The top eight biggest Christmas cons!

Cliff D'Arcy
by Lovemoney Staff Cliff D'Arcy on 14 December 2011  |  Comments 28 comments

As Christmas approaches and consumer spending becomes a whirlwind, we reveal the eight biggest ways to get taken for a ride -- but not in Santa's sleigh...

The top eight biggest Christmas cons!

At this time of the year, retail spending goes through the roof as the present-purchasing season gets underway once more. 

However, before you rush off to the shops (or your PC) to grab some gifts, have your wits about you. Otherwise, you could be a victim of these six Christmas cons (in A-Z order)!

1. Charity Christmas cards

Many of us buy charity Christmas cards believing that we're generously giving to good causes. Alas, charitable contributions from the sale of Christmas cards can be tiny. In fact, the donation can be as little as a few pence per pack of cards.

If you want to buy charity cards this Christmas, then check how much they cost per card and how much of the purchase price goes to the good cause. In many cases, retailers pass on, say, 10% or less of the retail price to charity, while keeping the lion's share of the profits. Indeed, a 'charity card' can donate as little as 2p in the pound (2%) to a good cause and still qualify.

Check out The worst charity Christmas cards for more.

2. Charity credit cards

Millions of Brits do their spending using donation credit cards. After opening one of these charitable accounts and using your card, a good cause gets an upfront donation of between £5 and £25, plus 0.25% of your yearly spending. In other words, if you spend £1,000 a year, then the ongoing donation will be just £2.50 a year.

I've never been a fan of charity credit cards, as it's easy to be far more generous. Instead of spending on a charity card, spend on a cashback credit card. Each year, donate your cashback reward (via Gift Aid) to your chosen charity. When you consider you can get 5% cashback (in the first three months at least) from the market-leading cashback card, you're looking at a far better return for your charity of choice.

Read New cashback card shakes up the market for a comprehensive guide to the cashback credit card market.

3. Extended warranties

If you're buying an electrical item as a present this Christmas, odds are you'll be asked at the till whether you'd like to buy an extended warranty.

These are rarely worth the money. You have a manufacturer's warranty for the first year and may be covered after that by your home insurance policy for accidental damage to items in the home.

If you do want to get an extended warranty, don't buy it from the retailer or the manufacturer. Instead, shop around online. 

4. London shopping

An investigation by the Daily Mail found that prices for popular goods could vary enormously depending on where in the UK they were bought.

In some cases, retailers were charging twice as much for the same item, depending on which branch shoppers visit. The Mail found that Londoners were paying much higher prices in some chains (such as WH Smith and Boots) than shoppers in other major cities, such as Bristol and Glasgow.

My advice to avoid this regional rip-off is simple: forget the high street. Instead, shop around online using price-comparison websites to find the lowest ticket price. Also, buying via cashback websites such as Quidco gives you cash rewards to reduce the cost even further.

5. Set Christmas menus

You know the drill. You turn up to the restaurant and instead of its normal two- or three-course option for £10 or £15, the cost has jumped to £19.95 or even more. For what? Often the options are broadly the same, with a turkey and Christmas pudding thrown in for good measure.

Bah humbug, I say!

6. Christmas trees

Every year, you buy one. And every year, just a few weeks later, you throw it away.

OK, so Christmas wouldn't be Christmas without it - or would it? Do you really need fork out on a Christmas tree to be able to spend quality time with your family, or to celebrate Christmas as a religious holiday?

Maybe it's all just a con dreamt up by the Norwegians to ship their firs around the world. In collusion with B&Q and garden centres everywhere, of course.

Either way, if you're going to shell out for one, at least remember to follow the lovemoney.com mantra: shop around, shop around, shop around! And if you can, recycle it afterwards. Many local councils now offer this service - have a look on recyclenow.com for details of the recycling services on offer in your postcode after Christmas.

7. Pre-sale prices

You buy it before Christmas, when it costs £80. By Boxing Day, it costs £40. By mid-January, it's £20. It's like the shops know we need to buy gifts by Christmas Day, or something.

The only way to avoid this rip-off is to keep receipts for everything you buy, and double-check all the prices when the sales start. As long as the items are in good condition and you've kept the original packaging, you can probably get away with returning anything that's dropped in price, and then simply buying it again at the sale price.

Just make sure you check the returns policy of the shop, as it's up to the shop to decide how much to refund you. However, if you bought the goods over the internet, you have the legal right to return the goods and get a full refund within seven days of receiving the goods.

Winner!

8. Travel insurance

My final seasonal rip-off is travel insurance. If you're planning to go away over Christmas, or hit the ski slopes in the New Year, then be sure to find the right policy to protect you while you're away.

Your goal is to find the right level of protection at a value-for-money price. Never be tempted by convenience into buying your insurance from a travel agent or tour operator, as these policies can cost up to ten times as much as a Best Buy!

Tell us what you think

What are the worst Christmas rip-offs, in your opinion? Please share your thoughts with other lovemoney.com readers using the comments box below.

This is a lovemoney.com classic article, updated for 2011.

More: Find a cracking credit card for 2012 | Top ten credit cards for Christmas

Enjoyed this? Show it some love

Twitter
General

Comments (28)

  • smashley113
    Love rating 0
    smashley113 said

    I have no problem spending more to be able to eat out on Christmas Day.

    People prepared to work that day should be rewarded (hopefully the staff are paid extra of course).

    Report on 14 December 2009  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • DrRob
    Love rating 0
    DrRob said

    Regarding Christmas Trees - get an artificial one that can be used year after year!

    Report on 14 December 2009  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • nickynoodle50
    Love rating 0
    nickynoodle50 said

    Just to comment on your point 7: Most shops have computerised pricing, so anything you take back will be credited back to you at the sale price. I have first-hand experience of this with an item that really did break, and then when I took it back, I was offered only the sale price. I argued my point, but was still offered a refund of only the sale price or exchange. I eventually opted for a replacement, as the article was sold out anyway, and this new stock came in at an even higher pice than the original.

    I am not sure that it is a good idea to promote what is in effect gross dishonesty in your readers, anyway.

    Report on 14 December 2009  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • jaynep1461
    Love rating 0
    jaynep1461 said

    nickynoodle50, if you do not have a receipt then the shop will only give you a refund at the sale price, but if you do have a reeipt they must give you back the price it says on the receipt, regardless of what the sale price is.

    Report on 14 December 2009  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • msmoneywise
    Love rating 27
    msmoneywise said

    Jaynep1461, nickynoodle50 is correct. Even with a receipt both M&S and WHS offered me only the sale price as a refund. They argued that as the product is now cheaper your refund is correspondingly less.

    Report on 14 December 2009  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • 27TOZZA
    Love rating 5
    27TOZZA said

    Smashley113 - like most non catering people - is sadly and blissfully unaware of the treatment of catering staff over the "festivities".

    I worked my first Christmas aged 17 in 1962 and most others up until I retired from the Restaurant/kitchen/hotel aged 55.I NEVER got any more than time and a half ( and that only when I worked for Whitbread )lieu days were few and far between,and tips - don`t make me laugh.............because of the hiked prices most people thought we were getting WELL paid so didn`t tip much,and then if it got past the manager/owner and the restaurant manager/head waiter - well we might get a few bob to split amongst 12 staff ( including dishwashers - without them we were nothing !! ).Please don`t think I am some disgruntled commis chef,I have a degree in Hospitality and Hotel management,Michelin status ( 3 times ) 2 Masterchef tickets and 40 years experience across the board.When I was a manager/Proprietor I ALWAYS made sure there were fair shares - the joys of learning the hard way - unlike many so called celebrity chefs today who are too wrapped up in their marketing to notice the "workers".

    Enjoy your hiked price meal and remember the little guys behind the scenes who,if they are lucky will get to go home about 6-00pm and have a quiet Christmas before returning for breakfast/lunch Boxing day.

    Report on 14 December 2009  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • nickynoodle50
    Love rating 0
    nickynoodle50 said

    @jaynep1461 - They don't even with the receipt - they would be fools to do it that way - wouldn't we all want to exchange goods we'd paid full price for.

    Report on 14 December 2009  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • Santa
    Love rating 9
    Santa said

    I think the point about Christmas menus refered to the run up to Christmas rather than the day itself.

    At the hotel where I worked a few years back it was great to work Christmas day. Sure it was hard work but everyone was in party mood and the atmosphere was great. Afterward we all sat down to our own (free) lunch and, since the meal price had included a 10% gratuity we all got an equal share of the kitty.

    Report on 14 December 2009  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • Donna Ferguson
    Love rating 130
    Donna Ferguson said

    Hi Nickynoodle, You're right, it depends on the individual shop's policy - have amended the article to reflect this. However, internet purchases differ - you have the legal right to a full refund for any item returned within 7 days, regardless of the price they're now selling it for. And if the item is defective, as it was in your case, you should have got a full refund - again The following articles may help clarify the situation for you:

    Know your online shopping rights 

    Your Rights To Refunds, Repairs And Replacements! 

    Hope that's useful

    Donna

    Report on 14 December 2009  |  Love thisLove  1 love
  • oldhenry
    Love rating 265
    oldhenry said

    Catering is the 'slave trade ' of the current age. If you are paying over the odds for a 'special' lunch- of Turkey( cheap as chips) and sprouts ( animal food) you are mental and are just helping the profiteers. Not me.

    Why does everyone go balmy at Christmas and spend for the sake of it?, have a good life all year round and , yes, meet family and friends but do not waste a vast sum of crap that they will send to a rummage sale - or even bin soon afterwards.

    Report on 14 December 2009  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • Arthurian
    Love rating 5
    Arthurian said

    When Following the 'Shop Around Mantra' it is VERY Annoyining that companies like Sony & Apple [IPOD] Enforce 'Retail Price maintenance.

    Set Items from their Ranges are at SET PRICES.

    So YOU have noticed too!!

    Report on 15 December 2009  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • georgea
    Love rating 1
    georgea said

    The higher prices in London stores are not really a rip-off - the simple fact is that the rents, rates, and property prices in London are much higher so to make the same profit on an item the stores have to charge more. The second problem is that you can get the goods cheaper elsewhere, but how much time and money is it going to cost to get the goods for the lower ticket price. You also have to consider that a lot of people move to the London area because salaries are higher so maybe that compensates.

    Perhaps the real rip-off is why the rates, rents, and property prices are so much higher - the average temperature in London is also a little higher but that is due to the high levels of pollution caused by so many people crammed into such a small area.

    Report on 15 December 2009  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • PigeonFancier
    Love rating 0
    PigeonFancier said

    just become Jehovah Witnesses and you can then save loads of money.... ha ha

    Report on 15 December 2009  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • MrPound
    Love rating 11
    MrPound said

    Christmas tress seem to have drastically jumped in price in the last few years. 5 years ago I remember paying £1 / foot for ours form a local farmer who grew them in a field. I can't seem to find anyone like this nowadays. Ours cost us £30 this year from a garden centre and even that was after "shopping around". I wish I'd taken advantage of the B&Q free Christmas tree (when you spend £30 in store) offer 2 weeks ago but the missus wanted to choose it herself and she was busy that weekend. Ho hum!

    We recycle ours every year by burning it on our fire. It smells lovely as well.

    Report on 15 December 2009  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • ses
    Love rating 0
    ses said

    Buy a tree in a pot and keep it for more than one year. Either leave it in the pot or plant it and dig it up the following year.

    Report on 15 December 2009  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • dilbert999
    Love rating 8
    dilbert999 said

    Re Extended Warranties

    A few years ago, I took out an extended warranty (through the shop) on a video recorder. It promised to pay back the premium if you didn't make a claim in 5 years. Had to go through a few hoops - register the insurance and get a claim form, then make sure you sent the claim form in within 28 days of the 5-year anniversary. I suppose they depend on a lot of people forgetting when the 5-year anniversary is up - plus getting 5 years' interest on your premium - to make their money. I forget the insurer's name, but IIRC, they were based in Weston-super-Mare. In my case, I kept good records, sent the claim form off on time, and got the premium back. Seems like a win-win - if the machine goes wrong, the repair gets paid for, if it doesn't, you get your premium back.

    Report on 16 December 2009  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • mambach
    Love rating 33
    mambach said

    When I rule the world, I'm going to have every store manager who advertises Christmas before the beginning of December, shot. (This year's first Xmas ads started on 5th October)

    It's been three months and I'm fed up, and can't wait for it to be over.

    We are a bit lucky in our local area as Eid is a much more sensible festival, and Hannukah has less commercialism too. But we still get the big chain store's obsession with this fake festival.

    Try this one - celebrate Yule.

    No tacky tinsel, no eating-the-environment light displays. Just a few leaves, a candle or two, and a feast of whatever-you-like-best-to-eat (pork is nice and relatively cheap for this). One day, and get back to normality. (we do forgo the traditional pyre-with-sacrifice, and encourage the sun to come back by cutting our carbon footprint instead)

    Oh and you don't give presents, you give largesse - only whatever you've got an excess of. For me, that ususally means time to listen to people's woes. Others in my circle over the years have grown vegetables, sewn cross-stitches, braided hair and mended computers.

    No spending more than you can, no hassle. Job done.

    Report on 17 December 2009  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • rustybrain
    Love rating 3
    rustybrain said

    There is a lot of confusion over Charity Christmas Cards. The most effective way of passing on a contribution to a charity is to buy dierctly from the charity.  Charities that sell Christmas cards directly to supporters (not all do) do so through their own wholly owned trading companies. The trading company then gifts ALL the profits to the parent company.

    Some charities supply temporary Christmas card shops with cards. They are usually charged a % of the sales and required to supply voluntary help with manning the 'shop'. this can vary from a very very small 1 or 2% levy to a failry hefty 25% ( such as is taken by Cards for Good Causes). The charity still has to buy and distribute the stock.

    The cards that are offered by major retailers, like M&S, Boots, Tesco etc which bear a charity acknowledgement are quite different. Here the charity has no involvement with the selection or purchase of the cards. They merely enter into a licencing agreement with the retailer, or in some cases the publisher, to use the charity logo. Retailers woke up some time ago to the fact that, all other things being equal. a card which bears a charity name sells better than one which doesn't. Also the cards that bear the name of a 'heart strings, charity will outsell those that feature a 'cinderalla' name. Many charities would bite the hands off any retailer that offered them such a deal - why not indeed. No effort, no stock risk and a nice fat cheque to look forward to.

    So if you really want to contribute to a particular charity, buy directly from them by mail order or at a one-day sale where the cards are offered by the charity volunteer supporters. If you just want to look good to the people on your Christmas card list buy them from a high street retailer.

    There is quite a good analysis of the situation on the Cards for Good Causes website http://www.cardsforcharity.co.uk/advice.htm What it doesn't really tell you is that you can buy directly from the charity (and not pay 25% to their organisation)

    Report on 21 December 2009  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • rustybrain
    Love rating 3
    rustybrain said

    Christmas Trees. Free to 'eco-warriors' .

    In some places the local wildlife trust or county council actively encourage people to help control 'invasive' pines on local heathlands. In return for cutting down these pines that are destroying the local habitat you get to take home a tree you have cut down yourself. You can't get fresher! Not only that but they don't drop needles either.

    When you have finished with the tree it can be put through a shredder and used as a mulch!

    Ticks all the boxes.

    Report on 21 December 2009  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • DrAwkwArD
    Love rating 1
    DrAwkwArD said

     Mambach:

    When I rule the world, I'm going to have every store manager who advertises Christmas before the beginning of December, shot. (This year's first Xmas ads started on 5th October)

    It's been three months and I'm fed up, and can't wait for it to be over.

    You've got my vote!

    Report on 27 December 2009  |  Love thisLove  1 love
  • thanet04
    Love rating 13
    thanet04 said

    Cliff I see you've made some changes to this classic article, and to yourself. According to the comments below it, you used to be called Donna!

    My pet hate is, as a single guy, I get penalised on restaurants doing eat-as-much as you like menues as they only apply to two or more customers. And don't get me started on holiday and travel costs.

    Report on 14 December 2011  |  Love thisLove  1 love
  • bubbly9852
    Love rating 0
    bubbly9852 said

    Same here thanet single supplements etc it is a rip off.

    Report on 14 December 2011  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • rbgos
    Love rating 81
    rbgos said

    I always buy my Christmas tree from the Forestry Commission - then, not only can I see and visit the forest it came from, but I know the money I give them will be used usefully. And it's no more expensive than anywhere else.

    Oh, and on charity Christmas cards, there's an easy way to ensure that ALL the profit goes to charity - buy the cards direct from a charity shop, not Tesco or WHSmith!

    Report on 15 December 2011  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • plainvanilla
    Love rating 16
    plainvanilla said

    Christmas - the most divine time in the Christian calendar - hijacked by big business to peddle any old tat.

    The church authorities should look at the fine print and see if they can sue anyone using the term Christmas without a proper license and to get them to cease and desist if they haven't. Could be a nice little earner for them if they could get sole rights to the name.

    Report on 15 December 2011  |  Love thisLove  1 love
  • oldhenry
    Love rating 265
    oldhenry said

    What a great recycled article, I was just as grumpy two years ago! I don't believe it.

    Well , little has improved in two years but inflation has soared and taken Christmas costs with it.

    Better to buy your decorations in the New Year sale and keep them in the attic. I have a fibre optic tree that is lit from the bottom and looks good. I have had it five years and one new lamp in that time so I'm doing well.

    The biggest cost of Christmas soon will be the gas/electricity to cook the meal.Goodness know what that loony Hune will do to us energy users next year.

    Report on 15 December 2011  |  Love thisLove  1 love
  • rosemary101
    Love rating 1
    rosemary101 said

    I agree about with oldhenry and the cost of fuel - it is disgraceful. But I also think food and general groceries are such a rip-off. Why are there no regulations with the supermarkets. Prices are getting to the point of being ludicrous and simple basic items are going through the roof - bread, butter or spread, cheese, milk, eggs etc. and toilette rolls are just rediculous. Fight back and only buy what you really need over Christmas!

    I see people shopping with trolleys so full I wonder :-/ A man behind one of these people said to the person in front of him on Saturday 'Are You Expecting A War!' Well, it does make you wonder ...

    Report on 18 December 2011  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • electricblue
    Love rating 643
    electricblue said

    Which 'fine print' would church authorities be looking at ? The biggest con is Christmas itself and the church leaders are disgustingly silent in the matter of commercialism. How many of those bleating on about the costs of Christmas have the spine to actually stand up against the commercial pressures and do things differently? Stop complaining about whoever is ripping you off at this time of the year and don't subscribe to it. Play the shops at their own game and pick up reduced items at the last minute. We know it's going to happen every year, which is also why you should buy your winter clothes in Spring and your Summer clothes in Autumn.

    Report on 19 December 2011  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • rustybrain
    Love rating 3
    rustybrain said

    I still agree with everything I said two years ago - see my previous comments.

    Report on 19 December 2011  |  Love thisLove  0 loves

Post a comment

Sign in or register to post a reply.

Our top deals

Credit card
company
Balance transfers rate and period Representative
APR
Apply
now

Barclaycard 27Mth Platinum Visa

0% for 27 months (3.5% fee) Representative 18.9% APR (variable) Apply
Representative example: assumed borrowing of £1,200, representative 18.9% APR (variable). Purchase rate 18.9% PA (variable). BT fee is reduced from 3.9% to 3.5% (T&Cs apply).

Barclaycard 25Mth Platinum Visa

0% for 25 months (2.4% fee) Representative 18.9% APR (variable) Apply
Representative example: assumed borrowing of £1,200, representative 18.9% APR (variable). Purchase rate 18.9% PA (variable). BT fee is reduced from 3.5% to 2.4% (T&Cs apply)

Halifax BT 25 Month MasterCard

0% for 25 months (2.5% fee) Representative 18.9% APR (variable) Apply
Representative example: assumed borrowing of £1,200, representative 18.9% APR (variable). Purchase rate 19.0% PA (variable).
W3C  Thank you for using CGWEBLIV3