Netflix vs Lovefilm vs NOW TV: the cheapest way to watch films

John Fitzsimons
by Lovemoney Staff John Fitzsimons on 11 September 2012  |  Comments 20 comments

There are now two serious rivals to Lovefilm in the UK movie rental market.

Netflix vs Lovefilm vs NOW TV: the cheapest way to watch films

Almost everyone I know is a customer of Lovefilm, the postal and online film rental service now owned by Amazon.

That’s partly my fault – having been a customer for a couple of years, I regularly get sent gift cards offering family and friends a two-month free trial of the service. It’s a smart way for Lovefilm to expand its customer base, and I get to look generous without actually spending any money to boot. Perfect!

However, if you're happy to stream films over an internet connection, there are two serious pretenders to Lovefilm's crown in the shape of Netflix and NOW TV. Let's take a look at how they measure up.

The Lovefilm service

While I’ve long made use of Lovefilm’s postal service, I haven’t ever tried the online streaming service, Lovefilm Instant.

Pricewise, it appears pretty similar to the Netflix deal. If you're not already a Lovefilm customer and you haven't had a free trial in the past, Lovefilm is currently offering a free 30-day trial to this. After the 30 days, you will pay £4.99 a month for an "introductory period", £1 cheaper than Netflix.

You can watch the films on your computer, or on your TV via a Lovefilm-ready device. These include the PS3, Sony Bravia TVs (with internet video) and Samsung TVs. Check out this section of the Lovefilm website for more info on Lovefilm-ready devices.

Or if you want physical DVDs as well as the option to stream, you can sign up for a free trial of that too. And if you sign up via Vouchercodes.co.uk, you can also get a free voucher, ranging from £20 off at M&S to £20 off at Amazon or £10 off at John Lewis.

The Lovefilm selection

There’s currently nearly 7,500 films available if you watch as part of a package or take the streaming-only service, and while they are not exactly the latest releases, they seem a lot more current than the Netflix selection.

It’s worth noting that the online library is still nowhere near as comprehensive as the physical DVD library, but Lovefilm’s selection of films still seems far more enticing to me than the current Netflix range.

Netflix

Netflix is well established in the US and Canada, and claims to have more than 20 million customers across 47 countries and territories.

The service makes use of your internet connection, streaming films and TV shows direct to your home. You can watch that content in a variety of ways, whether using your PC, streaming it onto your smartphone, or even straight onto your TV by making use of a games console, like a PS3 or Nintendo Wii.

For £5.99 a month, you can watch whatever content you like, whenever you like. You can even connect through Facebook so that your friends can see what you’re watching.

You can sign up for an initial month’s free trial to give the service a go too!

Films and shows available on Netflix

OK, I’ll be honest, my excitement at the launch of Netflix in the UK was pretty seriously dented when I saw the selection of films for subscribers. There isn’t much in the way of new releases – yes, there’s Drive and Warrior, but most of the line-up is dominated by films that are at least five years old.

I love Bill & Ted’s Bogus Journey and Reservoir Dogs as much as the next guy, but I’ve got them on DVD already, and I doubt I’m alone.

There are plenty of classics though, from West Side Story and Brief Encounter to Some Like It Hot and Midnight Cowboy.

The TV selection is a little better with programmes like Breaking Bad and 24, as well as full seasons of British shows like The Inbetweeners and Torchwood. You can also catch up on old episodes of Top Gear, which will no doubt be a blow for the digital channel Dave.

NOW TV

Sky has now got in on the act with its NOW TV offering. For £15 a month you can watch unlimited films via the online service on a PC, Mac, iPhone, iPad, Xbox 360, YouView and some Android devices. You can also tune in to any of the Sky Movies TV channels

You can also stream a further 1,000 individual films from the Sky Store, which cost between 99p and £3.49, depending on their age.

While its selection is currently modest, Sky's USP is that it's offering new films to stream before its competitors. And it's certainly current – you can already watch Salmon Fishing In The Yemen, which hasn't long left cinemas. It definitely needs to add more films to its on-demand range to justify the monthly subscription charge but that will undoubtedly happen.

YouTube

YouTube now offers paid-for films (and some free ones) alongside its millions of hours of free videos. Prices range from £1.49 to £3.49 for recent blockbusters.

Other options

There are some other pay-per-view services out there, all powered by a company called FilmFlex. HMV has hmv on-demand, Virgin Media has its own Movies On Demand and Film 4 has Film4OD. They all offer a fairly limited selection of films, in comparison to Lovefilm or Netflix, that you can stream online or offline. The cost ranges from 99p for an older film to £3.99 for a recent blockbuster.

The new way of watching movies

I’ve no doubt that in the coming months the selection of films and TV shows from Netflix will improve significantly, and we will then see a real battle between the firm and Lovefilm. However, the more important point in all of this is that streaming movies directly to our TVs is going to become an ever more mainstream thing to do.

Apple, Google, Roku and YouView (a joint venture between the BBC, ITV, Channel 4, Channel 5, BT, TalkTalk and Arqiva, backed by Lord Alan Sugar) have all launched TV boxes that use your internet connection to offer streaming services.

Both Apple and Google boxes will stream Netflix and YouTube to your TV and cost £99 and £200 respectively. The Apple box can synchronise with your other Apple devices while the Google box also offers the BBC iPlayer, a Chrome browser and the Google Play app store.

Another American import, Roku, includes iPlayer and Netflix and its two boxes cost either £49.99 or £99.99.

Meanwhile, YouView offers the iPlayer and NOW TV as part of its internet TV offering which, unlike the others, includes Freeview and a digital video recorder as standard, although it is far more expensive at £299 (read Lord Sugar's YouView set-top box is a letdown for more on its initial offering).

However, TalkTalk is already offering YouView boxes to new subscribers to its Plus broadband and phone package with Lovefilm Instant bundled in free for the first year. BT will also be offering the boxes as part of BT Vision soon.

What it means for your broadband

So you’ve decided which firm to stream films from, and whether to do it via a laptop, internet-ready TV, digital TV box or games console.

The final thing to bear in mind is your broadband. It’s all well and good streaming a film every couple of nights, but what about the dent that will make into your broadband allowance? If you’re only on a package with a very small download ceiling, streaming films could see you smash through that limit, incurring additional charges along the way. So bear that in mind next time you shop around for broadband.

You can compare broadband deals in your area over at BroadbandChoices.com

This article has been updated from an earlier version

More on entertainment on the cheap

Watch free movies legally online

Where to listen to free music

Where to get free books

Sneaky ways to save money at Amazon

Enjoyed this? Show it some love

Twitter
General

Comments (20)

  • culluding-fool
    Love rating 49
    culluding-fool said

    I've been with love film for some time and have been using up my quota of online viewing watching some old TV series. Unfortunately love film have decided to take a big step backwards by switching over flash to some Microsoft only product, meaning I can no longer view movies online because I don't use Microsoft software. I have been looking around for something similar to love film that will work on non Microsoft systems but nothing comes close. Netflix didn't have a single program that I searched for & others were even worse. I have yet to try HMV though. I just find it do frustrating when companies make these decisions, especially as I pay yearly and online viewing is classed as a "free" added extra, so I get no compensation for loosing my online viewing. HTML5 is supposed to the future, isn't it?

    Report on 16 January 2012  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • Mike10613
    Love rating 599
    Mike10613 said

    I looked at the Lovefilm trial and wasn't even tempted by the free Amazon voucher, a couple of DVDs a month for £5.99? Not that great when the selection of new films was limited and they didn't seem to have many old ones. It's not worth the money and I doubt if Netflix will be any better. OK if you have more money than sense though...

    Report on 16 January 2012  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • killick_becki
    Love rating 58
    killick_becki said

    I agree with Mike10613 that it does seem expensive for what you are actually getting. However, I do believe that it can be a viable alternative to paying extortionate Sky subscriptions just for re-run content.

    Report on 16 January 2012  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • neilblackley
    Love rating 0
    neilblackley said

    I havn't tried the Lovefilm online service (I spend too long at my computer as it is :-)), however the Lovefilm DVD service doesn't offer a couple of films a month but a couple of films at a time with approx 3 day turnaround. I usually get through 2 a week, totalling 8 per month.

    It all depends on how many films you watch as to whether its a good deal or not.Its also quite handy for catching up with all the classics you never quite got round to watching on telly.

    Report on 16 January 2012  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • Salfordguy
    Love rating 22
    Salfordguy said

    Having seen Netflix on a friends Wii I can only see it would benefit people who have only got Freeview. Many on the programmes are on 4OD etc anyway! I have lovefilm simply for the latest releases which come along sooner than Sky. I have viewed a few old films online. Don't you just download the new viewing platform??

    Report on 16 January 2012  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • neilblackley
    Love rating 0
    neilblackley said

    Apologies to Mike10613- he is entirely correct. Having checked Lovefilm there is a limit on the number of discs/month for light usage. My comments refer to the unlimited package which is more expensive.

    For me it works out at about £1/ DVD plus all the online content, however I'm probably quite a high usage customer.

    Report on 16 January 2012  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • smithdom
    Love rating 34
    smithdom said

    I'm probably not a typical LoveFilm user as I only watch a couple of films a month at most. For me their pay as you go system is perfect as I pay £10 every four DVDs and have six months in which to use each £10 payment. I like the fact that there is no price difference for blu-ray.

    I've never been tempted by streaming services as the quality doesn't match blu-ray, and if it did then it wouldn't match my 60GB a month download limit.

    It doesn't worry me at all if I can't see the latest releases immediately. My enjoyment of a good movie is not the least bit impacted by knowing that lots of people have seen it already.

    Report on 16 January 2012  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • octotwin
    Love rating 0
    octotwin said

    All these online rental services are great, to an extent. However none, so far, offer full accessability for the deaf, hard of hearing or blind on their streaming services.

    There are no subtitle options or audio descriptive services, whereas, with the majority of DVD's, you do get these choices.

    It is something that all these suppliers really need to take seriously and develop for their services as soon as possible as they are restricting a lot of people from using the services.

    Report on 16 January 2012  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • acornkate
    Love rating 0
    acornkate said

    I pay Lovefilm £16 a month for unlimited DVDs & as much online watching as I want, which works out very cheap for me as we don't have a TV so we tend to watch DVDs instead. But because we live in the back end of nowhere the streaming is slow during the day. However, we work odd hours & tend to watch stuff in the middle of the night, & with the PlusNet broadband package we have any downloads between midnight & 08:00 don't count as part of the allowance, so we can watch as much as we want. I've looked at the other online DVD sites & none of them have such a good selection as Lovefilm.

    Report on 16 January 2012  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • Jonny2284
    Love rating 0
    Jonny2284 said

    It really comes down to whether you want TV shows or films.

    Lovefilm has a superior collection of films, however both it's quantity and presentation of TV shows pales in comparison to Netflix.

    personally I'm intending to keep both Netflix and the lowest unlimted Lovefilm package (using the Lovefilm DVDs to fill in some of the gaps in the collection), get the best of both worlds and still far cheaper than the Skybill.

    Report on 16 January 2012  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • Iamcoldsteve
    Love rating 308
    Iamcoldsteve said

    The cheapest way is neither of those mentioned in the title.

    If you know where to look you can easily find films for downloading. Quicker than going to the rental shop, free and easy. Usually take around 15 minutes to download a full film and it doesn't have the god awful adverts and trailers.... So I am led to believe. Download to your laptop and HDMI into your TV. So HD films on your TV played from your laptop.

    Sometimes, you can even download a film before it is even out in the UK cinema.

    Before anyone says it is killing the film industry - really? The main thing that is killing the film industry (read Hollywood) is the poor nature of the product.

    I is now very common for plot development, character progression, a good storyline etc all 'replaced' with special effects. So much so, that the films are NOT WORTH paying for.

    Downloading only hurts the manufacturer etc IF, and only IF the person downloading WOULD HAVE paid to see the film and now no longer does.

    Report on 19 January 2012  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • sludgeguts
    Love rating 54
    sludgeguts said

    Iamcoldsteve, whilst you were/are correct, that situation looks to be changing rapidly with the sudden demise of Megaupload. It won't be long before the might of the Film industry reaches out to put a stranglehold on other similar sites.

    What annoys me about the film industry is that they don't ever seem to think about us, their customers. Whilst there are many who clamour to see the latest film (even sitting in a queue for hours on end), there are many of us who do not want to sit in a cold, draughty cinema being deafened by SFX dolby digital surround sound (or whatever it is), we do not want to listen to the unruly kids chucking their popcorn everywhere & taking the rise out of the film or the constant coughing or rustling sweet packets.

    And whilst the likes of Wossy might 'big up' almost every film he sees, many of us believe that most of the films are a waste of money - the best bits being the ones we have already seen as trailers to entice us in to waste our money.

    The only time I would buy a DVD is if I have watched a freebie first and rate it worthy of buying the disk. The only time I would watch a film in the cinema is if someone bought me tickets.

    Report on 20 January 2012  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • Iamcoldsteve
    Love rating 308
    Iamcoldsteve said

    Megaupload is not many people favourite place to download from. A lot of people prefer torrent style downloading - ie downloading a small amount from many other people.

    Any decent anti-virus will suffice, as films formats don't really lend themselve to virus inclusion.

    Report on 20 January 2012  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • leah AKA global leah
    Love rating 21
    leah AKA global leah said

    I got to admit I am one of those people that download films from torrent sites, BUT if a film that's worth watching over and over again, I will go and buy the DVD, if not, then at least I didn't waste any money on buying something that only been watched once and then gathering dust...

    I was a member of lovefilm, and the problem with that is, if there isn't any films that you fancy at all, you STILL had to pay the monthly charge, I soon stopped the membership, it just wasn't worth wasting the money if I wasn't using the service.

    Report on 22 January 2012  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • Iamcoldsteve
    Love rating 308
    Iamcoldsteve said

    Another recycled story by LM.

    It seems that the 'powers that be' are incredibly dumb if they tthink that now "The Pirate Bay" has been blocked by UK ISPs it will make any difference.

    I now takes one extra click of the mouse to get to the same webpage as before and download whatever you want.

    Report on 11 September 2012  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • Bobski
    Love rating 19
    Bobski said

    I have a £4 pm Lovefilm subscription that gives me 2 DVD/Blu-Ray RENTALS a month. May not seam much but its fine for us at the moment. also if you pay upfront you can save a further 15-25%.

    Report on 11 September 2012  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • imoney-life.com
    Love rating 1
    imoney-life.com said

    How does the Netflix service compare to BTVision where you pay for TV shows on demand etc..? I'm thinking of switching to Vision myself and giving up SKY but am unsure what I'll be losing out on as it's very unclear!

    Report on 18 September 2012  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • killick_becki
    Love rating 58
    killick_becki said

    @imoney-life.com I have BT vision and have done for the last 3 years or so. I haven't managed to get to the point where there is nothing I want to watch,.....yet. I signed up early so we only have the TV section (rather than new signups who get everything or nothing). I pay £7.20 a month compared to c£10.99 for everything.

    The added bonus with BT vision is that unlike LoveFilm and NetFlix, they tell you when a show is going to disappear. This means that provided you plan your viewing, you know when a show will disappear so you shouldn't get left half way through a series with no way of watching the rest.

    I specifically emailed LoveFilm about this issue as I was thinking of switching but they said they did not have a facilities to offer an "end date" service and did not have plans to introduce this feature.

    If it gets to the point where there is nothing I want to watch for a couple of months then I will certainly be cancelling my subscriptions. Not there yet though!

    Report on 20 September 2012  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • killick_becki
    Love rating 58
    killick_becki said

    Should say that BT Vision is a bonus because the streaming via the vision box is not counted against your download limit.

    They have several catch-up services (if you have the full subscription) including BBC iPlayer, 4OD, ITVplayer and 5OnDemand.

    Report on 20 September 2012  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • j_man
    Love rating 0
    j_man said

    Be careful of LoveFilms 30-day no obligation trial. When I did this it was almost comical. Out of three disks, one didn't work, one was the wrong movie and the other never showed up. I know that sometimes things just don't work out so no hard feelings, I decided to cancelled the service with a wry grin.

    What happened next was unforgivable. They continued my subscription against my requests and charged me a monthly fee. I wrote and complained, and requested my money back and they sent me a giftcard which I didn't want. I never did get the money back so I feel it important to let people know.

    Report on 06 November 2012  |  Love thisLove  0 loves

Post a comment

Sign in or register to post a reply.

Our top deals

Credit card
company
Balance transfers rate and period Representative
APR
Apply
now

Barclaycard 27Mth Platinum Visa

0% for 27 months (3.5% fee) Representative 18.9% APR (variable) Apply
Representative example: assumed borrowing of £1,200, representative 18.9% APR (variable). Purchase rate 18.9% PA (variable). BT fee is reduced from 3.9% to 3.5% (T&Cs apply).

Barclaycard 25Mth Platinum Visa

0% for 25 months (2.4% fee) Representative 18.9% APR (variable) Apply
Representative example: assumed borrowing of £1,200, representative 18.9% APR (variable). Purchase rate 18.9% PA (variable). BT fee is reduced from 3.5% to 2.4% (T&Cs apply)

Halifax BT 25 Month MasterCard

0% for 25 months (2.5% fee) Representative 18.9% APR (variable) Apply
Representative example: assumed borrowing of £1,200, representative 18.9% APR (variable). Purchase rate 19.0% PA (variable).
W3C  Thank you for using CGWEBLIV3