Earn the top rate on savings from £1 to £25,000+

Jane Baker
by Lovemoney Staff Jane Baker on 13 October 2009  |  Comments 27 comments

Find out how you can earn the top rate on your savings, whether you're stashing away just £1 or more than £25,000.

This time last year, the top easy access savings accounts paid well over 6.5%, while the best fixed rate bonds offered 7% plus. Halve those rates and you'll be pretty close to where they stand now.

It's not much to write home about, is it?

In fairness, inflation is much lower today than it was back then, but many argue the official rate has very little to do with the real purchasing power of our savings.

So, when it comes to finding a home for your spare cash, you'll need to look harder than ever for a decent rate. With that in mind, here are my tops picks for all savers - whether you're putting away £1 or £25,000+.

£1+

Save what you can, when you can - even if it's only small amount to begin with. Remember, mighty oaks from little acorns grow!

If you're just starting out as a saver, you'll be pleased to hear many of the top easy access accounts can be opened with as little as £1.

Even the current market-leader, Citibank Flexible Saver Issue 6 only requires a £1 opening deposit. In return you'll earn a top rate of 3.3% AER!

Just bear in mind the rate includes a fixed bonus of 2.25%, which lasts for a year. Before the financial crisis stuck, bonuses really weren't worth giving a second thought. But with today's low rates, any account which guarantees a minimum return has got to be worth a closer look. So, with the Citibank Saver, you know you'll earn at least 2.25 per cent for the next 12 months.

After the bonus has disappeared, the rate will be cut to Citi's dismal standard variable rate. This is unlikely to be competitive given that it stands at just 1% today. So be prepared to switch your savings somewhere new as soon as the first year is up.

On the plus side, you'll get proper easy access with this account which means no notice and penalty-free withdrawals as often as you need them.

If you're already a Citi saver you won't qualify for this top rate. The next best choice for you is the ING Direct Savings Account. With this account you'll earn a competitive rate of 3.2% AER. But the great thing is this rate is guaranteed for a year. If Citi reduced the rate on the Flexible Saver by more than 0.1%, ING would have the edge.

Again you'll get true easy access and, like the Citi account, the rate will revert to a much lower standard variable rate which is currently just 0.5%. Note that this account isn't open to existing customers either and that money is protected by the Dutch Central Bank's Deposit Guarantee Scheme and not by the UK's Financial Services Compensation Scheme (the FSCS).

£500+

If you have a little more cash to save, you could earn a better rate by choosing a fixed rate bond. But this is only be a suitable choice for you if you can afford to lock your money up for a while.

You'll also need to consider what might happen to interest rates in the future. After all, if you're earning a fixed return, but the rates paid on variable accounts shoot up in a big way, you'll wish you'd given bonds a wide berth.   

To reduce the risk of getting stuck with an uncompetitive account, I suggest fixing your rate for no more than a year. If you have at least £500 to spare, you could earn a guaranteed rate of 3.7% with the Post Office One Year Growth Bond. 

All you need to do is decide whether an extra 0.40% over the top easy access account justifies having no access to your cash for a year.

I should point out here that you can earn higher rates if you're prepared to tie your cash up for longer. For example, if you choose a five-year bond, you can get 5.30% with Yorkshire Building Society on savings of £100 plus. But since there's no way of guaranteeing this rate will remain competitive over the longer-term, I prefer to stick with a short bond.

£1,000

If you have plenty to put away you might be hoping for better rates, but I'm afraid you're going to be disappointed. There are currently no preferential rates for savers with a few thousand in spare cash. But, on the plus side, all the accounts I've mentioned so far are also open to you.

£25,000

But there's better news for big savers. If you have a lump sum of at least £25,000 and you can afford to give three month's notice before taking any money out, you won't go far wrong with the Investec High 5 account.

With High 5 the rate you earn is always calculated as the average of the top five gross rates published by lovemoney.com partner, Moneyfacts.

The return is updated weekly to reflect the changing rates on the best buy easy access and notice accounts. But, right now, the account is paying 3.35% which beats both Citibank and ING.

This unique account is a real no-hassle option. You can always be confident you're getting a competitive rate without having to continually shop around. But, at the end of the day, you might only earn a small margin above the top easy access accounts which are open to all savers.  

Compare savings accounts at lovemoney.com

More: The top three savings accounts you should avoid | When a bonus isn't a bonus

Enjoyed this? Show it some love

Twitter
General

Comments (27)

  • Chorlton1
    Love rating 61
    Chorlton1 said

    That is a big gap to fill between £1000 and £25,000 a large percentage of savers probably fall into this bracket I know I am struggling to put my money into sufficient pots to gain a decent rate of interest and not all of this money can be risked on stocks and shares.

    Report on 13 October 2009  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • MrRee
    Love rating 65
    MrRee said

    I would be very wary about pushing ING Direct, or indeed any Bank who are not covered by the UK Compensation Scheme.

    Report on 13 October 2009  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • p1747
    Love rating 0
    p1747 said

    Whilst ING are not covered by the UK compensation scheme the Dutch compensation scheme covers investors up to 100 000 euros, about £90000.

    UK investors would be able to claim under this scheme.

    Unless anyone knows different

    Report on 13 October 2009  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • oldhenry
    Love rating 266
    oldhenry said

    Do you trust the Dutch Governmnt to cough up?, the British one would anyway if ING went bust.but I think the dUtch economy is more sound than ours. I see DSB went bust though, so the dust has not settled yet.

    Egg are owned by Citibank, so watch the level of investment there.

    Report on 13 October 2009  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • Snotmee
    Love rating 8
    Snotmee said

    Jane,

    Can you please clarify this issue. My understanding is that frozen assets from IceSave and Landsbanki were transferred by the UK Government to ING and guaranteed by the UK Government and the FSCS.

    http://www.ftadviser.com/FTAdviser/Investments/News/article/20081008/b6611f6e-9527-11dd-8351-00144f2af8e8/Icesave-deposits-safe-as-ING-steps-in-to-save-Heritable.jsp

    This does not square with claims above that "ING are not covered by the UK compensation scheme" ?

    In fact it makes no sense at all - as a consumer I assume that savings I hold in any bank, building society operating in the UK would be covered by the scheme and therefore are safe.

    I am confused !!

    Report on 13 October 2009  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • lo
    Love rating 0
    lo said

    I would like to know if its safe to put money in ING, as its the Dutch company who covers the 100k euros, how likely are British Citizens to lose money?

    City bank- is def NO NO, as it took me 20-30mins to speak to someone in India, also on money supermarket forum the feedback about City bank is bad.

    Report on 13 October 2009  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • kenem
    Love rating 0
    kenem said

    I agree with lo, after receiving my account details from citibank, they gave me a number to ring to activate my account i spent 1 hour and 5 minutes on the phone, no response!!! so bye bye citibank.

    Report on 13 October 2009  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • dspillett
    Love rating 2
    dspillett said

    @Chorlton1 - there is one other option between £1,000 and £25,000. I have an A&L "Premier Direct" current account that is paying 6% on up to £2,500. It will only pay this for the next ten months (the 6% is fixed for 12 months, after that it drops to something much smaller). So if you don't mind mucking about with an extra current account (you don't need to fuilly switch - I haven't and I seem to be getting the 6% rate, I'm just pumping my mortgage payment through it to keep the miniumu amounf going in, and back out, each month) it is worth signing up for while it still seems to be available (it was supposidly stopping last month IIRC, but it is still listed at http://www.alliance-leicester.co.uk/current-accounts/index.aspx). There is even a referral scheme so you can make a little extra out of them if any of your family/friends want to sign up too.

    Report on 13 October 2009  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • fenemore
    Love rating 205
    fenemore said

    I have said it before many times - why do we have to risk our savings in foreign owned banks to get a decent rate? Surely it is not beyond the wit of British banks to offer similar rates?

    The teaser rates offered by A&L (another foreign owned bank) of 6% on a poultry £2.5k is an insult. Capped at that amount means for them, it is a loss-leader, hoping that at the end of 12 months you will stay with them.

    As for Citi - not worth getting out of bed for.

    I wish lovemoney would publish a list of British owned instutions that are wholly based here - including call centres.   

    Report on 13 October 2009  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • MrRee
    Love rating 65
    MrRee said

    Do the LoveMoney contributotrs live in the same world as the rest of us?

    They bang on about INGDirect, like they did about ICESAVE and Kaupthing Edge!

    There was an excuse for the Icelandic recommendations, as a melt down had never happened ... and, of course, Iceland backed the deposits (like the Dutch Bank in the case of INGDirect) ...... but, there is absolutely NO excuse at all for recommending a Foreign Bank after we saw the the Icelandic Government leave the UK Investors high and dry!

    It's not as if INGDirect treat their customers well either, is it? If you are an existing customer then you can forget all about good rates of Interest.

    As for CITIBANK - I have a new account, tried to activate it, waited for ages on the phone - no answer!!! Sorry, no answer, then no investment from me! Also look at the CITIBANK reviews on the internet ...... still want to put your money there? Thought not!

    So, come on Lovemoney contributors - start telling it as it is and stand up for us mere mortals!!

    Recommend a standard rate, without Bonus, in a UK Bank .... and forget about headline grabbing rates from foreign banks and those that don't even answer the phone!

    Report on 13 October 2009  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • keeping-it-real
    Love rating 4
    keeping-it-real said

    Personally I wouldnt put any savings into ING for the plain and

    simple reason that you can get a FSCS backed account offering just over

    3% (Egg, A&L etc), so why bother risking it.

    There are also a couple of great 2 year fixed rate bonds on the

    market ,offering over 4%, which allow access to your funds with a

    penalty. I see these as the best way forward if you can afford to

    leave it there.

    Report on 13 October 2009  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • Mr Logic
    Love rating 3
    Mr Logic said

    Why no mention of Barnsley BS who do a fixed rate bond for 3 yrs at 4.7%? You've also got the extra confidence of mutuality, so no greedy shareholders to appease. If 3 yrs is too long Kent Reliance do 2yrs at 4.25%

    Report on 13 October 2009  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • brian100
    Love rating 0
    brian100 said

    I tried citibank, got to the paying in stage, and was told that despite their inrtoductory letter saying that a payment from my BankCard would be accepted, they refused to do so, saying that I had to p[ay by cheque !!! I wonder how much they are making on that little game. Like everybody else I say leave well alone.

    Brian.

    Report on 13 October 2009  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • MalcolmS60
    Love rating 8
    MalcolmS60 said

    I can't understand why nobody ever mentions the Vantage Accounts with LloydsTSB. As long a syou pay in £1000/month(there's nothing to stop you transferring it back out again) and if you keep between £5000 - £7000 in the account, they are paying 4%. I have several Vantage accounts, each with around £6000 in, and transfer the £1000 between them by Standing Order each month. The money is earning good (by today's standards) interest, and is available instantly if required.

    Report on 13 October 2009  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • sortyourselfout
    Love rating 0
    sortyourselfout said

    ive recently invested with ing direct. Really wasnt sure if I was doing the right thing but went for it knowing that my savings would be covered, allbeit, by the dutch government compensation scheme. Its one of the best paying interest rates going at the mo and fixed for 12 months,,,,, however the Birmingham Midshires are doing a telephone extra account earning 3.15 % interest (part of which includes a bonus) so am fairly tempted by this. Either way, at the end of 12 months Ing direct's interest rate drops right down, and so would Birmingham Midshires at the end of the 12 month bonus period. So either way, in 12 months I shall be on the move again !!!! Who would have thought savings could be such a complex matter !!!!!

    Report on 13 October 2009  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • sortyourselfout
    Love rating 0
    sortyourselfout said

    Thank you Malcolm for that very useful information on the Lloyds Vantage account. Very interesting. So, assume I open 2 accounts and place,, lets say £20k in each, I could just set up a standing order to transfer £1,000 monthly from one to the other, and in return earn 4% interest ??? It sounds too good to be true ??

    Report on 13 October 2009  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • dspillett
    Love rating 2
    dspillett said

    @fenemore - A&L may now be foreign owned, but they are still a properly registered UK banking entity and so are covered by the relevant protections. Of course, any profit made goes to the foreign body in some way shape or form but if (like you say) this is a loss leader, they are not going to be making any profit on holding a chunk of my funds for a year (I currently have no plans to plan to leave FD for my day-to-day banking despite the 0% current account interest rate). And I don't know about you, but with the total size of my current funds £2,500 isn't all that poultry!

    Report on 13 October 2009  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • L&N
    Love rating 0
    L&N said

    I agree with MrRee lets forget the headline grabbing rates. We want a Uk based bank/ building society with reasonable rates preferably without the bonus.

    Anither thing that really anoys me about fixed rate accounts is that everyone recommends only tying money up for 1 - 2 years but then they print the best buy tables and all of these are 4 or 5 year deals. Why not print a table of the 1 -2 year deals so that we can compare like with like.

    Report on 13 October 2009  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • grumpyone
    Love rating 0
    grumpyone said

    What about the current offers from NS&I,they are offering 4.45% for two years

    Report on 14 October 2009  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • jacky007
    Love rating 7
    jacky007 said

    Does anyone know anything about the Barnsley B S which has a good % for 1,2,3 and 4 year Bonds?

    Report on 14 October 2009  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • jacky007
    Love rating 7
    jacky007 said

    Grumpyone, where did you find NS&I @ 4.45%? I've looked through their site, but can't find anything as good as that!

    Report on 14 October 2009  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • fenemore
    Love rating 205
    fenemore said

    dspillett - Regaarding A&L, I was expressing despair at yet another British insitution falling into foreign hands. It seems to me that it is always Great Britain for sale to anyone and everyone.

    I don't think A&L are expecting to make any money out of the first year - but for everyone who moves their cash at the end of the year, others will find it too much trouble and just stick with it - it is these that will generate their profit.

    Regarding your comments about £2.5k - I acknowledge that some people consider that sum to be significant, but ask yourself what you can buy for that these days? Maybe 1% of a house, possibly 10% of a new car or even 100% of a family holiday. Not a lot is it? It wasn't so many years ago that such a figure could purchase a top of the range brand new vehicle - now it barely covers 1 years council tax. 

    Report on 14 October 2009  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • executor21
    Love rating 2
    executor21 said

    Pardon me for talking turkey (ie getting straight to the point) but I think you mean PALTRY not poultry!

    Report on 15 October 2009  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • Jane Baker
    Love rating 5
    Jane Baker said

    There have been several comments on how deposits held in the ING Savings Account are protected.

    So, to clarify the situation, money is protected by the Dutch Central Bank's Deposit Guarantee Scheme and not by the UK's Financial Services Compensation Scheme (the FSCS).

    Compensation under the Dutch scheme is limited to the first €100,000 of total deposits held with ING.

    Some of you have drawn parallels with Icesave and the failure of foreign compensation schemes. Remember that all UK savers were eventually compensated following the collapse. And, although this situation was far from ideal, no savers suffered financial loss.

    Of course, you may not feel comfortable choosing account which is covered by a foreign scheme rather than the FSCS. That decision is yours, but here at lovemoney.com, we want to make you aware of the best rates available on all savings accounts, even if they are offered by foreign banks.

    Hope that helps.

    Jane Baker (the author)

    Report on 16 October 2009  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • MrRee
    Love rating 65
    MrRee said

    No-one suffered financial loss, that is correct - but only because the UK Government stepped in to pay. They may not do so again!

    Plenty of charities were left high and dry, plus some people offshore - there were casualties in the Icelandic crash.

    The comments above are to serve as a warning about Foreign Banks with Foreign Government Guarantees, from people who suffered sleepless nights when the Icelandic Government proved that a Foreign Guarantee may not be worth the paper it's written on.

    Looking at the raw data of how much you gain chasing 0.2% I would suggest is not worth the risk of losing your life savings.

    0.2% Gross on £10,000 is 38p a week, subject to Tax, of course. If that, to you, is worth the risk - then go ahead - trust that a foreign bank will have any desire to pay compensation to non-residential investors. It will cost a LOT more than that to make me risk sleepless nights again!

    Report on 16 October 2009  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • The Crofter
    Love rating 0
    The Crofter said

    Citibank has taken some knocks in the comments here. For my own part I registered, got a card, activated it (2minutes), registred for online banking and away I went.

    Great rate for short term deposits with no strings attached.

    There are far worse outfits out there this one seems OK to me.

    Report on 22 October 2009  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • MrRee
    Love rating 65
    MrRee said

    The Crofter, congratulations on your success.

    I hope the reviews about CITIBANK are over harsh if you have any problems - keep us posted.

    As for ING - I see that a paper was running an article recently that they are to be broken up? Like I said above - be VERY careful where you put your money!

    Report on 27 October 2009  |  Love thisLove  0 loves

Post a comment

Sign in or register to post a reply.

Our top deals

Provider & account name AER/Gross Interest paid Apply
now

Aldermore
1 Year Fixed Rate Account

1.85% /
1.85%
On Maturity Apply

Derbyshire BS
Derbyshire NetSaver Issue 11

1.70% /
1.70%
Yearly Apply

Nationwide BS
MySave Online Plus

1.70% /
1.69%
Monthly Apply
W3C  Thank you for using CGWEBLIV2