Love to be the one to Grow your wealth?

Then register for free and get exclusive, personalised benefits that will help you achieve all your money goals.

Join the lovemoney.com experience

Register Now

Confused?

Why Register?

Top 10 ISA myths

Published 16 October 2009 in Grow your wealth

Confused about ISAs? You're not the only one. Here are all the facts you need to know.

There's a whole lot of confusion about ISAs and how they work. In a nutshell, an ISA is simply a way you can save cash or invest and pay less tax.

Do don't be put off by the jargon. An ISA is just like any other savings account or investment, except it has a 'wrapper' which you can put round your assets to provide the tax benefits. An ISA wrapper around a savings account, for example, transforms it into a cash ISA which then pays interest, tax-free, on your savings with a bank. An ISA wrapper around stocks and shares means you don't pay tax on your capital gain from stocks and shares.

But I'll admit the many ISA rules do complicate matters. Take a look at these top ten myths and check out the real ISA facts:

1. You can only choose stocks & shares or cash

This is totally untrue. You can open a stocks & shares ISA and a cash ISA in the same tax year if you want to. What's more, you can even choose a different ISA provider for each one. It's totally up to you.

Just remember the total ISA allowance is currently £7,200 of which no more than £3,600 can be put in a cash ISA. These limits are higher for the over-50s, and will increase for everyone when the new tax year starts on 6th April.

2. I have to put all my ISA money in one place

This isn't true either. If you choose a stocks & shares ISA you should be able to mix up the way your money is invested. For example, you can choose a range of funds which provide exposure to different markets around the world. And you don't have to stick to one type of asset either. Instead you can balance your investment across shares, bonds, property and cash. This will help to spread risk and diversify your savings portfolio.

You can also switch from a cash ISA into stocks & shares, which although more risky will give the potential for a better return. You can't, however, switch from shares to cash.

Don't forget, you can move old ISA money around as much as you like. Look out for the cash ISA best buys and top performing stocks & shares ISA which accept transfers, so you can always keep your money in the most competitive place.

3. Cash ISA rates are so low, I'd be better off with a traditional savings account

A quick look at current returns should easily resolve this one. In the red corner we have Citibank Flexible Saver Issue 6. This is the market-leading easy access savings account which pays a top rate of 3.30%. In the blue corner we have First Direct Cash e-ISA, the top instant access cash ISA with a rate of 3%.

But First Direct offers a tax-free rate, whereas the Citibank account is taxable. The net rates (the rates after tax) are actually just 2.64% for basic rate taxpayers and 1.98% for higher rate taxpayers. I think that's Round 1 to cash ISAs!

Only non-taxpayers would be better off with Citibank where they can earn interest gross by completing an R85 form. That's Round 2 to ordinary savings accounts!

4. Opening an ISA is complicated

Have you ever actually seen an ISA application form? They're usually no more challenging than two pages of pretty straightforward stuff. Questions like: what is your name, address, national insurance number... nothing too difficult. And the same applies to ISA transfer forms too. You can handle that!

5. The best time to open an ISA is at the end of the tax year

You've heard of the ISA season, right? This is the time where floods of ISA applications are made in the run up to April 5th, the end of the tax year deadline. But there's no reason why this is a better time to invest than any other. In fact, by using your new ISA allowance on April 6 - the first day of the tax year - rather than April 5 - the last day of the tax year - you can take advantage of a whole extra year of tax-free saving or investing.

6. I'll have to declare ISAs on my tax return

Quite simply, you don't. That's the point of an ISA.

7. ISAs are a better way to save for your retirement than pensions

This is a long-standing debate. But ISAs and pensions can actually be invested in very similar ways. And although the tax treatment of each of them is different - one is essentially the reverse of the other - it pretty much comes down to the same thing in the end. That said, some savers prefer ISAs because they can be accessed at any time, and there's no need to buy at annuity at retirement. Find more about that in Five reasons why ISAs are better than pensions.

8. ISAs are only suitable for big savers

You'll actually find many ISAs can be opened with just £1, making them suitable for both small and big savers. Some providers may ask for more, so make sure you check the minimum deposit before you sign up.

9. ISAs are only worth it for higher rate taxpayers

ISAs are exempt from income tax and capital gains tax, so it follows they will be more valuable to people who pay the most tax - i.e. higher rate taxpayers. But that doesn't mean they aren't beneficial to basic rate taxpayers, who can also reduce their overall tax liability.

10. ISAs are risky

Cash ISAs are just as safe as ordinary savings accounts. But there's always an element of risk when you invest in stocks & shares. And, ISAs are just a wrapper around the investments you have chosen. It's no more or less risky than investing in the same assets outside an ISA.

Compare ISAs at lovemoney.com or get a free ISA guide

More: The top 21 worst cash ISAs | Cash ISA changes for the over-50s

Enjoyed this? Show it some love

Share this lovemoney.com content on any of the social networks and utilities below by simply clicking the site of your choice.

  • You can subscribe to all lovemoney.com articles via our RSS feed.

Comments

Arthurian said

  • 1 recommendation

Problem: Many 'Stocks & Shares ISAs' are currently worth less than when taken out so the main beneficiaries are the 'Sellers' [IFAs/FAs etc.]

MANY Child Trust Funds are in a Similar state.

SiGl26 said

  • 0 recommendations

There's another potential misunderstanding that needs to cleared up, which is a downside of an ISA; after you have invested in an ISA, if you then withdraw any of your investment you cannot replace it.  So for the best return you need to be able to lock the money away.  This is prime reason for the 'ISA season'...

tonygogo said

  • 2 recommendations

What about the myth that stock and shares ISAs are tax-free? My understanding is that dividends are taxed at source and paid to the ISA net of tax, and unlike the olden PEP and early ISA days, the income tax suffered can't be reclaimed from Inland Revenue to offset the ISA annual management charge. Although there's no further income tax liability (ideal for high-rate taxpayer) the standard-rate taxpayer's only benefit is no capital gains tax. In fact, the annual management charges still have to be paid each year, so if there's no capital gain each year....

Unless you intend to keep the shares long-term to make more than the CGT allowance, is there a benefit to a stocks and shares ISA these days?  

Danny said

  • 0 recommendations

Tonygogo, ISA benefits

ISA income and gains do not have to be recorded on the tax return

ISA income does not count towards the means test for age related allowances for the over 65s.  This is a significant benefit of an ISA to certain basic rate tax payers

Many people hold investments too long because they don't like to pay capital gains tax.  If you had invested in ISA and PEP since 1987, you would have invested over £170,000 ignoring the growth.  A portfolio of this size will generate capital gains tax problems which you don't have to worry about.

tonygogo said

  • 1 recommendation

Danny - many thanks. Still not convinced though...I can see how it benefits a retired person on benefits, but I'm a long way off being 65, and still a basic-rate taxpayer. I still think it's a myth to describe an ISA as 'tax-free' when dividends are already taxed and you can't reclaim the tax paid any more.

I'd like to know who but the rich, brave high-raters can afford to put away the maximum allowance each year since 1987, and still keep it all invested... 

The original point of PEPs/ISAs was all about encouraging the low-paid to save regularly (in the stock market) and get back tax suffered on dividends and no CGT or tax return worries. It benefits high-raters much more than standard-raters, so it's not for everyone IMO...  

  • 0 recommendations

My understanding is that ISA's as not exempt from IHT - so potentially subject to a whopping 40% tax when I fall off my perch!!

tonygogo said

  • 0 recommendations

RedundantHippie - Yep, you got it right. When you pop off, your ISA tax advantages cease to be. Your ISA pot becomes part of your estate, and any shares held must be sold. On top of IHT, Your ISA pot is potentially liable for CGT, but if there's any CGT losses arising from the ISA, these can reduce any gains.

CGT gains are only worthwhile when crystalised in the ISA and withdrawn, ie while you're still able to munch the millet, and IHT can be reduced/avoided if your assets stay under the IHT limit, so consider gifting/transferring some of your assets to your chosen ones, and hope you outlive the 7-year IHT time limit. Ever thought about spending some of your hard-earned?

dspillett said

  • 0 recommendations

As with all decent savings rates at the moment, that FirstDirect e-ISA is only a good rate for 12 months, after which it drops to 0.2%.

They offer an ISA product at 7% for 12 months too though that is not an easy-access account. I have one of them hitting the first year aniversary soon, and that will then drop to 0.2% too, so if anyone knows a decent rate ISA product that would accept a transfer-in...

  • 0 recommendations

As Tonygogo rightly says, dividend income is still taxed at source - but I'm not sure about income from Govt Gilts in an ISA (either held directly or in a fund) - what is the position then?

keirfamily said

  • 1 recommendation

Good posts Tonygogo, there are some bad points about ISAs which can catch the unwary. They are good for bond income (i.e. not taxed at source) but for a basic-rate taxpayer investing in shares, ISAs mean paying your administrator to do what you could do yourself for free. If you prefer ETFs & trackers to funds because the charges are less, stay out of ISAs - for the same reason.

Yes, ISAs pay no CGT. Hands up everyone who made over £9000 in shares this year? Thought so...

massive said

  • 0 recommendations

tonygogo is right when you die the ISA forms part of your estate their is no CGT to pay up to the date of death ,only if their is any gain after death which your personal representative will pay.

Myth number 7 the biggest problem with saving for retirement in an ISA is that people tend to dip into it ,whereas with a pension you cannot take any money out until age 50 (55 from 6 April 2010) but the good thing about an ISA is that all the money you take out is tax free whereas in a pension 75% is taxed. 

allyp20 said

  • 0 recommendations

This is a question about clarifying the ISA annual allowances, whether by transfer or by new purchase.  My understanding is that you're only allowed to invest - by either method (transfer or new purchase) - up to the legal ISA limits defined by the Treasury.  In other words, to utilise my full allowance in the next tax year (from April) I must choose EITHER to transfer OR to buy.  Is that correct?

Thanks in advance. 

Join the conversation

Please sign in or register to add a comment or recommend.

Our top deals

Credit card
company
Balance transfers rate and period Typical
APR
Apply
now

Barclaycard Platinum with 16 Month BT Visa

0% for 16 months
(2.9% fee)
Typical 16.9% APR (variable) Apply

Virgin Money Credit Card MasterCard

0% for 14 months
(2.98% fee)
Typical 16.6% APR (variable) Apply

Egg Visa

0% until 1st Oct 2011
(3% fee)
Typical 17.9% APR (variable) Apply
W3C  Thank you for using One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest