Follow this topicFollow this topic Knowledge » Gas and electricity

British Gas' 10% Cut Is Just The Beginning

Neil Faulkner
by Lovemoney Staff Neil Faulkner on 22 January 2009  |  Comments 28 comments

British Gas says it's going to reduce its gas prices by 10%, but that's just a fraction of the story.

British Gas will reduce the bills of some of its customers from 19 February, and other suppliers will no doubt follow. But which British Gas customers will see a reduction and by how much, and which of these won't receive the reduction automatically, but will have to contact BG to fight for it?

How much is the reduction?

The first thing to note is that not all British Gas customers will benefit from the change in prices, as the table below shows:

Type Of British Gas TariffReduction
Standard Tariff10% on average
Zero Carbon9.3%
Click EnergyUp to 10% (so probably less than 10%!)
WebsaverUp to 10% (so probably less than 10%!)
EssentialsNo reduction
Fixed-Price TariffsNo reduction
Capped TariffsNo reduction
Price Protection/Guarantee TariffsNo reduction

Good news for standard tariff customers?

BG says standard-tariff customers should see their bills reduced by £84 on average, which means that it reckons the average price paid for gas alone is around £900.

But this is not the great news it appears to be. Most energy providers increased their tariffs by around 20% last summer, but BG's went up 35%. Now, after we've used a lot more gas over the winter period, it's simply bringing prices back into line after an unnecessarily high hike.

Of course, British Gas isn't the only one - all energy companies' results (i.e. profits) should be a shocking read for customers this year.

There is some good news, however. I think we will see more price decreases over the next few months - although they'll occur too late to help with the winter period, as usual. I think there's room for gas cuts of maybe 15% on average, and perhaps 5% off electricity.

Will the decrease happen automatically?

If you're on one of the tariffs that is going to be reduced, your bill might go down, but what about your payments? Most energy suppliers overcharge you and let you build up hundreds of pounds in credit unless you take control.

If you're billed quarterly you should continue to send your meter readings regularly. This'll ensure you benefit immediately from the reduction.

BG tells me that direct-debit paying, standard-tariff customers who had their payments reassessed last July or later will receive the 10% cuts to their payments automatically. (If you were reassessed prior to July 2008, then your payments should go down too, provided that your usage is `consistent'.)

Sadly, BG has made no promise to reduce automatically any direct-debit payments for customers other than those on standard tariffs.

For those reasons, after the price reductions on 19 February, I recommend that everyone affected should contact BG to reduce their direct-debit payments. Otherwise you'll end up paying out more every month than you need to.

Is the standard tariff competitive, now?

On 19 February, British Gas will also introduce a prompt-payment discount of `up to' (those words again) £15 per year for customers on standard gas tariffs. If you have electricity too, there'll be a similar discount for that.

But, there's no getting around it: BG's standard gas and electricity tariffs are still hideously expensive. So a reduction of 10% on gas plus perhaps another £30 off doesn't help much. You're still paying way over the odds.

If you've never switched suppliers, you may not even realise you're on this tariff. When you last moved home, the existing supplier will have automatically placed you and your property on their standard tariff.

If this is the case, then using roughly average figures and The Fool's comparison tool, I reckon you could save around £350 a year by switching to a new supplier.

Even if you have to make very rough estimates about your energy usage, any top Internet deal should save you a huge amount of money.

Other energy customers who are already on decent tariffs should think strongly about waiting to see which supplier comes out on top over the next two months.

BG says the cut in standard-tariff rates will benefit 7.5m homes. That's a lot of people still paying hundreds over the odds for their energy.

Future price cuts may be on their way

It's worth noting that British Gas has not publicised the precise new figures for the tariff, nor have any comparison sites updated prices. Normally, comparison sites don't wait for the day that the new rates go into effect. However, it seems that BG hasn't released figures to them immediately.

The reason for this seems quite obvious to me. BG has put forward its modest decrease as an opening gambit. It's waiting to see how the other suppliers respond between now and March, and then it'll make a final decision on how much it's actually going to reduce rates. Any further reductions may or may not be limited to standard-tariff customers, depending on what cuts the other suppliers make. So watch this space.

> Compare gas and electricity prices through The Fool.

Enjoyed this? Show it some love

Twitter
General

Comments (28)

  • RuthinShropshire
    Love rating 0
    RuthinShropshire said

    This reduction is long overdue, despite what the energy companies tell us they have managed to once again introduce a price drop just as the seasons are changing and our usage will decrease therefore maximising profits. Didn't they do this last year? I am sure that come the Autumn we will once again see prices rise. Why is it that now gas prices have dropped that Big Gas storage containers like the ones I pass on the M6 are still only 1/3 full?!

    Report on 23 January 2009  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • jheenan1
    Love rating 0
    jheenan1 said

    Why cant gas and electricity prices be more like mortgage rates? Ok, you can fix your rates for a year or 5. How about a tracker rate, where you pay 5% more than than the spot rate calculated as an average at the end of every month. It seems fair for all. At the moment oil and gas prices have plummeted and these companies that raised rates last year are making a killing. Ok I will stop gassing on now

    Report on 23 January 2009  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • TMFVertigo
    Love rating 0
    TMFVertigo said

    Hey RuthinShropshire. you're right about last year and that it'll likely happen again this year. I did write words to that effect in my article, but my editor's been trigger-happy today ;)

    jheenan1, BG created a tracker, but it tracked at such a high margin that it wasn't worth it.

    Neil (the author)

    Report on 23 January 2009  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • oldlowie
    Love rating 9
    oldlowie said

    I have just received my gas bill. I am on the standard tariff. The bill was £275 against last year's £150. I thought we must have used more gas, so I did a little research, and to my horror found that the unit price had increased from 86p to £1.34! This represents a 56% increase in just one year. I have never switched utility suppliers, so must be regarded by BG as some kind of mug. I will be onto Uswitch as soon as they take off the oxygen mask...

    Report on 23 January 2009  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • TMFVertigo
    Love rating 0
    TMFVertigo said

    You know that you can compare and switch here? And, in my opinion, The Fool's comparison tool is better than anyone else's, including USwitch.

    Neil (A Fool writer but, even so, that's my opinion. Us writers are independent, and I'd rather drown with only a laughing bottlenose dolphin for company than write something I didn't actually believe :) )

    Report on 23 January 2009  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • sharewatcher
    Love rating 0
    sharewatcher said

    British Gas is just one of six utility companies. I am with Arlantic who boast that they are always the first to reduce prices. Well not this time, although I believe British Gas raised their prices more than the other companies last year.

    Report on 23 January 2009  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • TMFVertigo
    Love rating 0
    TMFVertigo said

    Just one of the six 'big' suppliers, sharewatcher! A lot of Fools like the ethics or customer service they receive with smaller suppliers, such as Utilita or Ebico.

    Neil

    Report on 23 January 2009  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • mer2k
    Love rating 0
    mer2k said

    Come on every one get switching:

    If only a few people switch when the utilities hike prices, then they will do it again, or only pass on a small cut, and continue to make huge margins. 7.5M people stuck with BG one of the most expensive providers. The regulators have failed to produce a competitive market, so its up to us consumers to vote with our feet (fingers on keyboards?) and switch to the lowest supplier. The utilities will only cut their profit margins when they loose significant customers, so come on everyone make my and your bills lower and get switching.

    And don't accept their comments that there is competition as they offer a huge range of tarrifs - complete rubish.

    Report on 23 January 2009  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • TMFVertigo
    Love rating 0
    TMFVertigo said

    mer2k, that's 7.5m on BG's most expensive tariff, it's standard one. BG has a lot more customers on other tariffs too, many of them still paying over the odds, but actually it's cheapest tariffs are competitive.

    Neil (again)

    Report on 23 January 2009  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • MrPound
    Love rating 11
    MrPound said

    Only a couple of months ago, another Fool writer wrote an artlice saying that people should fix their prices if they hadn't already done so because there was little chance that the suppliers will reduce their prices! I thought at the time that this was twaddle and it has now been proved thus. However I would still wait (as the article advises) because come March the other suppleirs will have made their moves and more competitive deals than the BG one will be available. Hold tight people! We're getting there.

    Mr Pound (a buyer of gas & electic on the wholesale market for a manufacturing business for my job)

    Report on 23 January 2009  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • deloco121
    Love rating 0
    deloco121 said

    Woohoo

    So do BG think they are doing anyone a favour? Does an insulting 10% decrease on a standard tariff come anywhere near the price increases that BG and everybody else brought in last year. Was it not 35% they jumped up at one point.

    What about pensioners and people who thought they were doing the right thing by joining a fixed rate tariff - they get absolutely nothing out of this decrease. It makes me so mad.

    I work in the offshore drilling industry for both oil and gas. I have a pretty good idea of what is involved in getting these commodities from the ground and what kind of profits these companies are making.

    They disgust me and the fact that the Government do nothing about these price hikes makes them just as bad. The sooner Brown the Clown is kicked out the better for everyone.

    Report on 23 January 2009  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • BikeMadder
    Love rating 0
    BikeMadder said

    I just wanted to say that changing supplier in the search for lower prices is not always the road to contentment.

    About 3 years ago I switched to British Gas as they were good value at the time, and for the next 2 years BG charged me on the meter reading of a property down the road! Turned out to be an incorrect recording of the MPAN numbers (the one used by the central generator) between our two houses. As a result we perpetually received grossly excessive gas bills, but did they have the competence to get it corrected? Er no.

    BG always changed the charge whenever I rang up with a meter reading, but after two years I got fed up complaining, even wrote to the Regulator, and received from BG a refund of my DDR overpayments. Eventually my supply contract had been assigned to EON, as I found out after receiving a Bailiffs letter from their solicitor for non-payment! In two phone calls I got EON to call off the dogs, take the correct reading, organise a meter engineer visit and set up (correct) DDRs based on proper consumption, and some 6 months' later (touch wood) all is still well.

    I am now on a good value fixed price tariff with EON and am very impressed with their management and admin, so I did end up changing supplier for the better, but be warned, it could create hidden difficulties.

    Report on 23 January 2009  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • LittleSteve
    Love rating 0
    LittleSteve said

    BikeMadder, I had a similar experience with BG and their meter readings. I'd just had a new meter fitted (switched from prepayment) and my first gas bill was over £600. I checked the meter reading myself and it was twenty-something, compared to the 1242 they said it was. Seems they'd used my phone number as a meter reading!

    Report on 23 January 2009  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • TMFVertigo
    Love rating 0
    TMFVertigo said

    Hey MrPound.

    As you say, it must have been another writer that mentioned about fixing if it was a couple of months ago. If I remember correctly, I believe that the prices of fixes had already got too high by then, but that's my opinion based on forward expected prices, and the savings you'd make in the short-term by sticking with the cheapest possible variable tariffs.

    However, you're probably being a little too harsh on that writer. This tiny drop now will be more than offset by rises at the end of this year, and over the next few years.

    Neil (you know who I am)

    Report on 23 January 2009  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • PeterJ42
    Love rating 0
    PeterJ42 said

    British Gas put up my direct debit by £10 last month without telling me. On trying to contact them they disabled my web access telling me I'd made multiple attempts (1 correct attempt) and I'm still waiting for an answer to an email I sent them through their contact. I refuse to phone them as they can record the call and I cannot. It seems they don't want to give me my money (which they took without asking) back. What a way to do business!

    Report on 23 January 2009  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • Meg54
    Love rating 0
    Meg54 said

    How very kind of British Gas to reduce their charges by 'up to' 10%, saving us £84 a year.

    As they hiked them up by firstly 15%, then a further 35%, are we to be delighted by their generosity?

    Using their calculations, they have pushed up the average price of gas by a whopping £420 a year, so giving us a return of £84 is paltry, we are still paying too much!

    Report on 23 January 2009  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • PeterJ42
    Love rating 0
    PeterJ42 said

    One of the things which annoys me is that they quote the rise in the wholesale price and make a rise accordingly (though never a cut). Only a small proportion of our bill is the price of the actual gas - the rest is the cost of the pipework, metering, collection etc. and gas forms under 15% of the cost. Thus rises of the order we've seen are indefensible.

    Report on 23 January 2009  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • deloco121
    Love rating 0
    deloco121 said

    TMFVertigo

    Aplogies, I never seen that you had already mentioned the 35% price increase in your article. Don't want to be accused of plagarism.

    I used to have gas supplied by Scottish Gas and paid a fixed amount every month by direct debit. When my quarterly bill arrived in springtime (for the winter period) it showed that I had used more gas than in the previous quarter (for the autumn period) - No s#*t Sherlock?

    Due to this Scottish Gas then doubled my Direct Debit payment without even telling me. Once I noticed this and contacted them they claimed I would need to pay more because my usage had increased. I informed them that Yes, usage had increased over the winter but my usage would DECREASE over spring/summer therefore balancing my gas usage out. No, thats not how it works I was told. I then cancelled my DD with them and made them wait for payment for every bill after that.

    I no longer use gas and all my heating is oil. I hope I never have to go back to dealing with gas companies again.

    Report on 23 January 2009  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • Chongq
    Love rating 0
    Chongq said

    What shocked me was to hear Phil Bentley CEO of BG lie on TV yesterday and the BBC & ITV let it pass. Indeed the BBC has repeated the same lie over the previous 2 months.He said that there is a vulnerable customer tariff for the over 80's and this was saving them 3 or 400 pounds a year. Dean Weaver,a BG customer contact manager confirms that this tariff was withdrawn unilaterally 3 or 4 months ago. As far as I am aware this tariff was never advertised, certainly not to my 89 year old relative. Stop the misinformation.

    Report on 23 January 2009  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • kujar
    Love rating 0
    kujar said

    My bill this year was £30 lower than the same period last year £210 as opposed to £240. However in April our 30 year old back boiler finally packed up (or one irreplacable part packed up) and we replaced with a new Worcester Bosch condensing boiler. This is beginnig to pay off as the price of gas increased by 20+% and this year was colder than last.

    Why are the power companies permitted these opaque methods of pricing their wares. When the price of oil went up they claimed that the cost of gas was linked to the cost of oil. Now that the price of oil has been down dramatically for months they are finally beginnign to bring the price down. No linkage there then?

    They'll claim its lots of other factors such as a lack of storage within the UK etc. but why does the government not make them use their super profits to provide this storage? Germany has storage for over a 100 days. Neither the Tory nor the Labour governments were or are looking after the interests of their consumers.

    Report on 23 January 2009  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • Ofolaller
    Love rating 0
    Ofolaller said

    .

    Those who use oil as a heating fuel are the poor cousins, frequently getting left out of discussions about greedy gas and electricity power companies. They are mainly country and village dwellers who have no choice.

    .

    I wish someone would investigate the oil supply companies, who have reduced their charges for heating oil(paraffin or kerosene in US English) but not remotely in line with the reduction in their costs of sourcing and providing diesel / paraffin.

    .

    Report on 23 January 2009  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • NC442000
    Love rating 0
    NC442000 said

    Just to strike a sligtly different note, and whilst I have no interest in the company per se, honest, I signed up to Atlantic (SSE I believe), have changed my direct debits up and down when I want to with no argument (to keep my balance around zero), I get a month's debit payment amount for each of gas and electric (£75 in total) back as a rebate once a year, they suggested without my asking that I have my electric meter replaced as a new one would be cheaper (and then did it free of charge) and they even offered (again without my asking) to pay back an outstanding balance to my bank account once because we were heading into summer and I was carrying a credit (as they subsequently did it) So, yes, the prices have gone up, but they all have, and I've been pretty impresssed by the service overall.

    Report on 23 January 2009  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • TMFVertigo
    Love rating 0
    TMFVertigo said

    That's interesting thanks NC442000. If any other readers have had similar (or conflicting) experiencs with Atlantic/SSE in regards to fair treatment with direct debts, please comment too. It'd be nice to get a bigger picture.

    Neil (the author)

    Report on 23 January 2009  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • GregXJR1300
    Love rating 0
    GregXJR1300 said

    Yeah, good on Atlantic, I have been with them since March 2005 and would not switch for the anything. I have experianced the same rebate every year, basically it boils down to only making 11 payments each year for gas and electric and have also hade my electric meter replaced/upgraded free of charge. All dealing and meter readings/enquiries have been handled in a professional customer service manner, as a result we are a very satisfied customer and as such will remain loyal to this supplier.

    Report on 23 January 2009  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • karatekate
    Love rating 0
    karatekate said

    I have just switched using the MF facility to EON from EDF - approx savings apparently will be £172pa - not a fabulous amount, but it's better in my pocket than EDF's! I also get tesco clubcard points for every £ spent on fuel, so that will help at Christmas time too.

    Report on 23 January 2009  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • tonyheaven
    Love rating 0
    tonyheaven said

    Having just read these articles there is a problem for those who like myself who have a key meter for there gas or as in my case electric we pay for our commodity before we get it and strangely we pay a higher tarrif for the pleasure we do have an emergency facility where we can put the key in and get £5 emergency credit which seems to run down quicker than when you have payed the normal lot but maybe it only seems that way on enquireing about going back to a quartely meter i am told that i will have to pay £50 to change back. Now in the past there have been problems you pay for your electric up front well(allthough this happened some while ago)when i rang to enquire they said you will have to pay monies back that you owe how so well i will explain over the course of the year you do get a statemant which tells your payments that have been made how much you have used etc then at the bottom as per normal is how much you owe so you ring up and you get told thats nothing to worry about its only where payments that you have made have not caught up with the meter oh ok then here's the bang some time down the line you get abill for an outstanding amount £180 so i call them and they say its because there engineers have not reset the meters in time so after getting the runaround as usual you get in touch with someone who gives you the number for the high up customer services they squash all the money you owe after a lenghty discusion and send a letter confirming that only 6 mts later it all starts again a letter saying you owe £250 this time and so i call them quote this letter and i dont here anything back now they can alter the meters by computer they tell me. So yes i would like to change to a quartely meter and take advantage of these deals but dont see why i should pay for the meter change when they say we can alter things by computer yes my friends the price of progess ha ha

    Report on 24 January 2009  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • pastsellby
    Love rating 6
    pastsellby said

    I change suppliers about once a year, and the only people I've had good service from have both been SSE 'names'.

    Like 'NC442000' I had faultless service from Atlantic, including varying direct debits up and down when I want, and paying back outstanding balances without being asked.

    I also had excellent service from Southern Electric, part of the same group.

    They both have freephone 0800 numbers for customer service, which have always been promptly answered, and they seem to always solve the query quickly and satisfactorily.

    Of course this is only my personal experience, and I have no connection with the company, but for customer service they would get my vote!

    Report on 24 January 2009  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • sjw321
    Love rating 2
    sjw321 said

    I too am with Atlantic and have been for a few years now. Never had a problem with them and always get my yearly rebates (84.66 this year!). Not sure how they fare price wise in relation to the rest of the companies but with the rebate I reckon they must be one of the cheapest over the year. It would take an awful lot to convince me to change to an alternative supplier!

    Report on 24 January 2009  |  Love thisLove  0 loves

Post a comment

Sign in or register to post a reply.

Our top deals

Credit card
company
Balance transfers rate and period Representative
APR
Apply
now

Barclaycard 27Mth Platinum Visa

0% for 27 months (3.5% fee) Representative 18.9% APR (variable) Apply
Representative example: assumed borrowing of £1,200, representative 18.9% APR (variable). Purchase rate 18.9% PA (variable). BT fee is reduced from 3.9% to 3.5% (T&Cs apply).

Barclaycard 25Mth Platinum Visa

0% for 25 months (2.4% fee) Representative 18.9% APR (variable) Apply
Representative example: assumed borrowing of £1,200, representative 18.9% APR (variable). Purchase rate 18.9% PA (variable). BT fee is reduced from 3.5% to 2.4% (T&Cs apply)

Halifax BT 25 Month MasterCard

0% for 25 months (2.5% fee) Representative 18.9% APR (variable) Apply
Representative example: assumed borrowing of £1,200, representative 18.9% APR (variable). Purchase rate 19.0% PA (variable).
W3C  Thank you for using CGWEBLIV4