

    To be charged a fee every time the bank had to reject a payment together with your embarrassment when the recipient quite rightly demands their money, quite possibly with added charges for having to re-apply for the money.

    Alternatively are you looking for an excuse for defaulting on a payment? That would be fraud!

    Mike

    Posted on 16 November 2010 | Love Love  0 loves Report
  • mike1blade
    Love rating 0
    mike1blade posted

    Sorry Joe, you're wrong - Banks can control the overdrawn situations simply by organising their computers correctly, it's not a staff thing. In the case I was referring to the transaction was an ATM withdrawal whilst I was overseas, and immediately followed a check on the internet banking site which confirmed there were funds in the account - the bank was 4 days late in updating the balance, but well done that you've never gone overdrawn, I hadn't in my 40 years until now. There was no agreed mechanism, instead I had 3 lettersemails from the bank (HSBC) stating that I had no overdraft facility - at my request I might add.

    mike GG1, also wrong, in these modern days computers are used you know - HSBC won't let my account go over the funds available in my account whilst using their net service to transfer funds from one account to another, but they will allow it will on cash withdrawals - exscuse for defaulting on a payment, your'e obviously well versed on that point. Your assumptions are wrong and you haven't read the question.

    missingoz - thanks mate, you read the question - yes, they do manipulate these occasions to charge fee's, interestingly, their terms and conditions will probably tell you that if there is no facility for an overdraft on your account then that decision is adhered to, I've already referred my case to the Financial Ombudsman.

    Posted on 17 November 2010 | Love Love  0 loves Report
  • poppasmurf
    Love rating 18
    poppasmurf posted

    Halifax do it all the time go into an unathorised overdraft by say 1pence (or if you dont have one) and they charge you £5 a day, its just daylight robbery.

    Posted on 20 November 2010 | Love Love  0 loves Report
  • ogram23
    Love rating 5
    ogram23 posted

    Further to this. I only have debit cards, never had and never wanted credit card. This means I can only spend what I have and not get credit( debt!). Therefore when presented and transaction declined it's because I have not enough money in account. I am sure I had this happen once in a supermarket. However couple of years ago I had a debit card transaction passed with not enough funds to cover. (only £2 on £300 transaction). I had used the wrong card as they were both the same colour. When I got a letter saying they were charging me £70 for this I immediately went to the bank and complained and had this charged removed. Needless to say did not have a satisfactory answer as to why this transaction was allowed to go through in the first place.

    Why use silly US spell check on a UK site! 

    Posted on 20 November 2010 | Love Love  0 loves Report

Post an answer

Sign in or register to post an answer.

Something you're dying to ask... or answer?

Register with lovemoney.com to start asking and answering questions on Q&A.

Get started now

Sign in for a better Q&A

Registered already? Great! You can just sign in to ask and answer questions.

Sign in
W3C  Thank you for using Lock, Stock and Two Smoking Barrels