Follow this topicFollow this topic Knowledge » Credit cards

The very best card to take on holiday

Jane Baker
by Lovemoney Staff Jane Baker on 21 July 2009  |  Comments 23 comments

If you're going on holiday, this is the best card to use abroad, with no fees for withdrawing cash and no hidden currency charges!

The very best card to take on holiday

THIS ARTICLE IS NOW OUT OF DATE. FOR THE LATEST ON TRAVEL MONEY OPTIONS, READ The best debit cards to use abroad, The best credit cards to use abroad and The best prepaid cards for spending abroad.

Welcome to our second daily installment of Holiday Week, where we'll show you how can save money on your travels. In this article, I'll be looking at a new way of spending on holiday.

If you're sick of paying sky high charges when you use your debit or credit card abroad, and travellers' cheques are just way too inconvenient, a prepaid currency card could be the answer.

How do prepaid currency cards work?

Once you've chosen a card, your spending money can be pre-loaded before you go away. You can load the card with Euros, US dollars or Sterling. Then you can top it up with extra cash whenever you need to. It's easy as that.

The great thing about prepaid cards is they're a safer way to take money abroad with you because they aren't linked to your current account. If your card is ever lost or stolen, you don't need to panic because you can block it and ask for a replacement.

What's more, your card can be used in lots of restaurants, shops and other outlets as well as for taking out cash at ATMs, so it'll be the only card you need as you head off for sunnier climes.

Which prepaid currency card should you choose?

There are lots of prepaid current cards out there, such as the Travelex Cash Passport, the FairFX Currency Card and the Post Office Travel Card. In fact, I could do a huge comparison table to show you the pros and cons of each. But, I think there's only one real contender: the Caxton FX Currency Card.

Caxton FX offers three cards, two of which can be loaded with Euros or US dollars. There's also a Global Traveller card which can be loaded with sterling and used anywhere in the world if you're going somewhere more exotic on your hols. Then you simply use it like any other card. When you run out of money on the card, you can top it up online, over the phone or even by text message.

What's more, if you're unfortunate enough to lose the card, your money should be secure because it's chip and PIN protected. For a small fee of around £5, Caxton will aim to send you a replacement card within 24 hours.

So, why do I think Caxton FX is a star buy?

Well firstly, the card offers a competitive exchange rate on your currency. Better still, there's a guarantee which means if you can find cheaper travel money anywhere else, they'll refund the difference. You can't say fairer than that!

At the time of writing, another competitive currency card provider - Fair FX - were actually quoting a better exchange rate on Euros and US dollars. So make sure you check them out first, and the other generally competitive choices such as the Post Office, ICE and Travelex. Then if Caxton's own rates aren't quite as good, ask them to match it.

Secondly, you won't be charged a host of extra fees which would otherwise drive up the cost of your holiday money. There are no fees for the card itself, no commission charges and no charges on items you buy abroad either. You'll find some of the other cards tend to slap on additional fees left, right and centre, destroying what looks like a good deal on the surface.

As if all that wasn't enough, Caxton FX has recently abolished all charges on taking money out at ATMs abroad. This is huge step forward because cash point withdrawals on pre-paid card used to be pricey, costing €2 or $3 each time.

In fact, the Caxton card is still the only pre-paid card I can find which doesn't charge an ATM fee.

And finally, the Caxton Currency Card is a Mastercard which means it's accepted at millions of retailers around the world.

Alternatives

What other cards are good to use abroad?

Well, there's the Nationwide debit card - long a favourite of ours here at lovemoney.com - but sadly, Nationwide now charges at 1% transaction fee on all transactions and withdrwals outside Europe.

There's also the Abbey Zero card. With this card, you pay no extra fees for purchases made abroad or online in a different currency. You can also withdraw money from an ATM without paying any fees... but because this card is a credit card, you'll start incurring interest at a whopping 27.9% APR the moment you withdraw your money! So it's definitely not a good idea to use this card to withdraw cash abroad, even if you pay your bill off in full each month.

So, when it comes to fees and charges, the Caxton Currency Card beats both these cards hands down.

Is it perfect?

Not quite! On the downside, the card must be preloaded with a minimum of £100 and every top-up must be at least £100 too. This is quite a lot higher than some of its rivals including the Fair FX Prepaid Mastercard which can be topped up with just £10.

This might be a tad inconvenient if you're getting to the end of your holiday, and you only want to put a little extra cash on the card before returning home.

If you want to get a refund of unused cash after your holiday, it'll cost £10, although this fee isn't unusual. And you must have at least £10 on the card before you can redeem your balance. So it's not as flexible a friend as it could be.

But overall, I would say the Caxton FX Currency Card is very cheap and easy to use. In fact, it's the (almost) perfect holiday companion!

More: Make money from your holiday | Five ways to save money on your summer holiday!

Apply for the Caxton Currency Card in time for your holiday!

Enjoyed this? Show it some love

Twitter
General

Comments (23)

  • SmudgeButt
    Love rating 83
    SmudgeButt said

    I have never seriously considered a currency card before so I was interested to see the Caxton Global card - would have been perfect for my recent trip to both the US & Canada (as they seem to consider Canada an exotic location!! mother will be pleased!!!).

    But looking on line there is a little comment in the description that states The exchange rate applied is fixed at 2.5% from the prevailing interbank rate. Now what does that mean? Sounds like you are paying an extra 2.5% fee to me. I know that exchange rates vary off the bank rate so the buy/sell spread makes money for someone but didn't think it was as much as 2.5%.

    I might consider one of these in any case - perhaps a Euro one as most hotels in Austria do not take any credit cards at all. Does anyone know if there is a dormancy fee? I would be happy to leave a small credit on there to wait for the next trip same as I always have small amounts of notes and coins left after a trip.

    Report on 21 July 2009  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • SiGl26
    Love rating 26
    SiGl26 said

    Smudgebutt - the currency comparison site I use (http://www.oanda.com/convert/classic - others are available, as the BBC would say) suggests a 'typical credit card rate' of Interbank +2%, and a 'typical cash rate' of Interbank +4%, so the Caxton spread looks somewhere between the two. 

    Can the Caxton card be used in Mastercard outlets in the UK? This would remove the need to pay the exhorbitant fee to redeem your money from it...

    And what evidence does it need to 'match better rates'?

    Report on 21 July 2009  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • gordonbanks42
    Love rating 11
    gordonbanks42 said

    Can I load this card with USD and spend in (say) USD or Euros?

    We earn modest sums in USD and I am always interested in ways of spending the USD without converting them into GBP first, as the exchange rates can be unhelpful at times.

    Report on 21 July 2009  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • kostlin
    Love rating 0
    kostlin said

    gordanbanks42:- You could use the Global Traveller card? (https://www.caxtonfxcard.com/cards_description.asp?dist=CAXTGENL)

    Report on 21 July 2009  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • tribalthunder
    Love rating 0
    tribalthunder said

    I started using the

    Cactus card (www.cactuscard.co.uk) recently after i was told about a

    promotion over the summer. It has no additional fees when i use it

    abroad, and the exchange is at market rate....today for the Euro that's

    1.15673 compared with Caxton's 1.1330 or NatWest's 1.0959.

    My account is held in pounds, so i can still use it back in the

    UK without penalty - given that i travel a lot for work to different

    countries, this has been a great product.

    Report on 21 July 2009  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • kostlin
    Love rating 0
    kostlin said

    tribalthunder: does this card have any joining or other hidden fees / expenses?

    Report on 21 July 2009  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • shind
    Love rating 0
    shind said

    there is one small flaw to your no charges cards i have recently had 3 weeks in thailand,and whilst my flex account card charged me nothing the atm machines themselves,charged 150 baht(3 quid)per transaction,so i got really stung,so it is back to travellers cheques for me

    Report on 21 July 2009  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • Honky81
    Love rating 4
    Honky81 said

    shind,

    I ought to remember that this was discussed on an other article - I believe this to be a Thailand banks specific problem, rather than a problem from the card issuer.

    I have never been there and tried to search for the article but couldn't find it so... anybody else got an opinion/experience?

    Report on 21 July 2009  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • dangriffin1983
    Love rating 0
    dangriffin1983 said

    I really like the idea of these things as they seem to be a much better option that taking the credit card away or the seemingly obsolete travellers cheque. But I'm going away for a gap year and need something to take with me.. places include india, thailand,australia and mexico so variety of currencies used.. anyone got any suggestions?

    Report on 21 July 2009  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • msmoneywise
    Love rating 27
    msmoneywise said

    Tribalthunder, the cactus card seems to have a list of fees. It charges for loading, ATM withdrawls, foreign exchange fee (2.75%) and also admin, personal data inspection, etc. I wonder how it compares with caxton after all these are taken into account. Anyone tried both??

    Report on 21 July 2009  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • neepdocker
    Love rating 0
    neepdocker said

    One problem with foreign ATMs that you do need to watch out for (I got caught out in Norway) During processing of your withdrawal you get asked confusing questions about how the transaction exchange is calculated e.g in euros or pounds. I believe you have to state pounds or you suffer a charge. Easy to get caught out when it is unexpected and there is a queue waiting behind you. This will probably be the same for all preloaded cards.

    span.jajahWrapper { font-size:1em; color:#B11196; text-decoration:underline; } a.jajahLink { color:#000000; text-decoration:none; } span.jajahInLink:hover { background-color:#B11196; }

    Report on 21 July 2009  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • RayR22
    Love rating 3
    RayR22 said

    WARNING: Always read the T&Cs

     

    The Caxton Card seems to be a useful addition to the traveller’s financial toolbox. However, before getting carried away with its benefits we need to make a fairer comparison than given in the article.

     

    Buried in the Caxton T&Cs are Fee Summaries where under Service Fees you will find there is a Foreign Exchange (FX) Mark Up of 2.5% per transaction when using the card for a currency other than that of the card.

     

    The Euro Card is good in countries who use the Euro currency BUT there is the 2.5% FX Mark Up charge in other ‘local’ countries where you may holiday (e.g. Sweden, Switzerland, Egypt, Turkey and, of course, the UK).

     

    Similarly, the Dollar Card is good for the USA but stray into Canada or Mexico and that 2.5% FX Mark Up charge kicks in.

     

    The Global Card is really the same as either of the other two with a 2.5% FX Mark Up charge for ALL transactions (as far as I can tell).

     

    So the Caxton cards still seem quite good but perhaps not the best in all circumstances.

     

    So, how does Caxton fare in Eurozone and Dollarland?

    I estimate that their exchange rate is about 2.5% less than the Sterling Rate (which is substantially better than the Tourist Rate). I don’t know exactly how much the Visa network exchange rate is below the Sterling Rate but the Visa Inc. website shows it as almost identical. So when comparing like with like the Nationwide cards are better within Eurozone and, even with the 0.84% Visa charge, better outside Eurozone (very much better outside Eurozone and the USA). Note that Nationwide abandoned uplifting the Visa charge (from 0.84%) to 1% from 1st July.

    Example: 22nd July - £ to Euro:

    Visa network = 1.16 (excluding bank fee);

    Nationwide = 1.15 (including 0.84%); 1.16 in Europe;

    Caxton = 1.133

     

    As a Nationwide debit card holder, I think I will stick to using their credit card for purchases and their debit card for cash withdrawals.

    Report on 22 July 2009  |  Love thisLove  1 love
  • kostlin
    Love rating 0
    kostlin said

    Nice one RayR22: do you know how Nationwide exchange rates fair

    with other currencies other than €, $, £? or would they also be very competitive

    ?

    Report on 22 July 2009  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • mikailb2
    Love rating 0
    mikailb2 said

    I am planning to visit Moscow where my Girl friend lives  and where i will stay for 40 days or so and think It would be a good idea to  take  a dollar  card with me .I wonder if anyone has comments  good or bad  about that idea.

    Report on 22 July 2009  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • RayR22
    Love rating 3
    RayR22 said

    Kostlin,

    It's not a Nationwide exchange rate on their cards, it's the Visa network exchange rate which seems pretty close to (or the same as) the Sterling Rate as published in the newspapers (NOT the tourist rate). All traded currencies are covered.

    As mentioned, Nationwide add a fee of 0.84% on FX transactions outside Europe (that's Europe as opposed to the Eurozone) thereby reducing the exchange rate a little.

    If you want to see the Visa network exchange rates conversions go to:

    http://www.corporate.visa.com/pd/consumer_services/consumer_ex_rates.jsp

    Report on 22 July 2009  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • hsb79
    Love rating 0
    hsb79 said

    I am lucky enough to be travelling to Peru and Bolivia later in the year. I am interested in these cards, but can't see at the moment, whether they are the best way to carry money to countries outside the Eurozone, or US Dollar places.

    Have I missed something, or is there further information I need to be looking for?

    Ta,

    hsb

    Report on 22 July 2009  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • RayR22
    Love rating 3
    RayR22 said

    Mikailb2,

    It would an unecessary additional cost to convert £ to $ then $ to Roubles. If you are using Caxton, to minimise fees only use Euro Card in countries whose currency is the Euro (€); only use the Dollar Card in the USA; for other countries use the Global Traveller Card. 

    If you want to withdraw cash whilst there then the Nationwide debit card is still best as far as I am concerned. Of course, you would need a Nationwide current account (Flexaccount) to get the card. Failing that then the Caxton Global Traveller card is still pretty good - it's actually a Sterling card, so withdrawals in Russia will be converted from Sterling (I would estimate that the exchange rate would be about 4% worse than with the Nationwide debit card)

    Credit card for purchases: Abbey Zero, then Nationwide 

    Report on 22 July 2009  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • tribalthunder
    Love rating 0
    tribalthunder said

    To MS Moneywise...in my experience, all cards charge these sorts of fees. They don't operate in the same way as traditional banks so this is how they make their money. There is a range that charge monthly administration fees and others that charge for useage i.e. loading or for purchases.

    As far as Cactus, then there is a foreign exchange fee quoted but this is currently being waived. So basically this is charged to my account and then refunded. Not sure why they charged it in the first place, but mine's not to reason why!

    Having re-read the site, this isn't necessarily very clear. But then i was sent it on the promotional email which is probably why. I have to say, i am a friend of one of the directors who asked me to try it, so did get a little more personal explanation.

    As far as fees for things like data inspection, then i think if you read most company t&c's you will find that there is a set fee they will ask you for this. I think there is provision under the data protection act, or whatever. The reality is i'm not sure how often you request such information, but i rarely do so don't get affected by this. On the plus side, i think they have been very open with all the charges - possibly to their own detriment?

    Report on 23 July 2009  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • gardener
    Love rating 25
    gardener said

    Just used the post office Euro card very successfully in France, Belgium, Netherlands, Germany and Austria. It was accepted everywhere, and when I ran out, someone in England topped it up for me just using my card number. Minimum amount is £50. I will definitely use this again and in fact when two of my children are travelling abroad this summer I will get them a card each with spending money.

    Would be very interested in hearing about a card one can use in the non-euro zone, which is not a debit or credit card.

    Report on 31 July 2009  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • daytrader33
    Love rating 1
    daytrader33 said

    i'm generally a fan of the nationwide debit and credit cards and used them extensively whilst travelling in brazil for 3 months, fees extremely low and card accepted everywhere.

    my only complaint is that the visa rates are not particularly competitive. as someone who has traded fx as a day job for a hedge fund previously, i obviously kept an eye on the rates intraday...for the BRL this can be a volatile ccy. several times on withdrawals or credit card transactions i noted that the visa rate applied to my account was well away from the rate at the time of transaction.

    could be that they only bulk retail flow up and process at the end of the day but my suspicions are that they pick the most favourable rate intraday. for example i noticed once a rate applied to my card that would have been impossible at the time of the transaction. i queried nationwide and their response was: "speak to visa they control your rates. their number is on visa.com" (seriously!) when i replied to tell them that i had no direct relationship with visa and that nationwide as my credit and debit card provider should look into it....they went suddenly quiet and said they would look into it (surprise surprise nothing from them yet and this was several months ago!)

    Report on 30 August 2009  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • Gavster
    Love rating 1
    Gavster said

    This is a great looking card and I have just applied for the EUR and USD version. However, I think the article should point out that there is a risk if the Newcastle Building Society goes bust - you would lose any balance loaded up on your card and you are not covered by the FSCS.

    Report on 20 September 2009  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • Irmajo
    Love rating 0
    Irmajo said

    Surprised that there is no mention of the Post Office version.  Based on advice from this article, I purchased a Post Office money (euro) card and used it successfully in Portugal a month ago NOT at an atm but as a debit card in a store. Was so pleased with the result that I have now got a sterling card as well and used it last week also as a debit card. I find it an oddity, however, that there is a charge to take out a sterling card but not the euro version. (Got great advice and help from the cashier in the post office I used.)

    Report on 27 September 2009  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • hol
    Love rating 0
    hol said

    I use the caxton fx card in the dollar and euro version as i do travel every year. I find the caxton fx card always has the best exchange rate available and i cant beat it any where. There are no atm charges. Try it i think its the best card on the market, you get some great offers with it too as it is recognised as a mastercard.

    Report on 05 August 2010  |  Love thisLove  0 loves

Post a comment

Sign in or register to post a reply.

Our top deals

Provider & account name Credit rate (AER)
Based on £1
Overdraft
rate

Based on £1
Apply
now

Santander 123 Current Account

0.0% 0% plus £1.00 per day usage fee Apply

Barclays Bank Account

N/A Up to £200 – 0% interest pa (variable). Over £200 and up to £5,000 – 19.3% interest pa (variable) Apply

first direct 1st Account

N/A 0% Apply
W3C  Thank you for using CGWEBLIV2