Lovemoney.com
Sign in Register
Cookie policy
Follow this topicFollow this topic Knowledge » Cars

Why we should all buy German cars

Robert Powell
by Lovemoney Staff Robert Powell on 23 January 2012  |  Comments 35 comments

German manufacturers have swept the board at the latest What Car? magazine awards ceremony...

Why we should all buy German cars

Those prone to European economic envy should look away now.

The German economy has somewhat bucked the doom-laden trend established throughout Europe in 2011. Growth in the country has increased robustly. And this has in turn has shrunk the public deficit. Unemployment levels have also ducked.

Depressing, I know.

The reason for this success? Commentators have in part put it down to the country’s range of world class companies.

So it may come as no surprise to hear that the jewels in Germany’s business crown - car manufacturers - have cleaned up at the 2012 What Car? awards. Yes, German automobile companies took ten of 16 category wins, as well as the overall prize for car of the year.

Car of the year

Volkswagen’s 'up!' picked up the award for car of the year. The model is on sale in the UK from March starting at £7,995 for the three doors 'Take up!' model. According to What Car? the up! has a fuel economy of 60.1mpg, a top speed of 100mph and is in insurance group five (the lower the group, the lower the insurance cost).

The magazine’s editor-in-chief Chas Hallet said: “The Volkswagen up! is the best car we've seen this year because it combines refinement, quality, space and economy. It sets new standards for the £10,000 price bracket. It feels at home in town and copes admirably on the motorway; it is the right car for the time.”

The up! also took best city car as well as the safety award for its innovative ‘City Emergency Braking System’. The feature watches the road while at low speeds and applies the emergency brakes if you are about to drive into the car ahead.

Volkswagen’s fourth award was in the best small family car category, given to the Golf for the fourth year in a row.

Other German winners

Audi emerged from the awards as another successful German brand, picking up three awards. The A1 – winner of last year’s car of the year award – was named best supermini, the TT was awarded best coupe, while the TT Roadster took best convertible.

Best SUV went to the BMW X3. What Car? praised the 50mpg fuel efficiency of the model. BMW also took best executive car for the 3-Series. The German group of ten was completed by the Mercedes-Benz S Class, winner of the best luxury car award.

The rest

Ford was the next most successful make at the awards. The American manufacturer’s Mondeo took two awards: best family car and best estate car. What Car? praised the spacious nature of both models, along with their handling and fuel efficiency.

Renault picked up its only award for the Megane, winner of the best hot hatch category.

The MPV prize was given to the Seat Alahambra. The magazine did criticise the model’s visual shape but said that the square lines did allow for better manoeuvring and parking.

Porsche’s 911 won out in the sports category. But with a price tag of over £80,000, would you expect anything less?

The low carbon, fuel consumption award was given to Kia. What Car? highlighted the Rio as an example of one of the manufacturer’s models that prices up well (at £11,415) and boasts a good interior, while also emitting a small amount of CO2.

The MG 6 hatch picked up the best security award for its new alarm and immobiliser system, a feature that comes complete with perimeter detection.

And finally the readers' award for the most exciting car set to hit the market in 2012 was given to the Jaguar C-X16. The model will be unveiled at the Geneva motor show in the spring and is expected to have a price tag starting at around £50,000.

Do you agree?

Do you agree with these awards? Are German cars really the best?

Have your say using the comment box below.

The What Car? Awards 2012 full results

Car of the year and best city car: Volkswagen up!

Best Supermini: Audi A1.

Best Small Family Car: Volkswagen Golf.

Best Family Car: Ford Mondeo.

Best Estate Car: Ford Mondeo.

Best Sports Car: Porsche 911.

Best MPV: Seat Alahambra.

Best Coupe: Audi TT.

Best Hot Hatch: Renault Megane.

Best SUV: BMW X3.

Best Executive Car: BMW 3-series.

Best Convertible: Audi TT Roadster.

Best Luxury Car: Mercedes-Benz S Class.

Fuel Consumption Award: Kia

Car Safety Award: Volkswagen up! braking system.

Car Security Award: MG 6.

Reader Award (most exciting car to be launched in 2012): Jaguar C-X16.

More: Married women are worse drivers | Buy a used car cheaply | Ten rip-offs that drive motorists mad

Enjoyed this? Show it some love

Twitter
General

Comments (35)

  • yocoxy
    Love rating 70
    yocoxy said

    I had this car and it was unreliable

    I had that car and it didn't go wrong.

    Therefore that car was better than this car.

    The What Car survey is about the driving experience in a brand new car but this thread is full of reliability anecdotes.

    Most reliable car I've owned? A BMW 3 series and Toyota Celica were both faultless in three years from new.

    Least reliable? A Ford Escort.

    The best car I've owned? A Chysler Crossfire. I still own it.

    Occasional problems but great fun to drive, I find it a good looking car (that middle aged student Clarkson disagreed). It's 80% Mercedes parts, was built in Germany but is it an American car? Frankly, I don't care.

    Report on 01 February 2012  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • Rob G
    Love rating 0
    Rob G said

    Absolutely agree with alexms, although it's great to see JLR and Nissan successfully exporting around 80% of the cars they manufacture in the UK, (with high percentage local parts supplier content).

    I would also like to point out that JLR has won "many" prestigious awards in Germany, (including the Jaguar XF winning best car in it's category by the respected motoring magazine Auto Motor Und Sport) and look at the success of the Evoque, (which I currently have on order). I personally do not think the BMW X1, X3s and Audi Qs are in the same league, but hey I'm patriotic!

    I guess private buyers have to make up their own minds, but I do think it's an insult to those working in the automotive industry, who see the public sector importing so many cars, (including the police) that they pay for with taxes from their hard earned cash. The public sector could be playing their part in getting the youth unemployment rate down in this country and generating the additional taxes they need for public service funding. We have so much talent going to waste with 20% youth unemployment.

    BTW: An interesting observation is that for all the awards British manufacturers have received in Germany, the Germans buy German, primarily I suspect, because they are patriotic!

    I actually expect to see vehicle manufacturing in the UK boom over the next 10 years, but primarily because the cars are being exported. It's a shame that the Brits do not seem to have faith and continue to import so many cars from abroad. Clearly all the talent exists in the UK, (look at F1) and most multinational car manufacturers have design & development in the UK.

    Report on 08 April 2012  |  Love thisLove  0 loves

Post a comment

Sign in or register to post a reply.

Related content

Our top deals

Credit card
company 		Balance transfers rate and period Representative
APR 		Apply
now

Barclaycard 22Mth Platinum Visa

0% for 22 months (2.9% fee) Representative 17.9% APR (variable) Apply
Representative example: assumed borrowing of £1,200, representative 17.9% APR (variable). Purchase rate 17.9% PA (variable). Refund offer reduces handling fee from 2.9% to equivalent 1.7% (Ts&Cs apply)

Virgin Money MasterCard

0% for 20 months (2.99% fee) Representative 16.8% APR (variable) Apply
Representative example: assumed borrowing of £1,200, representative 16.8% APR (variable). Purchase rate 16.8% PA (variable).

Barclaycard Low Fee Platinum Visa

0% for 17 months (1.6% fee) Representative 18.9% APR (variable) Apply
Representative example: assumed borrowing of £1,200, representative 18.9% APR (variable). Purchase rate 18.9% PA (variable).
W3C  Thank you for using The Four Horsemen of the Apocalypse