Don't make this £335m holiday mistake

Robert Powell
by Lovemoney Staff Robert Powell on 20 June 2011  |  Comments 12 comments

If you're planning on using one of these cards abroad this summer, you better be prepared to pay a hefty fee...

Don't make this £335m holiday mistake

Going on holiday is pricey enough nowadays without having to pay for the privilege of using your debit or credit card. But nevertheless, millions of us do – and it’s costing us an estimated £335 million in fees and charges every year.

Research by Travelex reveals that British holidaymakers will use a debit or credit card to fund around a quarter of their holiday expenditure. But with the majority of card issuers now levying hefty conversion fees as well as flat rate charges, this is an expensive way to pay for your holiday.

The worst banks for overseas spending

In the table below are the fees levied by six major card providers on all of their standard current accounts.

Debit card

Foreign currency exchange fee (applied to all non-£ transactions)

Point of sale purchase transactions fee

Cash withdrawal fee

Lloyds TSB

2.99%

£1

1.5% (min £2, max £4.50)

RBS

2.75%

£1.25

1.5% (min £2, max £5)

Halifax

2.75%

£1.50

£1.50

NatWest

2.75%

£1.25

2% (min £2, max £5)

Santander (apart from Zero account)

2.75%

£1.25

1.5% (min £1.99)

HSBC

2.75%

£0

2% (min £1.75, max £5)

As you can see, a few transactions and visits to the ATM while abroad when using these cards could add a substantial sum to your holiday bill.

The fees for many credit cards are just as steep with most providers charging an exchange fee of at least 3.00% and a minimum cash withdrawal charge of around £3 a time. That’s on top of the huge cash advance interest rates – usually in the region of 25% - charged by nearly all credit card issuers from the moment you withdraw any notes.

Foreign friendly credit cards

Here are some of the best credit cards for overseas spending:

Credit card

Exchange fee

Purchase fee

Cash withdrawal fee

Cash withdrawal APR

Interest charged on cash withdrawals from

Rep. APR

Halifax Clarity

0%

Free

Free

12.9%

Withdrawal day

12.9%

Sainsbury’s Gold MasterCard (£5/month fee)

0%

Free

Free

24.9%

Non-payment of your full bill

20.1%

Saga Platinum (over 50s card)

0%

Free

2% (min £2)

19.6 %

Non-repayment of your full bill

19.6%

Nationwide BS Balance Transfer Visa

0% (until 31.07.11)

Free (until 31.07.11)

2.5% (min £3)

27.9%

Withdrawal day

15.9%

Santander Zero (existing current acc customers only)

0%

Free

Free

27.9%

Withdrawal day

18.9%

So the Halifax Clarity Card offers no exchange, purchase or cash withdrawal fees, but you will still pay 12.9% in interest from the moment you take cash from an ATM until you clear the bill in full.

The Sainsbury’s Gold Card will charge you no such fees, as long as you clear off your bill every month; but you will have to pay a £5 per month general charge. Similarly the Saga card will not charge you any interest if you clear your bill every month, but you will have to foot a 2% (min £2) charge for cash withdrawals and be over 50 to be eligible for the account.

Nationwide’s credit card is fee free for purchases until the end of July. After this, Nationwide will start operating a reward system for overseas transactions – the more you spend, the greater your 0% overseas spending limit will be.

Santander’s Zero card is completely fee free but does charge a hefty 27.9% interest rate on cash advances from the day you make the withdrawal. You’ll also need to have held a Santander current account for at least three months, and paid in at least £1,000 each month to be eligible. Or alternatively you must be switching to Santander and transferring two direct debits or standing orders to the account as well as meeting the £1,000 funding requirement.

Rachel Robson highlights five of the worst airline rip-offs to watch out for...

But remember, if you do acquire a new flexible friend for your holidays, make sure you pay off the bill in full when it drops through your door – or you’ll be hit with interest charges.

Foreign friendly debit cards

If you don’t fancy getting hold of a new credit card for your overseas spend there are couple of current accounts lurking around that boast no charges on foreign transactions.

Santander has a zero current account which is completely fee free for purchases and cash withdrawals. But again this account is only available to existing customers who hold a mortgage, savings account (with over £10,000 in for at least three months) or current account. Existing current account customers must have at least two direct debits or standing orders set up and must pay £1,000 or more into the account every month.

Norwich and Peterborough Building Society also offer two cards that both charge no fees on currency exchanges, purchases or withdrawals – the Gold Classic and Gold Light accounts. To be eligible for the Classic account you must pay in £500 every month or foot a monthly bill of £5 while the Light account charges £5 per month if you make fewer than five transactions.

Pre-paid cards

An alternative to taking out a new bank account is to go for a pre-paid foreign currency card. These accounts allow you to top up the card online using your regular debit or credit card (but there is often a fee for topping up on credit) and then spend the balance while you’re abroad. In effect they work much like a debit card; however it is not linked to your current account and so is safer to manage while overseas.

What’s more, the top pre-paid currency cards around today will charge no fees for currency exchanges, purchases or cash withdrawals.

Here’s how the market leaders stack up on their specific currency card offerings – I’ve included the price in sterling (on 17 June 2011) for €500 and $500 to give you an idea of the exchange rates offered by each issuer.

Card and currencies offered

Price of currency card loaded with €500

Price of currency card loaded with $500

Minimum card deposit

Fees

Card cost/delivery

FairFX:

€, US $

£450.45

£314.96

€60, $75

No conversion of purchase fees, €1.50/$2 ATM fee, refund fee

Free card (for lovemoney.com readers who load £50 onto it) and free delivery.

CaxtonFX:

€, US $

£452.07

£316.45

€150, $200

No conversion, purchase or ATM fees, redemption fees (back to £) and domestic spend fees apply.

Free card and free delivery, £10 deposit when you apply – repayable when you load the card for the first time.

My Travel Cash:

€, US $

£456.16

£319.45

€30, $40

No conversion, purchase or ATM fees (1% cashback paid on purchases). Inactivity, dormancy and cancellations/ redemption fees apply.

Free card and free standard delivery or €6/$8 for express delivery (free over €800/$1000)

Travelex:

€, US $, Canadian $, Australian $, New Zealand $, S African Rand

£452.08

£319.08

£100

No conversion, purchase or ATM fees. Inactivity, overdraft and cashout to £ fees apply.

Free collection or £3.95 delivery for cards below £300, £1.95 above £300, free above £500

As you can see, FairFX offer the best exchange rates, but you will have to pay €1.50 or $2 a time to withdraw cash. The other three cards are completely fee free, save of a few small inactivity fees (if you leave your card dormant for over a year) and cashout fees (applied when you change any excess current back to sterling). My Travel Cash also offer 1% cashback on any purchases you make while overseas.

The providers listed above also offer global cards that can be used for transactions in any currency; however these accounts do all charge a conversion fee. FairFX charges a straight 1.4% in addition to a £1 fee per cash withdrawal, CaxtonFX levies a 2.5% conversion fee, My Travel Cash’s exchange charge is 2.99% and Travelex has a 1.49% fee.

And finally, if you do get hold of an overseas spending card, always remember to press the local currency option on ATMs and chip-and-pin handsets – not the sterling option. If you do choose sterling, then the local bank will handle the conversion, often at a rubbish exchange rate.

How do you pay when on holiday?

Do you use pre-paid cards on holiday? Or just stick to cash?

Let us know in the comment box below.

More: Compare overseas credit cards | Ryanair trumped by zero-fee airline | The best value flight ever!

Enjoyed this? Show it some love

Twitter
General

Comments (12)

  • electricblue
    Love rating 643
    electricblue said

    Much as I have a love hate relationship with Barclays, I think it is only fair to point out that if travelling in the USA there is a reciprocal arrangement with Bank of America so that there are no cash point fees when using a Barclays Visa Debit card. I also have a Bank of America account and the reciprocal arrangement of using my USA account card in the UK also works fine for me. Exchange rate calculations are not far off commercial rates so for once an area where Barclays are good value.

    Report on 21 June 2011  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • andrewjameshowar
    Love rating 25
    andrewjameshowar said

    The pre-paid cards are yet another move by banks to sell you stuff you don't actually need - in this case the foreign currency you don't spend and need to change back. Even with money-market exchange rates, the buy/sell spread is costly.

    The best way to get foreign currency without paying for bankers' holidays is to make early payments to your credit card. Don't wait for the statement but make ad hoc payments to the card as soon as you can. Consider putting the card into credit (you don't have much to lose at current interest rates) before going away, if you can get away with it, or getting on the internet whilst abroad to make payments from your bank account. Or do it as soon as you get back. 29% APR for a week is about half a per cent.

    Another tip - buy at Travelex with a buyback guarantee as your emergency cash stash then take it all back. This insurance costs less than £4.

    Report on 21 June 2011  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • dilbert999
    Love rating 8
    dilbert999 said

    Not available to everyone, but as we have a Spanish mortgage,we have a Spanish bank account, with Spanish credit card. No fees as long as it's paid in full every month, and usable throughout the euro-zone (though for how much longer is anyone's guess.... :-). We transfer money via a broker (Currency Index), and get near commercial exchange rates.

    Report on 21 June 2011  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • Mike10613
    Love rating 599
    Mike10613 said

    Or you could use old fashioned cash - get the foreign stuff from the Post Office - http://www2.postoffice.co.uk/travel/travel-money/foreign-currency

    Report on 21 June 2011  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • dennissm
    Love rating 0
    dennissm said

    Was in the Canaries at Easter and used my Nationwide Debit Card to withdraw cash. I found that the transaction was on a par with buying currency at home even with the 2% charge +£1. I guess the wholesale rate applied to such transactions makes up for the extra charges. Safer too than carrying wads of currency when travelling.

    Report on 21 June 2011  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • sodit
    Love rating 127
    sodit said

    I presume that all these surcharges apply to online purchases as well, so that when I buy in $ I have to pay an extra 3% for the privilege of doing so.

    Report on 21 June 2011  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • Colper44
    Love rating 0
    Colper44 said

    Forgive me for what might be a stupid question but I'm planning to give my son a pre-paid card for his post A Level trip to Greece and in the somewhat naive belief he may return with some balance on the card, I was wondering whether you can reclaim any unused balance ???!!

    Report on 22 June 2011  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • pbaxter
    Love rating 0
    pbaxter said

    @sodit Yes, these apply to purchases if you don't use a no 'foreign loading' card like those mentioned. I use Post Office Mastercard which has no loading or Nationwide Visa which has no loading in Europe I think.

    @Colper44 I have a FairFX card and you can withdraw an balnce in Stirling from a UK ATM but there is a fee for this. Ineviatably there will be a small amount left on the card that you can't get at because ATMs don't deal in small denominations. I don't know about the other prepaid cards.

    Report on 23 June 2011  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • jfconnors263
    Love rating 0
    jfconnors263 said

    I am travelling to Canada in September. I have a PO Mastercard for purchases. Is there a prepaid card I can use for cash withdrawals?

    Report on 23 June 2011  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • jscadden
    Love rating 16
    jscadden said

    I use a Cashplus pre-paid Mastercard for my domestic use. That also gives me a pre-paid Euro Mastercard and a pre-paid US Dollar Mastercard for free. Usuage, including atm withdrawals (atm owners may charge locally however), within the relevant currency areas is entirely free as is loading and unloading the cards to Sterling.

    Another benefit is that transactions show up immediately and can be checked online. There is also no mimimum top-up on any of the cards!

    Report on 23 June 2011  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • sqnldrjimbo
    Love rating 3
    sqnldrjimbo said

    If you are going to Spain and have a Santander account (that has a minimum of £1,000 per month paid into it) it's worth knowing that cash withdrawals from a Santander cashpoint are free.

    Report on 24 June 2011  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • The Bank Manager
    Love rating 72
    The Bank Manager said

    Cor Robert. I'm so happy you informed us of this, as your headline warned that if any of the bloggers should be spending £335m on a holiday this year (can you imagine what it will cost next year, taking into account inflation??), we ought not to make a mistake like this!

    Cheers mate....

    Report on 26 June 2011  |  Love thisLove  0 loves

Post a comment

Sign in or register to post a reply.

Our top deals

Credit card
company
Balance transfers rate and period Representative
APR
Apply
now

Barclaycard 27Mth Platinum Visa

0% for 27 months (3.5% fee) Representative 18.9% APR (variable) Apply
Representative example: assumed borrowing of £1,200, representative 18.9% APR (variable). Purchase rate 18.9% PA (variable). BT fee is reduced from 3.9% to 3.5% (T&Cs apply).

Barclaycard 25Mth Platinum Visa

0% for 25 months (2.4% fee) Representative 18.9% APR (variable) Apply
Representative example: assumed borrowing of £1,200, representative 18.9% APR (variable). Purchase rate 18.9% PA (variable). BT fee is reduced from 3.5% to 2.4% (T&Cs apply)

Virgin Money Credit Card MasterCard

0% for 26 months (2.99% fee) Representative 17.9% APR (variable) Apply
Representative example: assumed borrowing of £1,200, representative 17.9% APR (variable). Purchase rate 17.9% PA (variable).
W3C  Thank you for using CGWEBLIV1