The best supermarket financial products

Neil Faulkner
by Lovemoney Staff Neil Faulkner on 02 May 2012  |  Comments 6 comments

Going with a financial deal from your supermarket could leave you considerably better off.

The best supermarket financial products

Tesco and Sainsbury's are encroaching more and more into selling us financial products, from savings to loans to insurance.

They haven't got tangled up in the messy, complicated business that has recently destroyed several of the UK's banks and building societies. As a result, they continue to offer many better products and take more customers away from traditional financial institutions.

Savings accounts

Just last week, Tesco increased some of its savings rates further to ensure it stays at the top of the best buy tables.

The top one-year fixed rate savings accounts

Savings account

Interest rate

Minimum deposit

Tesco Bank 1 Year Fixed Rate Saver

3.5%

£2,000

United National Bank 1 Year Fixed Deposit Account

3.45%

£2,000.00

Aldermore 1 Year Fixed Rate Savings Account

3.35%

£1,000.00

I have excluded accounts that are not online, but none of those beat Tesco anyway.

None of these top three savings accounts come from renowned financial institutions, which is a demonstration of how poorly the major banks are able to compete right now. As we now know, being with a big bank doesn't make you all that much safer.

Savings in all three accounts in the above table are protected by the Government in the Financial Services Compensation Scheme. Tens of thousands of pounds of your savings could be protected by the guarantee offered by the scheme.

Credit cards for new purchases and balance transfers

Sainsbury's narrowly misses out on being in the top five credit cards for both balance transfers and new purchases.

The Sainsbury's Shopper card offering 12 months at zero interest on both types of borrowing is some way off from the Nationwide Select card. The latter offers 17 months on balance transfers (3% fee) and 18 months on purchases. However, you have to open a whole new bank account to get the Nationwide account, which is more effort than some people are willing to make.

You can see the best credit cards for dual deals in my article from last week: How to use credit cards for transfers and new purchases.

Credit cards for new purchases only

But when it comes to credit cards that offer 0% interest on new purchases only, Tesco and Sainsbury's peform again, coming joint second:

The top credit cards for new purchases

Credit card

Length of 0% deal on new purchases

Nationwide Select

18 months

Halifax/Bank of Scotland All-in-One

15 months

Sainsbury's Nectar Credit Card

15 months

M&S (HSBC) Credit Card

15 months

Tesco Clubcard Credit Card

15 months

Personal loans

Tesco makes it into the top five on personal loans.

Top five personal loans for those with excellent credit ratings

Personal loan

Interest rate*

Clydesdale Bank Personal Loan

6% APR

Derbyshire Personal Loan

6% APR

M&S (HSBC) Personal Loan

6% APR

Tesco Bank Personal Loan

6.1% APR

Sainsbury's Personal Loan

6.1% APR

*Half of applicants will get a higher interest rate than the one advertised.

With all these loans, if you borrow £7,500, you're looking at repaying around £145 per month for five years, so at least £1,140 in interest. Be sure that you need to borrow, because that £1,000+ could be useful to you.

It's worth noting though that if you go for a £7,500 loan over three years, the interest rate on a loan from Sainsbury's drops below 6%. For more read this article.

Car insurance

Supermarkets are also competing with insurers.

It's difficult to make any generalisations about who's the cheapest insurer. However, I have run a few tests and found that on car insurance at least, Sainsbury's does pretty well against the competition, provided you have a Nectar card and use it often.

You might be entitled to a 20% additional discount (up from 15% a few months ago) on a policy that is already reasonably cheap for some people. Read more in Sainsbury's promising £300 of benefits with its car insurance.

But everyone is different, and Sainsbury's will not be competitive for everyone, so there is no substitute to shopping around for your car insurance.

More on savings and credit cards:

How to use credit cards for transfers and new purchases

The best money transfer credit cards

Banking gimmicks are no bad thing

How to build an excellent credit history

Enjoyed this? Show it some love

Twitter
General

Comments (6)

  • babyhk
    Love rating 8
    babyhk said

    Some of us would find £2k a bit steep to invest in a lump sum . Try Cheshire Reg Saver which pays 5% until May 2013 and will allow 1 withdrawal . Save between £100 and £500 per calendar month or min deposits of £100 . Good if saving for next years ISA.

    Report on 02 May 2012  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • trolleyfan
    Love rating 2
    trolleyfan said

    I have held a Tesco Instant Access account for many years and enjoyed good service but that seems to have fallen apart in recent months since becoming Tesco Bank. As a result I am transferring all my income into First Direct after Tesco's lost 6 payments in.

    Report on 04 May 2012  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • MikeGG1
    Love rating 881
    MikeGG1 said

    Babyhk

    The Cheshire account (Platinum Monthly Saver 3) can only be opened or operated via a branch. Not much use for most of us.

    Mike

    Report on 06 May 2012  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • Mike10613
    Love rating 600
    Mike10613 said

    3.5% with Tesco, you would make a better return stocking up your freezer and food cupboard with food; this time next year when inflation and quantitative easing have taken their toll you might find you can afford to eat. You can also invest in second class postage stamps...

    Report on 08 May 2012  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • orangecat
    Love rating 5
    orangecat said

    Would love to trust Tesco with my savings, but after all the forum write-up's I have read on the pathetic service their Banking system creats, with tons of logging in problems. I think it would be wise to give them a wide berth?

    Orangecat

    Report on 08 May 2012  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • Grobbendonk
    Love rating 27
    Grobbendonk said

    I've not lost actual money by banking with Tesco, but their systems really are so bad, the cost of my time trying to sort out their mistakes definitely pushes them into the "do not use" category.

    Last estimate was around 12 hours to get most of it fixed and I've still got £200 they don't seem to be able to return to me (although I am still earning interest). Even pricing those 12 hours at minimum wage, I've made a loss.

    Don't touch them with a bargepole, unless they've sorted out their authentication systems, account integration and, well, everything.

    Report on 08 May 2012  |  Love thisLove  0 loves

Post a comment

Sign in or register to post a reply.

Our top deals

Provider & account name AER/Gross Interest paid Apply
now

Derbyshire BS
Derbyshire NetSaver Issue 11

1.70% /
1.70%
Yearly Apply

Nationwide BS
MySave Online Plus

1.70% /
1.69%
Monthly Apply

ICICI Bank UK
HiSAVE SuperSavings Online Account

1.75% /
1.74%
Monthly Apply
W3C  Thank you for using CGWEBLIV2