Follow this topicFollow this topic Knowledge » Current accounts

The ultimate current accounts for rate tarts!

John Fitzsimons
by Lovemoney Staff John Fitzsimons on 27 January 2010  |  Comments 23 comments

You've been voting in your droves for the best current accounts. But who has topped the lot for offering the best return on your money?

If there's one financial product you absolutely have to choose wisely, it's your current account. It's the product that you can't get away from - you can live without a credit card or an ISA or a pension (though that's not a great idea), but you'll struggle to get by without a current account. Where would your wages go for a start?

What you look for from a current account may vary. You may be the sort of person that always ends the month in the red, so you need a good, interest-free overdraft facility. Or you may prioritise the service you receive above any other concerns.

But if you are mainly concerned with getting the best possible return on your money, then you should definitely check out the banks covered below. Because more than 2,000 lovemoney.com users have voted them the best around when it comes to interest rates.

Runners up

In third place it's the bank that gives you extra, Halifax, with its very clever Reward Account winning your praise.

Why you gave Halifax a Cheer award

Somewhat paradoxically the best current account from Halifax for getting a great return on your money actually offers an interest rate of 0%. Instead, as long as you pay in at least £1,000 a month, you'll get £5 every month with the Halifax Reward Account.

Over the space of a year, that's a return of a quite marvellous £60. And unlike other current accounts which rely on you maintaining a high level of cash in the account to get some decent interest, with the Reward Account you only have to pay that £1,000 in. It doesn't even matter if you finish each month with a balance of £1 - you'll still get a cracking return!

In second place

The first runner up prize goes to Abbey, which has turned plenty of heads with its Preferred In-Credit Rate Account and Reward Bank Account, both of which pay a magnificent 6%!

Why you gave Abbey a Cheer award

At a time when getting even a moderate return on your money has been a challenge, for Abbey to have two current accounts each paying 6% - miles more than most of its rivals - has been fantastic. Clearly many of you agree.

With the Preferred In-Credit Rate Account, you can benefit from 6% for 12 months on sums up to 2,500. You'll even get a 0% overdraft for the first four months. All you need to do is make sure £1,000 a month is paid in.

It's a similar arrangement with the Reward Account albeit without the interest free overdraft. You'll benefit from a range of extras including annual worldwide family travel insurance, Green Flag breakdown cover and identity theft protection.

However you will have to shell out £10 a month for this account.

And the winner is...

However, the provider which topped our poll is Abbey's Santander stable-mate, Alliance & Leicester, which stole top spot thanks to a cracking range of deals including its Premier Direct account paying 6%.

Why Alliance & Leicester is the best

Alliance & Leicester just edged ahead of its fellow Santander firm, Abbey to win this very competitive award principally because it has a wider range of current accounts that all pay fantastic rates of interest.

The best product it offers is the fantastic Premier Direct account, which boasts a rate of 6% in interest (fixed for a year) on balances up to £2,500, so long as £500 is paid in each month. That's just half the funding requirement of the rival Abbey deal, so it's easy to see why it's more appealing. It even offers an interest-free overdraft for the entire year.

But it's not just the Premier Direct current account. Alliance & Leicester also offers great current accounts tailored for older and younger customers respectively.

There's the Premier 50 current account, a product specifically for the over fifties which also pays a great rate of 6% fixed for a year. Additionally, it offers worldwide annual multi-trip travel insurance up to the age of 79 and a number of health benefits, including two out-patient private medical consultations a year.

However, the account will set you back £10 a month.

For younger customers, there's the Premier 21 current account, paying 5% on balances up to £1,000, with the only requirement that your earnings (wages, allowance, any regular money that you receive) is paid into the account.

Do you agree?

There you have it, the best three current account providers for getting a great return on your money, as voted for by lovemoney.com readers. But do you agree with the results?

Be sure to share your experiences with these and any other current account providers via the comment box below!

Get help from lovemoney.com!

If you are trying to get your finances in shape, there's heaps of ways lovemoney.com can make your life a lot easier!

First up, why not try some of the great hints and tips in this goal: Manage on a small budget

Next, check out this video: Earn £235 extra by switching your savings

And finally, if you have any queries that need answering, why not see if your fellow lovemoney.com readers can help in our Q&A section

More: Where to find the cheapest overdrafts | The top five sneakiest banking tricks

Compare current accounts at lovemoney.com!

Enjoyed this? Show it some love

Twitter
General

Comments (23)

  • plc69
    Love rating 6
    plc69 said

    Unfortunately, both Abbey and Alliance & Leicester regularly come near the bottom of customer satisfaction polls.

    I for one am very unhappy with Abbey and will soon be moving. If you want the 6% on £2,500 for 12 months - then go ahead and open an account - but keep your existing account open as you'll probably want to move back in a year's time...

    Report on 27 January 2010  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • MrRee
    Love rating 65
    MrRee said

    Lloyds Vantage Account - pays 4% on balances between £5k and £7k.

    Report on 27 January 2010  |  Love thisLove  1 love
  • mrsh1807
    Love rating 0
    mrsh1807 said

    I moved to the Alliance & Leicester 1 year ago, lured by the features of the account. I have to say the online servicing functionality is extremely poor and moving money between accounts A&L bank accounts is painful, never mind the time is takes funds to reach a non-A&L account.

    My year is up and I'm desperate to move back to a proper bank account where updates are instant and I can see immediately what my current financial situation is, rather than any transactions I make online taking at least 24 hours to show.

    Anyone recommending this bank account must surely not rely on online banking to run their lives!

    Report on 27 January 2010  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • Yogi the bear
    Love rating 6
    Yogi the bear said

    The Santander deals are rotten. Come on lovemoney, you are supposed to be educating people, not tucking them into duff deals. Sure, the headline rate looks great, but do the maths. Assuming you invest £2500 on day one, you will earn a whopping £154 pa. But, you then need to pay £120 pa to run the account, leaving you with £34, a real return of about 1.4%. Then you'll be taxed on your interest, leaving you with a shade over £27. Not a smahing return on £2500 or just over 1%. Plus, according to plc69 you'll have a miserable experience too.

    You can do better thn this. Go back to the drawingboard and find something that really makes our money work.

    Report on 27 January 2010  |  Love thisLove  3 loves
  • divad
    Love rating 5
    divad said

    The A&L 6% accounts give 5% more than a "normal" 1% account.

    This gives a max. of 4% nett benefit for a tax payer, an absolute max. of £100, reduced to £80 for a higher rate tax payer. It will anyway cost £120 each year.

    You will therefore pay a minimum of £40 the first year, £120 premium thereafter, for a travel insurance which has "small print" limitations not listed on the A&L website. and some limited other benefits. This assumes the account doesn't give a lower rate in future than the normal ccounts.

    Caveat emptor.

    Report on 27 January 2010  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • flapmio
    Love rating 0
    flapmio said

    I'm interested in changing my account to Halifaxs Reward Account and when i went to discuss this with my current bank, Lloyds TSB, they said go right ahead! The reason they gave was that they were going to be taking over Halifax soon and i would still be their customer.

    Can anyone tell me how long this account will last? Is it for life or can Lloyds change the TnCs when they take over?

    Report on 27 January 2010  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • gembellina
    Love rating 0
    gembellina said

    @mrsh1807

    Seconding your comment about poor service, I tried to take out the A+L Premier Direct account, but they sent all the documentation to the wrong address.  As I wasn't able to get to a branch to rectify their mistake and they don't allow address changes by phone or by internet, even after answering their security questions, I couldn't use the account. A friend of mine had the same problem. My boyfriend has just opened an account with them, I wonder if he'll have better luck?

    Report on 27 January 2010  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • Swarbs
    Love rating 273
    Swarbs said

    @flapmio

    Yes they can change the T&Cs, and Halifax themselves could change them if they want at any point. with minimum notice given. They previously had a cashback current account which they changed to the current reward account. I would still switch to Halifax - I doubt Lloyds will change the account for the worse just after taking over, as they would lose a large proportion of their customers as a result. In fact, the reward account was actually launched after Halifax and Lloyds merged, which implies that it could have been part of the consolidation strategy for the two banks, and thus is even more likely to be kept.

    Report on 27 January 2010  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • edscott
    Love rating 0
    edscott said

    I've recently tried to move from the Halifax to Alliance and Leicester.

    Their preformance at switching is appalling. Lost details on one account, and the other still paid out a standing order I asked them to stop!

    All this has taken approximately eight weeks so far and is still not complete!

    No way am I transferring any other monies to them or taking out any insurances etc.

    Anyone any experience of a PROFESSIONAL bank where I can put my hard earned!?

    ED

    Report on 27 January 2010  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • Cazzkins
    Love rating 0
    Cazzkins said

    I'm not interested in any short-term deals and am sticking with Abbey as when I opened my current account there, they promised 'Free Banking for Life'. I'm sure that in the not too distant future we'll all be paying dearly for our current accounts and I'm hoping Abbey will stick to their promise! (Not entirely holding my breath though!) :-)

    Report on 27 January 2010  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • dananad
    Love rating 5
    dananad said

    I opened an Alliance & leicester Premium Direct current account in Sept. I am getting the 6% (less tax) paid monthly. I don't know why some are 'paying £120' per annum. I don't pay anything, though I am required to pay £500 into the account every month.

    The switch over of my Direct Debits did not go smoothly, and I still have on Direct Debit in my old IF account. I also have an Alliance & Leicester On-line Saver 6 where I am keeping 'ready cash' to put into the Stock Market when/as I decide.

    I monitor/use my account on-line every day. There is this 24-hour delay between my Saver 6 and my current account - though strangely if I transfer money from/to my RBS account (I actually also have a Barclays account as well linked to a monthly savings account - and I'm retired) the move from/to RBS shows up instantly. Go figure.

    I haven't decided yet whether I'll keep the Alliance account after the 12 months, but I am happy enough with it right now.

    Report on 27 January 2010  |  Love thisLove  1 love
  • eLJay
    Love rating 76
    eLJay said

    Once again a shoddy marketing attempt, please keep these adverts to yourselves and stop disguising them as articles...

    Report on 27 January 2010  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • tonychaitow
    Love rating 0
    tonychaitow said

    Personally I think the Halifax wins hands down. Their Reward Account gives you the £5 a month on a permanent basis - The Abbey and Alliance & Leicester offers are just for 12 months and then go down to 1% interest which is neither here or there.

    Report on 27 January 2010  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • SannaLar
    Love rating 1
    SannaLar said

    @mrsh1807

    Hear! Hear!

    A&L's internet banking is absolutely dreadful, with transactions only showing up after midnight. It's confusing that your current balance and total balance are different. And you can only make transfer per day to a particular recipient.

    Report on 27 January 2010  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • foolishsceptic
    Love rating 7
    foolishsceptic said

    Yet another blatant plug by lovemoney for Santander - no doubt paid for by the four adverts which appear on my screen surrounding the article. You really must think we are all turning into fools!!!! What won't lovemoney and the fool do to get a bit of dosh - sell your grandmothers? Don't you just love this 'independent' journalism.

    Report on 27 January 2010  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • Donna Ferguson
    Love rating 130
    Donna Ferguson said

    I think some of you are being very unfair.

    Yes, Santander are advertising but as I've said before, that doesn't influence editorial on this site and it never will. We always write what we think about products, and try to highlight the market leaders. Santander came top of a poll of more than 2,000 readers - that is a fact. We offered you the chance to rate every current provider in Britain, and that was the result. Your result, not ours.

    Would you rather we didn't write about results of the poll if the brand is advertising with us, for fear of just such criticism?

    Obviously the site has to make money to provide free content, and affiliate links and advertising are ways that we use to do that. But we always write what we think and have in the past heavily criticised brands that are advertising with us - for example, Aviva last year in

    Britain's worst insurer! - despite the fact that Aviva were indeed advertising with us at the time and indeed on that very page!

    Hope that clears things up.

    thanks

    Donna

    Report on 27 January 2010  |  Love thisLove  1 love
  • liesarenocomfort
    Love rating 134
    liesarenocomfort said

    I agree with MrRee, check out Lloyds - I don't keep as much as him in my LLoyds classic plus current account but it still pays 2.47% gross which is not to be sniffed at, and there isn't the nonsense of switching after a year when rates plummet. I've always found Lloyds customer service good and have been with them for 20 odd years. Not sure about the shares though.

     

      

    Report on 28 January 2010  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • nosbort
    Love rating 126
    nosbort said

    I was quite impressed a while ago by the advertising from Alliance and Leicester for 'free' business banking and even tried to open an account but they are so incompetent that despite my attempts they failed to get me as a customer. The reasons were centered around their paperwork sent in the post which is utterly inflexible in its insistence that a limited company must have 2 authorised signatories for a bank account and that the person making the application MUST be the company secretary. The paperwork further insists that the details MUST NOT BE AMMENDED, however, when I called to ask for a corrected set of paperwork I was told to ammend the set I had and post it. If this is typical of Santander's competence and attention to detail I want nothing to do with them.

    Report on 28 January 2010  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • rjkelsall
    Love rating 0
    rjkelsall said

     I have the Halifax reward account and if used properly it is up there with the best. After having my wages paid into it I immediately transfer them into another account. This still bags me the fiver every month with the account practically empty most of the time.

    However I must stress to anyone that the account is only worthwhile if you NEVER go into the red with it. Any authorised overdraft upto £2500 charges you £1 a day, over £2500 is £2 a day. Any unauthorised overdraft costs £5 a day.

     These fees kick in regardless of how little you are overdrawn. Therefore being a couple of pence overdrawn for 5 days would completely wipe out your £5 reward. If you are overdrawn for longer than this then you are losing money. So in my opinion this account is great if you make it work for you. Make a couple of mistakes and you will rack up some pretty hefty charges. I'm sure that this is what Halifax will be banking on.

    Report on 28 January 2010  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • grannymabe
    Love rating 1
    grannymabe said

    As Mr Ree says, Lloyds TSB pays 4% as long as your balance is between £5K and £7K, and that's on the entire balance. So if you keep your balance topped up to £7K, you can earn £280 pa, less tax, £224. I'm a non tax payer so my share on our joint account is paid gross. You also get access to LTSB Incentive saver account which pays 3% for months you don't dip into it, or their e-savings account paying 2.5% where we keep a bit of top-up money for the current a/c. I haven't found a more attractive deal yet and their service is excellent.

    Report on 30 January 2010  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • nobax
    Love rating 1
    nobax said

    I moved from the Halifax high interest account a year ago, when it was paying almost no interest to the A&L Premier Direct . My year is up and I am looking for another high paying account. I had no problems transferring cash between accounts. My gripe is how when they update at midnight and apply the debits before credits and this can sometimes show insufficient funds for which they want to charge a daily fee.

    Report on 30 January 2010  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • SiGl26
    Love rating 26
    SiGl26 said

    I'm a very satisfied A&L Premier Direct customer. The switch (from cahoot) was seamless and painless; they even picked up 'dormant' payees with whom I'd had long past transactions. Am I the outlier, or is it only the whiners who post? Coming to the end of the year now, and I'll be switching to Abbey... [yes, I know I can't go direct from A&L to Abbey]

    Contrary to several posts, there is no account management fee, and it is part of the 'faster-payment' scheme; on-line debits paid to my other current account arrive instantly, as do credits from other faster-payment participants.

    All my online accounts show differing 'available balance' (including overdraft, excluding uncleared credits) and 'current balance' amounts, but if you look beyind the headline summmary this is crystal clear.

    Report on 04 February 2010  |  Love thisLove  1 love
  • Foolabc123
    Love rating 0
    Foolabc123 said

    I think some people have confused the Premier Direct account and the other account for over 50's - they both pay 6% but the over 50's account is £10 a month because it has add ons like insurances etc - the Premier Direct is 'free'

    I have a Premier Direct and have had no probs with the online banking - works well for me

    I chose A&L because it has better overdraft terms than Halifax as it's free for a year and then the charges after a year are less - tend to dip in at the end of the month

    Report on 15 February 2010  |  Love thisLove  0 loves

Post a comment

Sign in or register to post a reply.

Our top deals

Provider & account name Credit rate (AER)
Based on £1
Overdraft
rate

Based on £1
Apply
now

Santander 123 Current Account

0.0% 0% plus £1.00 per day usage fee Apply

Barclays Bank Account

N/A Up to £200 – 0% interest pa (variable). Over £200 and up to £5,000 – 19.3% interest pa (variable) Apply

first direct 1st Account

N/A 0% Apply
W3C  Thank you for using CGWEBLIV4