The UK's favourite shop

Robert Powell
by Lovemoney Staff Robert Powell on 06 May 2012  |  Comments 22 comments

Robert Powell looks at new research outlining the nation's favourite retailer.

The UK's favourite shop

10% of Europeans are conceived in beds made by a company that was founded by a 17-year old. Now there’s a sentence I bet you didn’t think you would read today.

The company I am referring to is, of course, the world’s largest furniture retailer: IKEA. But the flatpack giant doesn’t just excel in size. It has now also been named the UK’s favourite shop – beating something of a British institution to snatch first place.

Nation’s favourite shop

Yes, IKEA has been crowned the nation’s favourite retailer, following a survey of 6,000 people carried out by Verdict Research. Last year’s winner, John Lewis, ended up in third place. Affordable womenswear chain Bonmarche emerged in second.

IKEA, a Swedish-owned company founded in 1943 by 17-year old Ingvar Kamprad, came second in the poll last year. However Verdict said that the chain's move to the top of the survey reflected its continued strength at a time when many consumers were cutting back.

Maureen Hinton, Practice Leader at Verdict, said: “[IKEA] has an extensive, stylish, range at attractive prices and with the majority of consumers on a tight budget it has something for everyone wanting to brighten up their home”.

Clothing retailer Bonmarche was lauded by shoppers for the range and quality of its stock, beating stores like Topshop, H&M and Next. Verdict said the chain had excelled in the poll due to the high level of service it provided to a relatively niche market of mature women.

John Lewis came in third place and won the individual poll for service. The retailer also emerged second for the quality of its goods.

The fall of John Lewis and rise of IKEA from the top spot could indeed be seen as a sign of the austere times. IKEA is famous for its reasonably priced, stylish furniture. However customer service is often described as sparse, to put it mildly. On the other hand, John Lewis – a partnership department store with the mantra of ‘never knowingly undersold’ – is well known for its thorough in-store attention.

Sector polls

Verdict also put together a rundown of the nation’s favourite companies by sector. Here are the full results:

Sector

Top retailer

Second retailer

Third retailer

Clothing

Bonmarche

H&M

Marks & Spencer

DIY

Wilkinson

B&Q

Wickes

Footwear

Asda

M&S

JJB Sports

Food & grocery

Waitrose

Asda

Morrisons

Entertainment

Play.com

Amazon

Asda

Personal care

Asda

Morrisons

Boots

Homewares

IKEA

M&S

John Lewis

Electricals

John Lewis

Amazon

Comet

So as you can see, the three overall winners – IKEA, Bonmarche and John Lewis – are top of homewares, clothing and electricals respectively. Also dominating the three categories are Marks & Spencer, Amazon, H&M and Comet.

Online retailer play.com comes out top for entertainment. The store also came in fourth place in the overall poll. Amazon follows in the entertainment rundown.

Both play.com and Amazon are Channel Island-based companies. This allows them to ship products under the price of £18 to the mainland without having to pay VAT, undercutting high street stores. Or it did. Changes brought in by the coalition abolished the Low Value Consignment Relief loophole that forms the cornerstone of the business model used by online entertainment retailers. Indeed, it will be interesting to see how online stores like play.com and Amazon score in next year’s poll.

Turning to the food and grocery sector, a somewhat surprising store emerges as the public’s pick – considering the importance price played in deciding other winners. Yes, high-end chain Waitrose comes out top, followed by the more budget supermarkets Asda and Morrisons. Asda also tops the poll for personal care stores, ahead of Morrisons and Boots and value retailer Wilkinson comes out first for DIY.

Your favourite store

Do you agree with the results? Does IKEA win out over John Lewis for you?

Let us know using the comment box below.

More: Tesco launches online marketplace to rival Amazon | Voucher codes leave you worse off! | Why I'm boycotting Amazon and where I'm going instead

Enjoyed this? Show it some love

Twitter
General

Comments (22)

  • Mike10613
    Love rating 600
    Mike10613 said

    You would have to pay me to use Ikea. They had a sale on the last bank holiday that cause traffic jams and a tailback went up the slip road of junction 9 on the M6. How irresponsible can you get, to keep putting profit before road safety? I suppose we have the same chaos again on the May Day bank holiday as they relieve those with more money than sense, of the money they have made sitting behind desks pretending to do something useful.

    The bloody sun is shining now. That will bring the credit card crowds out. Let's hope it rains persistently on Monday; it is a Bank Holiday after all. Bugger the Swedish, lets keep our Bank holiday traditions; let it pour!

    Report on 06 May 2012  |  Love thisLove  1 love
  • Tumbleweeed
    Love rating 22
    Tumbleweeed said

    I went round Ikea once...hated the whole experience!! It didnt seem to be a very friendly shop, you couldnt find the box with the thing you wanted to buy easily and it was stupidly busy.

    Everybody raves about the bloody place I know but I enjoy the whole shopping experience when buying something for my home, Ikea makes you feel like you are on conveyor belt. Maybe theyve changed since I last went!!

    Report on 06 May 2012  |  Love thisLove  1 love
  • marram
    Love rating 46
    marram said

    I always hated IKEA too, thought their stuff was cheap-looking and too lacking in style - that was when they first opened. I would never even consider IKEA as a place to buy for the home.

    On the other hand, i had a personal account at a shop called Trewins which was a bit like Grace Brothers, even used to offer cups of coffee when trying on clothes or looking at furniture, and used to change cheques for cash for account holders (in the days before cashpoints were everywhere). Then they were taken over by John Lewis. The coffee disappeared (unless you spent a fortune in their cafe), they stopped cashing cheques, and then moved to a large shopping mall. at that point they stopped tryng to help you no matter what. I once asked if they could get hold of a certain item of furniture for me, which they had always stocked. No. I pointed out that I had been an account holder for 30 years, and they had always been very helpful in the past. I was told that in this shopping centre there was a large amount of 'passing trade'. I asked point blank if she was trying to say 'plenty more fish in the sea'? yes!

    I closed my John Lewis account and have never been back since. So much for customer service.

    Report on 06 May 2012  |  Love thisLove  1 love
  • laidbackcyclist
    Love rating 3
    laidbackcyclist said

    Went once - never again! Crowded noisy conveyor belt with no escape until you had been through the whole store. Probably the worst store shopping experience I've ever had.

    Report on 06 May 2012  |  Love thisLove  3 loves
  • gardener
    Love rating 25
    gardener said

    I have been to John Lewis once and I felt judged and pressured, never been back. Ikea has been great for childproof and adaptable furniture, but you must know which ones are good (Ivar, Anneberg & Sten) and which ones will soon fall apart. Having said that they have never been difficult about giving my money back and the children still love going there (grown up now!). Pick your time & day and you can have a chilled time. M&S is great; great service & products and I especially like the fact it is not very young and disinterested teenagers serving me but a wide range of people who all seem to excel at being helpful and friendly!

    Report on 06 May 2012  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • culluding-fool
    Love rating 49
    culluding-fool said

    I don't like the way Ikea is laid out to force me to walk around to whole shop but I did buy a very good baby cot for £25 which was less than I could find second hand at the time (2007), but I haven't been back there since. I've never been in a John Lewis. M&S have recently moved to our area and do have excellent service. Surprised Asda is top for footwear. I used to buy all our shoes at Stead and Simpson before they closed down. They had a good service and the shoes lasted well, especially my daughters school shoes.

    Report on 06 May 2012  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • newf317
    Love rating 0
    newf317 said

    IKEA can be horrendous at weekends and in school holidays - long queues - everything taking ages. Have tried cutting short the conveyor belt in a new store and promptly got lost so now when needs must only go when the store is likely to be quiet and just whizz past everything I'm not interested in. Some of the stuff they sell is just absolute rubbish but like gardener says - if you know which are the good ones - you can get something very good for an excellent price. Lewis's is in a different league. My local Solihull store is great - no pressure from staff, helpful when required - I'm not surprised they did so well on service. I bought a rogue washing machine from them - on offer. They replaced it with a better more expensive model that cost £100 more but only asked me to pay an extra £50 (the discount on the original machine) I could have had the machine replaced for free if I'd opted for the same model but reverted back to my favourite brand machine instead. On price - Lewis's stacks up there too - bought a hand mixer there yesterday after checking online prices - better than online too.

    Women's clothing - I guess it depends on what you're looking for ... Have been into Bonmarche and H&M but made a quick exit. If your priorities lie with quality and value then M&S take a lot of beating. Their ranges are much trendier (Per Una) than they used to be and they seem to have moved away from purely being the shop of choice for the mature woman. As for underwear ... I'm sure I read somewhere that more women wear M&S undies than any other brand.

    Having recently been involved with a lot of building / renovation work have found myself visiting all of the named DIY stores and in my opinion B&Q is by far the best all round. Wickes does carry stuff that B&Q doesn't but overall have a smaller range. I used to like Homebase but frankly if you are doing anything more serious than a bit of minor work involving paint etc you are wasting time going there. They have a cutting service that's lamentable - half the time it's unmanned - staff having to be called .. Or it's their day off and no one else in store is trained to use the equipment. I drive an extra 3 miles instead to B&Q. The only Wilkinson in my area is rubbish ... less said!

    I buy lots of stuff online and I guess like others who shop this way am a demon for getting the best price - but will pay a bit more if the only choices include unknown / unrated suppliers. I'm an Amazon Prime member and do get a lot of books and media through them - and must admit that they go overkill on the packaging (as highlighted recently in a Watchdog programme) Perhaps they'll have to cut back on this waste if they are to continue to compete with the VAT changes.

    We shop in Sainsbury's. We have all the usual range of supermarkets fairly close apart from Waitrose. I have found over the years that the quality of a Sainsbury's store varies according to its catchment area. I used to work in a fairly poor area and the Sainsbury's in that area had a much more limited range of goods than the store nearest to where I live - which serves a much more affluent area. Quality and value are important as well as overall shopping experience / service etc. I really like M&S food because the quality is excellent - but the prices put me off. I'm surprised Waitrose did so well - like M&S quality is great but prices aren't competitive. Our local Morrisons is ok but fresh fruit and veg isn't a patch on Sainsbury's and the same applies to Tesco ( a store my other half hates and won't go in unless under sufferance). Asda is cheap (I had a summer job as student some years ago in an Asda store) but they cater for a different market and frankly their cheap ready meals are cheap for one reason only ... and it's got nothing to do with quality! You generally get what you pay for and on the very rare occasion that I buy a ready meal I go to M&S or Waitrose.

    Report on 06 May 2012  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • jedi44
    Love rating 31
    jedi44 said

    As a woman of a certain age, I have to agree with the placing of Bon Marché. It is one of the few shops that can provide reasonably-priced casual, stylish clothes for my age group. I know the kids wouldn't be seen dead in it but it occupies the gap for women who don't want to look like mutton dressed as lamb but who aren't ready for the tweed skirt and headscarf. Our local store was one of those selected for closure after the recent take-over but, after the sale of everything, there was such an ourcry that it has been reprieved.

    As for Ikea, when they first opened I was intrigued by all the publicity. I made the hour drive up to town, drove round the car park for another 30 minutes before I got a space, then joined the never-ending queue of shoppers round the store. There was never time or space to really browse and, to be scrupulously honest, there wasn't much worth looking at. Having taken all the time I felt I should buy something to make it worth the trip. As a last resort,I picked up a couple of wee baskets at the exit area, headed for home and have never been back.

    Report on 06 May 2012  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • rlx
    Love rating 1
    rlx said

    IKEA for me is a house of horrors. Most of the stuff is junk and overpriced, with only the odd good piece. It's probably fine if you don't mind your furniture falling apart after a while and everyone knowing you've got no taste.

    But the worst part is queuing to get out.

    How, then, do I know so much about it? It's good for temporary furniture when you move somewhere new (until you can get some proper stuff).

    Report on 06 May 2012  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • elaineb64
    Love rating 6
    elaineb64 said

    I can't comment on Ikea because I've never set foot inside one. Marks & Spencer have always been high on my list for good service but they got a blot on their copybook the other day when they refused to let me pick up some stuff I ordered online for a store pick up because they were "shutting in 15 minutes"!! How long does it take to get a parcel out of the store room and bring it out to the desk? I find my local Morrison's offers decent quality on everyday groceries (with the added bonus that my daughter works there so I get staff discount) and my fruit and veg comes from the local market (I've cottoned on to the idea of buying seasonal produce in bulk when it's cheap and freezing it). I've had a few things from H & M and the quality seems ok but I buy cheap and cheerful from places like Asda or New Look for everyday use with the odd splurge at a local boutique for a special occasion. M & S do great quality underwear so I may have to overlook their recent faux pas with the parcel. My first stop for electricals is usually Comet or Miller's for white goods and small items I find Argos are quite cheap but I hate that ticket system - it's like being in the doctor's surgery!

    Report on 06 May 2012  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • electricblue
    Love rating 643
    electricblue said

    UK population 60 odd million, survey size 6000. What a waste of an article! IKEA isn't so much a retail experience as psychological warfare against their customers. No one with half a brain would give credibility to IKEA being voted number one in any kind of shopping survey. I shop at IKEA but find it stressful and unpleasant. I have never met anyone who thinks otherwise.

    Report on 07 May 2012  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • CuNNaXXa
    Love rating 362
    CuNNaXXa said

    Damn statistics.

    I did a survey once. Of 100 people I interviewed, 98 preferred MacDonalds over KFC. Of course, I was stood outside MacDonalds at the time.

    So, out of almost 70 million people living in this country, they take a sample size of just 6,000. That, in itself, is just a sample size of less than 0.01%, which is no indication whatsoever of our preference.

    Also, were these 6,000 from all over the country, or did they concentrate on the more populated areas? Did they canvass people who were way outside the catchment area of IKEA, or did they concentrate on people who have access to this store?

    The trouble with statistics is that you can more or less dictate the outcome by being very selective. If you interview people in a Tory stronghold, you will get a more pro conservative feeling than if you had visited a Labour stronghold.

    Report on 07 May 2012  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • SeaBee
    Love rating 15
    SeaBee said

    Waitrose comes top for food and grocery but seven times as many people shop at Tesco.

    Bon Marche is so popular that it went into administration in January no mention of Primark which has to virtually fight off its customers.

    Wilkinson with a few hundred SKUs is more popular than B&Q with 60000.

    I remember when Verdict employed half-way sensible people

    Report on 08 May 2012  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • LaurenceSt
    Love rating 3
    LaurenceSt said

    The best indicator: Tailbacks on the M6 They must do something right....

    Report on 08 May 2012  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • culluding-fool
    Love rating 49
    culluding-fool said

    I never thought of Wilkinsons as a hardware store. It can be useful for a few cheap household items but I go to Wickes for 'proper' hardware. We don't have a lot of choice here, no B&Q for eg. We have a Homebase but I don't find them any good for anything other than a few plants.

    Report on 08 May 2012  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • electricblue
    Love rating 643
    electricblue said

    @colluding-fool

    Wickes isn't a hardware store by any definition. That you don't think of Wilkinsons as such does not make you correct. Wickes is primarily a building supply store and hundreds of years of what defines a hardware store has perhaps escaped you. I do prefer Wickes in their particular field, the 1000 percent mark-ups in B&Q are obscene.

    Report on 11 May 2012  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • Basia02a
    Love rating 43
    Basia02a said

    I am amazed that Waitrose is in this list - presumably the survey is done down South as I know of onl;y one Waitrose within a 60 mile radius of me.

    Report on 11 May 2012  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • JudithValmai
    Love rating 0
    JudithValmai said

    Yes, you're most likely right about Waitrose being mostly down south. Occasionally I shop in the one in Bath, near me. Really good range of fresh fruit and veg.

    Report on 11 May 2012  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • MK22
    Love rating 142
    MK22 said

    I have to say I don't understand people's problems with IKEA. Their sofa beds for instance are brilliant (comfortable/robust) and cheap. If you want somewhere overpriced try Dunhelm Mill! My local IKEA is no more crowded than any other shops at busy times and their returns system beats most people's. Wlikinsons may have started as a hardware store but more local one certainly isn't. And yes, I go to B&Q for most things DIY, or else my local, locally owned, REAL hardware store.

    Report on 12 May 2012  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • Ginnymay
    Love rating 36
    Ginnymay said

    I broke my wristwatch while in London recently and made the mistake of going into John Lewis for a replacement, just wanting a basic cheap watch which tells the time. Now I know why they are never knowingly undersold - their range of stock didn't include a single watch in my price range, even if it was competitively priced for what it was.

    The Wilkinsons in our town doesn't sell much hardware, just the odd packaged item, like Tesco does, and you wouldn't call Tesco a hardware store. If you want a range of tools or nails and screws, the old-fashioned hardware store can't be beaten - let's hope B&Q, Homebase and the like don't squeeze them out of business. Use them or lose them!

    Report on 18 May 2012  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • yocoxy
    Love rating 132
    yocoxy said

    6000 sample too small? Ok then, the 20 people here must be right.

    Report on 21 May 2012  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • Ykslad
    Love rating 0
    Ykslad said

    Did they survey 6000 overweight women with no style? As that is the only way I can see Bonmarche doing so well! They are a very odd choice, surely Next or Primark are more mainstream.

    I always though Waitrose was expensive but recently went into Co-op and found they are often more expensive than Waitrose! Surprised Aldi don't get a look in as they generally do well in other surveys and they are surprisingly good.

    As other people have said, Ikea is good if you know what you are doing but a lot of it is overpriced junk, still they give you free drinks with their family card. Glad Homebase isn't in there for DIY, it's now so full of Argos rubbish my mother now wants to go there!

    John Lewis is my favourite store, especially the Oxford Street one.They aren't cheap but the products and staff are very good. I also love Boots, who have the best card scheme of any store.

    Report on 24 May 2012  |  Love thisLove  0 loves

Post a comment

Sign in or register to post a reply.

Our top deals

Credit card
company
Balance transfers rate and period Representative
APR
Apply
now

Barclaycard 27Mth Platinum Visa

0% for 27 months (3.5% fee) Representative 18.9% APR (variable) Apply
Representative example: assumed borrowing of £1,200, representative 18.9% APR (variable). Purchase rate 18.9% PA (variable). BT fee is reduced from 3.9% to 3.5% (T&Cs apply).

NatWest Platinum MasterCard

0% for 26 months (2.65% fee) Representative 18.9% APR (variable) Apply
Representative example: assumed borrowing of £1,200, representative 18.9% APR (variable). Purchase rate 18.95% PA (variable).

Royal Bank of Scotland Platinum MasterCard

0% for 26 months (2.65% fee) Representative 18.9% APR (variable) Apply
Representative example: assumed borrowing of £1,200, representative 18.9% APR (variable). Purchase rate 18.95% PA (variable).
W3C  Thank you for using CGWEBLIV2