Love to be the one to Get the best deal?

Then register for free and get exclusive, personalised benefits that will help you achieve all your money goals.

Join the lovemoney.com experience

Register Now

Confused?

Why Register?

The worst credit cards in Britain

Published 22 June 2010 in Get the best deal

Rachel Robson names and shames three of the worst credit cards on the market. Avoid these cards - or suffer the consequences...

Choosing a credit card isn't always easy. For a start, there are far too many to choose from. And secondly, many credit cards come with sneaky strings attached.

So in this article, I'm going to highlight some of the worst credit cards available, as well as possible alternatives.

Outrageous interest rates

One of the first things you should look out for when choosing a credit card is the rate of interest it charges. Frustratingly, many credit card providers have been sneakily upping their rates recently, and many credit cards - particularly store cards - charge astronomically high Annual Percentage Rates (APR).

One of the worst offenders is the Argos store card which charges 27.9% APR. By contrast, most credit cards charge around 16%.

If you had built up a debt on the Argos card, and could only afford to pay off the minimum monthly repayment (MMR) each month, it would take you a very long time indeed to pay off the balance in full. In fact, if you have a large debt, you may find that it takes decades to pay it off. Now, that's a scary thought.

The alternatives:

One alternative is to choose a 0% balance transfer card such as the Barclaycard Platinum card,  NatWest Platinum Credit Card MasterCard  or Royal Bank of Scotland RBS Platinum Credit Card MasterCard, all of which offer 0% on balance transfers for 15 months. By using these cards, you won't have to pay interest on any balance you transfer until October 2011!

But if you'd prefer to have a credit card that offers a permanently low APR, you could consider signing up for a lifetime balance transfer credit card. These cards offer a low rate of interest for as long as it takes to clear the balance.

One of the best options is the Barclaycard Simplicity Visa which offers a rate of 6.8% for every balance transfer and purchase you make! Simple.

Reward your spending

If you're going to be using your credit card purely for spending purposes, you'll probably like the idea of being rewarded as you spend. So if you enjoy jetting off on holiday every year, you might be tempted by air mile rewards. 

There's just one problem - this isn't always as straightforward as it seems.

Take the Virgin Atlantic Black American Express card for example. This card allows you to collect two Flying Club miles for every £1 you spend, and you'll also be given 6,000 Flying Club miles with your first purchase. You can then use these miles towards a flight.

Sounds great, right? Well, there's a catch. Not only do you have to pay an annual fee of £115 for the card, but when you come to spend your Flying Club miles, you'll find passenger taxes and fees aren't included with the flight. Instead, you'll have to pay for these yourself!

So given that fees and taxes almost always cost more than the price of the flight itself, you're likely to find your bargain trip isn't much of a bargain after all.

The alternatives:

If you're a keen traveller and still want to use a reward credit card for flights, I think a far better option is the fee-free Lloyds TSB Airmiles Duo credit card. This card is part of the Airmiles scheme and you won't have to pay any tax or booking fees.

But my favourite card for purchases is the American Express Platinum Cash Back Card. This fantastic piece of plastic has nothing to do with jet-setting, but simply gives you cashback for spending. In the first three months, you can get 5% cashback, up to £100. After that, you can earn up to 1.5% cashback. All of which you can spend on your holiday...

Dirty tricks

One of my pet hates when it comes to credit cards is the dirty little trick known as negative payment hierarchy. In a nutshell, cards which operate negative payment hierarchy pay off the cheapest debts first, and the most expensive last.

Rachel Robson explains how negative order of payment works and how to avoid it.

Unfortunately many credit cards operate in this way. A classic example is the HSBC Credit Card. This credit card offers an interest-free period for 15 months on balance transfers and three months' 0% interest on new purchases. After that it charges 16.9%.

If you only used this card for a balance transfer, it would offer a very competitive deal. But let's say you transfer your balance of £2,000 onto the card and then start using it for new purchases. You might think that if you repay everything you spend on the card before the first three months is up, you won't have to worry about paying interest. But you'd be wrong.

Instead, thanks to negative payment hierarchy (also known as 'negative order of payment'), your monthly payments will go towards the £2,000 you transferred onto the card - in other words, the interest-free debt. And that means you won't have paid anything towards the new debt you've run up by spending on the card. So once those first three months are up, you'll be hit with an interest rate of 16.9% on this debt. And you won't be able to pay it off, until you've cleared the entire balance you originally transferrred. Ouch!

The alternatives:

One way to get around negative payment hierarchy is to use a credit card that has the same interest-free period for both purchases and balance transfers. And I think the Sainsbury's Finance Mastercard is the perfect choice. This card offers 0% on both balance transfers and purchases for 12 months, so you'll completely avoid negative payment hierarchy. Hurrah!

Alternatively, you could use one credit card for purchases and a separate one for balance transfers. This way, the ordering of payments becomes irrelevant.

But whatever you do when choosing a new credit card, make sure you pick the right one for your needs and don't get caught out by any nasty surprises! If you need any more help choosing a card, remember that here at lovemoney.com you can find out more about the best cards available.

More: The UK's deadliest plastic | Fight the downturn with these credit cards

Enjoyed this? Show it some love

Share this lovemoney.com content on any of the social networks and utilities below by simply clicking the site of your choice.

  • You can subscribe to all lovemoney.com articles via our RSS feed.

Comments

  • 4 recommendations

The RBS Black Credit Card is only offered to people earning £75,000 a year or more, who by and large should know better than to make just the minimum payment.

The APR is distorted by the requirement to include the £250 fee against notional 'standard' borrowings of £1,500 (i.e. one weeks wages for an RBS Black customer!) while completely ignoring the fact that the minimum limit for this card is £15,000.

This is completely spurious because if you pay the £250 fee and make no borrowings at all the APR would be infinite.  All APR figures are not the same, some make for great headlines and poor facts.

Additionally, the annual fee is not a charge for borrowing but levied in order to pay for inculded benefits such as travel insurance, airport lounge access and on-call personal assistance.

Excluding the fee, interest is 1.04% per month (13.15% effective per year)

Overall, a very poorly chosen example.

  • 1 recommendation

A very good point re the APRs.  APRs with annual fees included are not comparable to normal APRs.  There are usually benefits associated with the fee and theat should be looked at separately.  ie is £250 a fair fee for travel insurance, airport lounge access, etc.

Could we not have a section of lovemoney which has properly researched articles, and separate from the light fluff articles like this? I really miss the insight that the Fool used to provide.  All we get now is stories about "Avoid these credit card traps - did  you know if you don't pay back the money immediately they charge you interest for borrowing their money? And they don't like it if you don't pay anything of what you owe at all. Horrendous!"

astron said

  • 0 recommendations

The Virgin Credit Card should also be included to be named and shamed! They do offer a great introductory 0% rate but after this be careful as like most cards they do have a variable interest rate but whereas a lot of cards don't use the possibility they have to change the rates, Virgin will change it and give you 30 days notice of this. The first time they did this to me they raised it to 29.9% and I complained and they lowered it again. Then a few months later the sent another letter advising an increse in interest rates to 35.9% - almost doubling my interest rate. Be careful with this card!!!

ndf9876 said

  • 0 recommendations

And there I was, thinking about the likes of Aqua, Capital One Classic and Vanquis being in this article - instead I see a point about a card I am never likely to own, and yet MORE drivel about the Virgin Credit Card....do Virgin pay for this sites upkeep?

  • 0 recommendations

I aam glad the first poster gave some details, otherwise I would have thought the card shown as an example, was on the lines of Aqua, Capital One Classic and Vanquis.

Virgin One card is shown a lot on thise site, and may be decent for the interest free period, but then again, the people who need these types of deal more than others are the one least likely to get these sorts of cards.

I don't know why this card keeps popping up on a regular basis on this site, maybe a little more help for people trying to reduce their interest rates, with help to move to other cards with less interest would be helpfull, where the banks are not so stringent on their checks or only give cards out to the select few.

whitefiver said

  • 0 recommendations

Be very careful with the Virgin card. I've just cancelled mine as I was 1 day late with a payment (stupid, I know) which meant that the 0% rate was immediately cancelled and my next statement showed a late payment charge of £12 - fair enough and interest of almost £300!!! (I had a balance of around £14k). Fortunately I've had 10 months interest free, with the money offset against my mortgage but even so. Virgin would not consider a refund so I paid it off and closed the account.

  • 2 recommendations

Thank goodness for ThatLindseyGuy - saved me having to point out the distortion caused by the legally required, but occasionally misleading, standardised APR scenario! 

Frankly, I'm a tad disappointed that us subscribers seem to do more research than the writers on some topics! 

Since Fool became Love it seems that an attention grabbing headline is often favoured over an objective and useful article.

stevieg said

  • 0 recommendations

*RANT*

Anyone noticed how many credit card articles like this on LoveMoney have misleading article headlines about scary credit cards and then go on to plug the MBNA Virgin Credit Card...???

Perhaps we should be told how much they make on kick backs when someone applies for the card using their links?

MBNA are a dreadful organisation for raising APRs with little notice and as my learned colleague pointed out above, if you are just one day late with a payment for whatever reason you lose the deal, no negotiation....

As for the RBS Black card, this actually should be a best buy card as RBS/Natwest do not generally stitch people up with interest rate hikes, if you take the annual fee out of the equation the APR is fairly low (in relative terms) and there is NO fee for balance transfers. The fee becomes very good value if you use at least some of the services offered. Only sticking point is the minimum salary requirements of course!

What happened to the impartial articles that made the fool once great??? I don't need 2-3 articles a week recycling the same info with a different headline...!!

*END OF RANT*

Jaguara said

  • 0 recommendations

And the other two worst cards you are supposed to tell us about?? Surely not two of the others mentioned in this article who have the audacity to expect to charge interest after the interest free period!! Whatever next!!

I agree with telecaster100 .... enough of this drivel and lets get those meaty Fool topics back.

  • 0 recommendations

This article has now been amended and the reference to the RBS card has been removed. Apologies for this and thanks for bringing this mistake to my attention.

Seang1965 said

  • 0 recommendations

I think it is a really good idea to pount out negative payment hierarchy.  A lot of people do get caught out with this so it is worth highlighting.  I would like to see companies using tactics like this being "black balled" on this site.  It would be very useful to have a members rating system for credit cards as well as other financial products.

  • 0 recommendations

Hi Seang1965

A few weeks ago we launched credit card reviews (more info about it here).

We haven't yet launched them on comparison table, but you can find them by clicking on 'more' on any credit card on our search table.

Please feel free to review any of the 200+ credit cards we list. The more users who review credit cards, the better for the community!

GaryDean said

  • 0 recommendations

Yes don't forget to mention the Vanquis Vandals. The creeps who prey on those who are desperate exacting 34.9% interest. Pity they don't use the stocks anymore. I'd gladly invest in the rottenest veggies available. Though I'm sure they'd feel quite at home with the stench.

charles125 said

  • 0 recommendations

Capital One and Virgin cards are DREADFUL once past any transfer period. Rates over 25% (And More!!) on bog standard cards are APPALLING......

Also watch out for any minor infringenments, a day late payment, very temporary above limit for any card as the penalty can be several months or more with a complete block on card transfers!  OUCH.....

  • 0 recommendations

you choose the words worst cards  yet you never mention the sharks in the industry vanquis  they prey on the poor they like vultures ready to devour  your last bones god dont ever be late with a payment or go over the limit your phones will ring say and night and you get the rudess woment talking to you llikr your  secont class citizens  they bleed you dry and want more

so come you have the power to go public with these companies who prey on the poor

but all we hear how good virgin is and other ok maybe vanwuis and capitopl dont line your pockets but speak up for your readers its about time you did

woghiren said

  • 0 recommendations

MBNA is simply the worst credit card provider in the UK

They are usually disguised under loyalty card schemes so beware.

Whatever your circumstances you will end up paying 34.9% APR which they claim is justified by current market conditions

Do not use these cards!

Caveat Emptor!

Mike10613 said

  • 0 recommendations

Vanquis charge up to 59.9% and some of the Provident loans are worse. Capital One do a card at 39.9% typical 'to rebuild you credit'; which it won't. 

Then you have the payday loans sharks like www.wonga.com lending at 2689%APR and www.lendingstream.co.uk lending at 2641% APR - it should be illegal. Maybe now the FSA is on it's way to Neverneverland; the Bank of England will REGULATE! 

GEN said

  • 0 recommendations

"names and shames three ....."  which are the three named and shamed in this article?  Recommending others cards?  Off-topic perhaps?

ohmigod said

  • 0 recommendations

What are you are all going on about????  You all obviously live way beyond your means - I will spell it out for you:  you are spending money you haven't yet earned and living a life-style to which you are NOT entitled.   DONT DO IT!!!   Then you wouldnt have to worry about credit card options and APR's etc etc.  ONLY SPEND WHAT YOU EARN !!!!! 

Pay off those cards ASAP and get into the real world!!!!!

Good luck!!!!

GEN said

  • 0 recommendations

A rerun from the Best of Series, no doubt.....

Join the conversation

Please sign in or register to add a comment or recommend.

Our top deals

Credit card
company
Balance transfers rate and period Typical
APR
Apply
now

Barclaycard Platinum with 16 Month BT Visa

0% for 16 months
(2.9% fee)
Typical 16.9% APR (variable) Apply

Virgin Money Credit Card MasterCard

0% for 14 months
(2.98% fee)
Typical 16.6% APR (variable) Apply

Egg Visa

0% until 1st Oct 2011
(3% fee)
Typical 17.9% APR (variable) Apply
W3C  Thank you for using Three Kings