Depreciation: the ten cars that will hold their value in 2012

Cliff D'Arcy
by Lovemoney Staff Cliff D'Arcy on 08 May 2012  |  Comments 18 comments

Cars can depreciate at a rapid rate. However, these ten are the most likely to hold their value.

Depreciation: the ten cars that will hold their value in 2012

Which are the most important factors to take into account when choosing a new or used car?

With the price of fuel hitting all-time highs, you should check a vehicle's fuel economy, as well as deciding whether you want a petrol or diesel engine. Be sure to read Diesels are cheaper than petrol cars...for some of us

Also, when doing your sums, you'll need to add on the cost of car insurance, so check to see which of the 50 insurance groups your new vehicle falls into. Likewise, your Vehicle Excise Duty (VED, or 'road tax') could be anything from zero to over £1,000 a year, depending on the car's CO2 emissions.

And then there's for service, maintenance and MoT costs, plus interest charges and fees if you buy using a personal loan or other finance.

The biggest cost of ownership

However, the above list excludes what is often the biggest cost of owning a car: depreciation.

Depreciation is the tendency for vehicles -- both new and old -- to lose value over time. As cars age, they become less valuable, largely because of wear and tear. Generally, the biggest loss of value comes in the first year of a new car's life, when depreciation is at its steepest.

Obviously, this loss of resale value really does matter, because the steeper a vehicle's depreciation, the less you'll get for it when you come to sell and replace it. Depreciation varies widely between makes and models, but typically ranges between 15% and 35% in the first year. Then again, depreciation can be even higher for cars with high mileages and those that haven't been well looked after.

How low can depreciation go?

On the whole, cars that are well-built, reliable and popular tend to hold their values much better than cars seen to be unpopular, unreliable or at the lower end of the quality scale.

To show you how low depreciation can be, used-car website Motors.co.uk has produced a survey of ten small cars that it predicts will hold their value well in 2012. Here they are:

1. BMW 1-Series

A popular choice for businessmen and families alike, a 2010 model will set you back around £19,197. On average, a new model costs just over £20,329, so the BMW 1-Series loses just 5.6% of its value in the first year, which is incredibly low.

2. Ford Focus

A new Focus bought a year ago would have cost £11,919, but is worth £11,207 today. This 6.4% drop in value in 12 months is a testament to the enduring popularity of the Focus.

3. Fiat 500

A funky, fun and fiercely popular first car, a Fiat 500 bought a year ago was priced at £9,815. Second hand, it now sells for £9,137, which is a drop of just 6.9%. Motors.co.uk reckons the 2010 and 2011 versions are both worth a look.

4. BMW 5-Series

The first of three classy German autos on our list, the BMW 5-Series is a firm favourite. A year ago, one of these cars would have set you back an average of £35,590, but now changes hands for £31,758, for a price fall of 10.8%.

5. Audi A3

The upmarket big brother of the Volkswagen Golf, the Audi A3 is a dream to drive. A new model costing £20,994 would sell for £18,437 with one year on the clock, which is a relatively modest 12.2% drop.

6. Vauxhall Corsa

Among the UK’s most popular and reliable cars, the Corsa cost £9,475 new, but still goes for £8,206 a year later. That's a price fall of 13.4%, making the Corsa "a great option for young drivers wanting a reliable first car with a great resale value," according to Motors.co.uk.

7. Ford Ka

The second of three Fords on our list, a shiny, new Ka came with a price tag of around £8,866 last year. Twelve months on, it sells for £7,659, which is a modest decline of 13.6%.

8. Mazda 6

The Mazda 6 holds its value well. Worth £18,379 new last year, it now fetches £15,876. This depreciation of 13.6% is surprisingly low for a mass-market, Japanese model.

9. Mercedes C Class

A solid favourite of well-heeled motorists, a Mercedes C Class costing £26,468 a year ago would sell on for £22,703 today. This fall of £3,765 works out at a first-year reduction of 14.2%, or £1 in every £7 lost to depreciation.

10. Ford Fiesta

The final Ford on our list is the ever-popular Fiesta, a British classic that definitely stands the test of time. A year ago, a new Fiesta would set you back £11,133, but would go for £9,469 today. That's a price fall of 14.9%, which makes the Fiesta a solid buy.

Choosing a cheaper make or model of car often backfires. This is because higher depreciation can make a low-cost vehicle a false economy, since it loses its value so rapidly.

Therefore, when choosing your next vehicle, be sure to ask your friendly neighbourhood petrol-head about the depreciation rates of different manufacturers. Otherwise, you could get a shock when you come to sell your once-prized motor!

More on motoring:

Why your car insurance is still too expensive

Diesels are cheaper than petrol cars...for some of us

The most expensive petrol in the world

A terrible way to pay for your new car

25 ways to cut your car insurance

Enjoyed this? Show it some love

Twitter
General

Comments (18)

  • Ken Rich
    Love rating 15
    Ken Rich said

    I don't know where they get their second hand car prices from - they obviously don't use the garage showrooms anywhere near me. If you tried to sell a one year old BMW for 5.6% less than you paid for it they would laugh you out of the building.

    Report on 08 May 2012  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • rbgos
    Love rating 81
    rbgos said

    My 1990 Lotus Excel is worth as much today as when I bought it a couple of years ago (for £3100, not bad for a classic sports car with that heritage!). In 10 years time, if properly maintained, I have no doubt it will still be worth that much, if not rather more.

    Zero or even negative depreciation - gotta love it!

    Report on 08 May 2012  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • This_is_me
    Love rating 24
    This_is_me said

    The Fiesta is not a |British car; all Fords are made abroad.

    These figures illustrate the lies, damed lies and stistics point. Try trading in any of these cars for a new one after a year and you will find you probably need to put a 2 in front of your percentage depreciation figures.

    Report on 08 May 2012  |  Love thisLove  3 loves
  • dainewb
    Love rating 4
    dainewb said

    Cliff, the figures here are just wrong. There is no way you would get such low depreciation, expecially on a ford or vauxhall which are notorious for high depreciation. I really think that you should have done some more thorough research than just using motors.co.uk. If you had looked at parkers, glass's and autotrader you would see that you are nowhere near. As an example the most recent model ford focus 1.6 edge 5dr which cost £16k new is expected to be worth £10k in a private sale after a year! This is 38% depreciation (albeit the buyer may have been able to get a discount on the list price) and even if a dealer sold after a year the price would be £11k)

    I really think that you should remove this article or research it properly because people will lose a lot of money if they believe it.

    Report on 08 May 2012  |  Love thisLove  4 loves
  • SeaBee
    Love rating 15
    SeaBee said

    Mr D'Arcy seems to be comparing the cost of a new car with the cost of a second-hand car on a dealer's forecourt. He needs to take into consideration the dealer's margin, which for a nearly new second-hand car is often greater than that on a new car.

    Report on 08 May 2012  |  Love thisLove  2 loves
  • superbrain
    Love rating 3
    superbrain said

    The Fiesta is not a British classic & never has been - it's been made in Spain since porduction began 35 years ago.

    Report on 08 May 2012  |  Love thisLove  1 love
  • dbirbeck
    Love rating 0
    dbirbeck said

    Its only a couple of weeks ago that I read an article that said Audi Q5 was the best car for holding its value..It doesnt even get a mention in the above.It suprised me because thats what Ive got.I think these articles need to be taken with a pinch of salt

    Report on 08 May 2012  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • Jeff
    Love rating 0
    Jeff said

    The only way to 'appreciate' a cars value is to buy an older one E.G the Celica GT4 and hold on to it for a few years (I have two... the ST205 UK WRC and the ST185 UK CS.. thats the way forward!

    Anything built since 200 is rotten!

    Report on 08 May 2012  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • electricblue
    Love rating 643
    electricblue said

    Comparing new car prices with used forecourt prices is as meaningless as it gets and spinning a whole article from a nonsense survey just continues a pattern on here.

    Report on 08 May 2012  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • the general
    Love rating 1
    the general said

    I used to drive old bangers and throw them away when they failed the MOT. I think I'll go back to that policy as I have lost £10k in the lat 4 years having bought an 18mth old car. I felt affluent at the time of the purchase but as economic times have changed I rue the day.....

    Report on 08 May 2012  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • aoh11
    Love rating 1
    aoh11 said

    Your facts seems to be materially incorrect. The BMW 5 Series is among the fastest and worst depreciating cars, that's why they make such a good second hand car. I fail to see how you have compiled the list above and as one other persons has commented you have missed the car that seems to hold it's value reasonably well, the Audi Q5.

    I also think you ned to revise this article or delete it as it could be rather misleading to many readers who are not that aware of which cars do actually hold their value reasonably well, not there is that many that do!

    Report on 09 May 2012  |  Love thisLove  1 love
  • Englishbloke
    Love rating 7
    Englishbloke said

    It looks like you have listed the new price and then the price they are listed on a forecourt 12 months later? Not the amount you would get in PX etc.

    Really don't believe a BMW dealer would offer you only 5.6% less for your 1 Series 12 months after you purchased it!

    Report on 10 May 2012  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • Philmo
    Love rating 2
    Philmo said

    This article is of no interest except to those intent on selling 12 months after sgelling out their hard earned on a new one, complete with all the relevant taxes!

    ie to a FOOL!

    IMHO what we are interested in is the group of 20 which depreciated the most in their first 2 to 3 years.

    Report on 10 May 2012  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • davidinnotts
    Love rating 2
    davidinnotts said

    There's the opposite benefit, of course...

    I bought my 2000 Mondeo at 3 years old for £5,500. It's a top model automatic with all the frills (£23,000 list price), had been immaculately maintained and hadn't been in use after it was 20 months old. Why? Because Ford Leasing had auctioned it off, and it had passed through 3 dealers' hands as it failed to sell. Why? It had done 97,000 miles in those 20 months and buyers were frightened of it.

    In fact, it has been a dream, incurring only £400 in replacements or faults over 9 years, plus the usual replacement of worn-out parts like tyres, wipers and brake parts. It's now approaching 150.000 miles and I'll probably retire it because of more serious parts coming up for change: my last Mot cost £400 because of a broken spring and worn rear suspension; more like it coming up.

    Nevertheless, such bargains are worth looking for; cars today tend to be so well built and so reliable that most models at high mileage are a good buy at the low prices they sell for. There is the occasional dog, of course, but the guides warn you of models with known problems to steer away from, and £30 for a professional report before you buy is always money well spent.

    Report on 10 May 2012  |  Love thisLove  1 love
  • electricblue
    Love rating 643
    electricblue said

    BMW have a one series ED model. Does it come with a free supply of Viagra, I wonder?

    Report on 15 May 2012  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • Mike10613
    Love rating 599
    Mike10613 said

    All this is a bit academic, with the average family having less than 3K in savings, Who can afford a new car? It seems companies will buy them and a few people on regular and high incomes will buy or lease. People on high incomes buy big cars and so we can expect plenty of those second-hand in years to come. Small cars might become even more scarce and so hold their value better.

    @electricblue, getting a bit desperate? :)

    Report on 15 May 2012  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • electricblue
    Love rating 643
    electricblue said

    @ Mike

    The ED model will be worth a lot less money on resale, Mike. Citroen changed their TRD French model to DTR in the UK. How about you stick to a subject you know something about, Mike? Plenty of people can afford new cars because few are bought outright. Used car prices in this country are very low comparatively speaking and the best indicator that plenty of new vehicles are still getting into the system. Since when did what people can afford determine what they actually buy anyway? Seems like the whole negative equity mess is the best proof of that.

    Report on 15 May 2012  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • mgbboy55
    Love rating 6
    mgbboy55 said

    perhaps i ve got this wrong - but if you are looking to buy a second hand car, surely those that drop like a stone in their first 18 months are the ones you should be looking at? Why would you buy a car that is two years old in order to save 5% (which if you shop around you could probably get as a discount on a new one anyway at the end of a selling month).

    i recently bought froma Jag dealer a 3 year old Jag XJ Sport Diesel, full service history, fully loaded, 20,000 mile on the clock (just nicely run in) , does 38 MPG, for £18k!! Now thats what i call a result!

    Report on 08 August 2012  |  Love thisLove  0 loves

Post a comment

Sign in or register to post a reply.

Our top deals

Provider & account name Credit rate (AER)
Based on £1
Overdraft
rate

Based on £1
Apply
now

Santander 123 Current Account

0.0% 0% plus £1.00 per day usage fee Apply

Barclays Bank Account

N/A Up to £200 – 0% interest pa (variable). Over £200 and up to £5,000 – 19.3% interest pa (variable) Apply

first direct 1st Account

N/A 0% Apply
W3C  Thank you for using CGWEBLIV3