Love to be the one to Grow your wealth?

Then register for free and get exclusive, personalised benefits that will help you achieve all your money goals.

Join the lovemoney.com experience

Register Now

Confused?

Why Register?

Savers stung by Tesco

Published 8 April 2009 in Grow your wealth

If you’ve opened a Tesco Internet Saver account this year, chances are it’s been a nightmare…

Back in January I decided it was time to reassess my savings. As I was being paid a pittance in interest on my Halifax account, I made the decision to switch savings accounts.

I didn't want to lock up my money for any period of time, so knew an instant access savings account was the best option for me. So after shopping around, I plumped for the Tesco Internet Saver account.

And why? Well, it was offering a very tasty interest rate of 6% AER (variable) which included a 1.5% bonus rate for one year - and I managed to apply just before the bonus was scrapped.

But my decision was also swayed by the following three things:

  • I would have instant access to my funds and there were no restrictions on the number of withdrawals I could make
  • I could open the account with just £1
  • The account would be online so I could access the account 24 hours a day, seven days a week - so I could check my balance, set up payments and transfer money.

Oh, and before I forget, according to the Tesco Personal Finance website, the account was also 'quick and easy to apply'.

Problem one - opening the account

Clearly with an account sounding this attractive in the current market, it was always going to be popular. And I know many lovemoney.com readers joined me in signing up for the account.

Admittedly, the Tesco Personal Finance website did warn customers there would be a delay opening the account because of the sheer volume of new applicants. However, I was assured I would still get my bonus, even though the bonus rate had been abolished by the time my application was processed. And Tesco has kept its word.

But in my opinion, the whole registration process was a nightmare and unnecessarily complicated. As I'm sure many of you know, you need a registration number and a customer number, and then you need to send off a signature, a cheque, and all sorts of other things. I'm not exactly sure why, but the whole process just seemed to take forever.

And once I had finally completed my registration, it still wouldn't log me on - I must have forgotten my password or something - and I had to start the entire registration process from scratch.

By this time I really was starting to tear my hair out (honestly, you should see it - it's much thinner than it was at the start of the year).

Anyway, just over a month after I had applied for the account, it was finally open and I successfully transferred some money into the account. I breathed a sigh of relief. It was finally sorted, or so I thought....

Problem two - the card reader

We've had complaints from several lovemoney.com readers about this next issue and I really do sympathise! Oh yes, having finally managed to put money into the account, many Tesco Internet Saver customers, including myself, are now trying to get over the hurdle of taking money out of the account.

Now I just want to remind you here that this account is supposed to be accessible 24 hours a day, seven days a week. So imagine my horror when I logged onto my account to discover I needed to order what's known as a 'card reader' to withdraw my funds.

Ok, it might not sound so bad - but I, like many other Tesco Internet Saver customers, have been waiting approximately two months for this device now. Although the card and PIN which are used in conjunction with the card reader have arrived, there's still no sign of the reader itself.

This card reader is a calculator-style device that's supposed to make your account extra secure - but surely it's not supposed to make it so secure that even the ACCOUNT HOLDER can't access the funds?

For several weeks now, the Tesco Personal Finance website has apologised about the delay, but there's been no indication of how much longer customers will have to wait.

So I, like many other customers, feel extremely frustrated right now. After all, in a climate where nothing is certain, being able to access your funds in case of an emergency is a top priority. And if you've opened up a new savings account believing you can access your money whenever you want, only to find you can't - well, quite frankly it's just not on.

Why the wait?

I've spoken to Tesco about this to find out what's going on. But it's as I expected - it's simply all been down to 'unprecedented demand' for the account.

Tesco claims it has 'significantly increased' its account handling resources and made customers aware from the start that there would be a delay in processing applications. Even so, there's no mention of the fact that once your application is processed you'll have to wait even longer for your card reader (at least not until your account is activated anyway).

On a slightly more positive note, I have been assured by a customer service representative that a new batch of card readers is on its way and should be in customers' hands by the middle of April - but let's face it, that's still a few weeks away.

However, if you do need to access your cash in the meantime, you can transfer money over the phone. Admittedly this is going to require some patience as you'll need to call up the Tesco personal finance helpline and you may have to wait.. and wait... and wait on hold. But do keep trying - I gave up on my first call after waiting for ten minutes, but I got through immediately on my second attempt.

That said, the helpline is only open 8am to 10pm Monday to Friday and 9am to 5pm Saturday and Sunday - so not the 24 hour service we were expecting. And of course, you'll be charged for the call.

Overall, I'm sure I'm not alone when I say that if I had my time again, I wouldn't be turning to Tesco to look after my savings. I think this has been a highly frustrating experience for many people. Let's just hope we will all be hearing the thump of a card reader on our doormats very soon.

If you've been affected by this, post your comments in the boxes below.

More: Why we're all starting to save | The best savings accounts for first time buyers

Enjoyed this? Show it some love

Share this lovemoney.com content on any of the social networks and utilities below by simply clicking the site of your choice.

  • You can subscribe to all lovemoney.com articles via our RSS feed.

Comments

  • 0 recommendations

Well that is Tesco for you generally a very greedy non-reactive organisation.

LastChip said

  • 0 recommendations

I hope they're not the same as the Nationwide examples. The screen is very difficult to read, the buttons appallingly small and how older folk get on with them, beggars belief.

I wouldn't argue they have cut crime rates and in that respect are tolerable, but they do need to become more user friendly.

peedee said

  • 0 recommendations

I'm deaf so being able to manage accounts online is important to me.  I found setting up my Tesco Internet Saver unnecessarily complicated and it's a longwinded job to log on.  I do have my card reader now but I've had to ring them to withdraw money and sometimes it's been difficult to hear what the recorded voice had been saying because it's not been clear.  However, I've been astonished at how quickly my money is transferred from my Tesco account to my nominated account - a matter of hours.

So, yes, it's been a frustrating experience, I really did expect better from Tesco but I'm satisfied now.

andy45fr said

  • 0 recommendations

And make sure you don't forget your password..... no button here to click for 'forgot your password', with an instant email providing it, or a new one. Oh no - you have to register again and WAIT for the snail mail to bring it to you in the post. Hardly what I call 'easy internet account'.

  • 0 recommendations

Tesco want to rule the world. Obviously the whole nightmare bank experience is because TESCO gets to keep and use the money; incredibly unprofessional and they should be sued for misleading advertising. I would never bank with a grocer, nor would I buy any other services from one. WALMART ,TESCO is not and never will be

smargetts said

  • 0 recommendations

Just to let you know if you have a card reader for any other bank then you can use this.  I have a Nationwide card reader and it worked fine.

Kezza said

  • 0 recommendations

I had exactly the same issues last week - I needed to get to my money to pay a builder, and then discovered the card reader issue...was a very stressful experience to say the least.

They were actually very helpful over the phone and I eventually had some of my money transferred, but I am now looking for another savings account as I'm not convinced the bonus is worth the stress - in the current climate having 24 hour access to money and being able to move it easily is more important than ever.

The site is clearly set up the same as RBS sites as they also use card readers and used to have a stake in Tesco finance....which makes me wonder if it was RBS who used to source the card readers for them, and now they're struggling to do it alone!!

Presumably all these problems mean Tesco are breaching our contracts in some way given we haven't got the 24 hour access we signed up for.....

Jonas said

  • 0 recommendations

Sadly my experience with the Tesco Internet Savings Account was similar to Rachel's, but the long winded registration and log-in did eventually work as expected and the initial interest rate at 6% with the bonus, currently at 3.25%, was worth a bit of work. The accrued interest was credited as expected at the end of March.

Andy45fr's experience with the log-in information caught me out as well on one occasion. I obviously mis-keyed something in the fairly extensive list of security data, and had to print out, sign and post a full re-registration request and then wait for the new log-in info. No big red error message and two further attempts with Tesco! Really rather unnecessarily pedantic I feel...

I have to admit that I didn't immediately deduce from the text on the website that one had to order a card reader. It seemed to suggest that one would be supplied, but when I tried to set up a linked account to withdraw funds the importance of the card reader came to light and I placed an order for one. A mid April delivery is what I have been quoted also, and fortunately that is OK for me. I have a card reader for a Barclays account and that works very well, offering good security confidence that is divorced from the PC.

peepobaby said

  • 0 recommendations

Well I think that this all works perfectly well and that they are currently paying an adequate interest rate (plus a healthy bonus to many customers) to compensate for any inconvenience there might be in waiting for a card reader to come.

  • 0 recommendations

I've been stung by this and complained to their customer services many times. Fortunately I don't need to withdraw from the account very often but having to phone for it is annoying.

I cannot believe Tesco feel that this card reader crap is a necessary security measure! I have had 4 or 5 genuinely INSTANT access internet savings accounts in the past and they never felt the need for it either. However, when I pointed this out to one of their so called 'customer service' reps she was adamant that it was an industry standard common practice - BULLSHINE!

Kirsty78 said

  • 0 recommendations

We opened our Tesco Internet Saver in November and had similar problems registering to use the account online. I had to send back 3 signatures before they finally sent me my log in details. Each time they said they must have been lost in the post.

Having read the forums recently, I was nervous about taking a lump sum out of the account. To be fair to Tesco I rang them last Sunday morning to transfer money out and it appeared in my current account 1 hour later!  Thank goodness they offer this on telephone banking as I don't really want to start going down the card reader route.

After all the coverage about this account, we will look to drip feed the rest of the money to a regular saver account instead. In my opinion, their competitive interest rate doesn't make up for the hassle factor!

  • 0 recommendations

I applied for this account on 2nd Jan. On the same day I applied for an ICICI account & a Nationwide Smart account for my son who has never had a personal bank account before. Felt smug - New Year Resolution sorted! ICICI were straightforward & easy, Nationwide was in action by mid-Feb even though we'd had to take a birth certificate into a branch as part of the process. Tesco 'lost' or didn't receive the signature I'd sent, then I got the letter about waiting for the card reader.

I think they offered a deal they later regretted, then made it all difficult & slow to stop too much money going into accounts at such good rates. If that's so, it worked in my case - my money came right out. I really don't want an account that doesn't work properly. Ing have got my Kaupthing money, and my Tesco money. They do appear to know how to run a bank.

matthew5 said

  • 0 recommendations

I don't have a Tesco account but do bank online with Barclays and Nationwide and the card readers each supplied can be read by the other. So you could try one other these...

grandmato4 said

  • 0 recommendations

I had all the problems above, including having to send my signature twice.  Why? It's an internet account, so when exactly do you need a signature???  I'm still waiting for the card reader, having waited for the card and PIN - and waited...and waited...

By the time the account would even let me in to look at my funds the interest rate had gone through the floor.  Not that Tesco had emailed me to tell me about that - as more responsible banks had done.  Could that be why it is taking so long to get money out - so they can hang on to it and pay pitiful rates?

Carol46 said

  • 0 recommendations

I'm just going through the registering process for the 2nd time.  I have no trouble with Tesco credit card which I pay on line every month.  I also have a Nationwide card reader and never have probs there.  Tempted just to give up on Tesco and close a/c

  • 0 recommendations

My wife opened an account. No mention of cardreaders at time of opening account. Instant access, what a joke.

Well we are not going to pay to ring them to get our money but as soon as the damned card reader arrives we will transfer the lot out. They have 5 grand of our money locked away!

Typical Tesco, rule the world ambitions, got their jackboots firmly on their suppliers necks too by all accounts.

We have had enough, stopped shopping there too now in protest.

Stickman said

  • 1 recommendation

I and my wife experianced all of the protracted process and precedures to set up Tesco savings accounts, with my wife having to re submit security details to allow access to her account. The need for a card reader also required the issue of a card and seperate pin number to complete the set to allow the the security procedut to be operated. we had opened the accounts to provide a temporary home for our Iceland ISA savings till the dust settled on the banking turmoil. We discovered the need for the card readers just befor we planned to go on holiday and we needed to move the cash to protect its ISA Status as we were not dueback til 2nd April.

We were refered to the telephone banking service, which till then we were not aware of, and managed to transfere the required funds, though the £10.000 daily limit was an added agravation reguiring the transactions to be diarised forward to allow completion.

I should add that as a longstanding RBS customer, since 1966, and familiar with their telephone and internet banking systems since inception, Tesco have not for once made best use of their former partnership with RBS technology and systems.

It does not bode well for the proposed Tesco Banks to be opened later this year.

Duxdeluxe said

  • 0 recommendations

Never really had a problem. The telephone banking has always been answered very rapidly and money transferred promptly. For me, at least, it did what it said on the tin

missflea said

  • 0 recommendations

I'm interested by the fact Tesco honoured the 1.5% bonus on your account when they haven't with mine as they received my application before the 8th January but did not process it till the 12th when the offer had ended. Also, completely agree that the registration process is the most comlpicated I have ever found on any financial product I have purchased. I have only just been able to access my account online after 3 months of trying. And this card reader business is completely new to me. I shall have to investigate that further.

  • 0 recommendations

I too tried to open an internet savings account with Tesco but after eight weeks and innumerable telephone calls, eventually gave up. I managed only to lodge my opening deposit and gain access to view the account in that period.  It was when Tesco then notified me of yet more "security" hoops to jump through before I could actually manage my account that I decided enough was enough (I'm obviously not as patient as some other contributors).  One strong letter of complaint and a demand for the return of my deposit resulted in my £5k (complete with full interest earned) being in my hand within two days, no apology, no acknowledgement of the problem, just a cheque with a Compliments Slip marked account closed. If Tesco can close an account as quickly as that then why not so for opening one - Maybe Warrior Princess is right.

Not sure about the suggestion of using another organisation's card reader. I applied for a Natwest eSaver account on the same day as applying for the Tesco account. Natwest had me up and running inside two weeks, complete with card reader, but that card reader did not function with my Tesco card - Still, worth a try however.

Savvy chic said

  • 0 recommendations

TESCO worries me in that it appears to want to take over the World. I did take out their Credit Card with 0% on purchases for 12 months - which, incidentally, I never saw the Fool recommending even though it was a better deal than Virgin which you were recommending as a Best Buy.

Anyway, I'm  almost afraid to say that appears to have been hassle free so far although I was surprised that they bank with The RB of S. That's on the Giro payment slip for the Card.

Nationwide customers need a Card Reader for making payments or transfers over the Net.

  • 0 recommendations

I opened my Tesco Internet Saver account on the 18 December and have yet to receive my card reader.

Does anybody have any information on how long the waiting times are ?

I agree with the comments that say how long winded it is to open an account but I managed to get the 1.5% bonus for a year and at the moment 3.25% isn't too bad - it makes up for all the hassle.

 

jamiemilne said

  • 0 recommendations

Having gone through the same pains as described in the article above, I reached the end of my tether today and closed my TPF account.  I won't be shopping there again in a hurry, either.

http://jamiemilne.wordpress.com/2009/04/10/tesco-impersonal-finance/

Holman said

  • 0 recommendations

I have no axe to grind either for or against Tesco.

I opened an account in October last year. They answered all of my questions about how Tesco was set up for banking. The account opened quickly. I was a bit put out when I first tried to get money out and realised that I had not got my card reader. But the alternative process - telephone -that Tesco have set up works very smoothly. And, amazingly, the money arrives the next day - something that no other bank can match (as far as I know).

The main plus is that the interest rate (while the bonus lasts) is a top rate.

In my experience, Tesco does an excellent job.

kenem said

  • 0 recommendations

Yes, thank you tesco for nothing, speaking for myself i can only agree that this internet account has and still is a nightmare. the card reader is still  at the manufacturers to whom tesco are blaming, obviously not a tesco problem,!!!! so the 24 hour a/c is not a 24 hour a/c and to move money costs money{tel; charges} Maybe the tesco bankers should join the likes of sir fred goodwin and all his sidekicks AT THE JOB CENTRE.

janevlowe said

  • 0 recommendations

I managed to open my Tesco savings account quickly and obtained the higher rate of interest, although I did have to chase up the card reader. Initially I too encountered problems logging in and had to phone the helpline. They told me to enter the site vie the main Tesco.com site which then worked. Since the first time I 've had no difficulty moving money AND it only takes about 24 hours to transfer to my current account - better than most!

So I'm very happy with the account. Seems I'm in the minority.

  • 0 recommendations

Dont use Tesco & after reading this, not sure I would. But with regards to the speed the funds transfer, this is down to banks signing up to Faster Payments. Not all are, but those that do, funds transfer on the same day, (working day that is) often less than 3 hours, so not really Tesco doing anything fancy.

  • 0 recommendations

I finally received my card reader over the weekend, so hopefully everyone else who has been waiting for weeks and weeks will receive theirs shortly.

Rachel (the author)

asdafan said

  • 0 recommendations

bit disappointed in this account and OF COURSE there has been a large drop in the interest rate since opening it (even with the 1.5% bonus).

didnt know I would need a card reader (which took ages to arrive) and I seem to be having problems with it. I shall have to have another look at it today but at the moment I cannot access my account with it.

I do not want to phone tesco to withdraw etc as my phone package does not support 0845 numbers.

I have a barclays card reader and no problems at all with that.

  • 0 recommendations

asdafan try 0800 Buster on  01229 330 800 and follow the prompts - it's a mobile version of say no to 0870, doesn't always work but worth a go.

asdafan said

  • 0 recommendations

abbeville boy - will try that.

have you registered with 18185 for cheaper 0845 etc calls? just google in 18185 and open an account. at least if you have to make the calls they are much cheaper that way.

any more tips very gratefully received.

cheers - asdafan

  • 0 recommendations

Hey - another rate drop from Tesco - happy Friday everyone!

asdafan said

  • 0 recommendations

I give up - the MPs needs seem to be greater than ours!

asdafan said

  • 0 recommendations

see tesco have just dropped their rates again! time to look elsewhere, I think ... but where?

Barney said

  • 0 recommendations

I have also experienced all these problems, and after opening a Tesco account in January, I have managed to withdrawal all my funds today.(20th June)  I am now the proud owner of a Card reader that I will never need to use again.  I am sure I am not alone, and I am wondering if there is some way of re-distributing these readers to the needy?

jamiemilne said

  • 0 recommendations

I've just blogged about an update to my post from April over here:  http://jamiemilne.wordpress.com/2009/07/17/tesco-can-i-help-you/

In short, my wife opened an account in early 2009 and is still waiting for a card and card reader.

However, instead of just moaning about it, I'd like to help Tesco sort out their process and systems.  Anyone know who I can speak to?

Join the conversation

Please sign in or register to add a comment or recommend.

Our top deals

Provider & account name AER/Gross Interest paid Apply
now

ING Direct (UK)
Savings Account

2.75% /
2.72%
Monthly Apply

Post Office®
Online Saver

2.75% /
2.75%
Yearly Apply

Santander
eSaver Issue 2

2.75% /
2.75%
Anniversary Apply
W3C  Thank you for using The Four Horsemen of the Apocalypse