The cars that depreciate the fastest

Rachel Wait
by Lovemoney Staff Rachel Wait on 11 July 2011  |  Comments 18 comments

If you're buying a new car, don't lose more money than necessary!

The cars that depreciate the fastest

Buying a car can be pretty exciting. After all, who doesn’t like the idea of whizzing around town in a shiny new automobile?

There’s just one problem: If you are buying a brand new car, the price of that car is likely to plummet the minute you drive off the forecourt. As depressing as it sounds, the minute you get into your new car and drive away, the value of your car can drop by thousands of pounds.

What’s more, Which? reckons cars only retain around 40% of their original purchase price after a typical three years and 36,000 miles of ownership, although some are worth a lot less than that.

This means that you’re actually better off buying a used car rather than one that’s brand new. That said, if you really do want to buy a new car, it’s worth noting that some cars depreciate in value far quicker than others. And as a result, these are the ones you should avoid!

The cars that lose you money

Which? recently carried out some research to reveal which cars are the worst offenders when it comes to depreciation. So let’s take a closer look at which cars lose their value the quickest.

These have been broken down into categories – superminis, medium cars, large cars, luxury cars, MPVs (multi-purpose vehicles), 4x4s/SUVs (sports utility vehicles) and sports cars. The table below highlights the worst offender in each category:

Category

Car

List price

Discounted price

Resale value

Other info

Superminis

Proton Savvy 1.2 Style

£8,151

£8,151

£1,956 (24%)

No discounts when new, and lack of interest in used market.

Medium cars

Proton Gen-2 Persona 1.6 4-door

£11,230

£11,230

£2,808 (25%)

Will only be worth a quarter of what you’ve paid after three years!

Large cars

Cadillac BLS 2.0T Elegance 4-door

£23,155

£18,987

£5,326 (28%)

You might get an 18% new discount, but you’ll still lose out!

Luxury cars

Chrysler 300C 6.1 V8 SRT-8 4-door auto

£44,910

£44,910

£10,778 (24%)

In its final year of sale, but there are still no discounts!

MPVs

Fiat Scudo Panorama 2.0 Multijet 163

£29,415

£29,415

£7,354 (25%)

No discount offered, and very cheap to buy used.

4x4s /SUVs

Nissan Murano 3.5 V6

£38,595

£33,964

£10,807 (32%)

Even after a 12% discount, you’ll still lose 68% of its value over three years!

Sports car

Alfa Romeo Brera 3.2 V6 JTS Q4

£32,878

£32,878

£9,535 (29%)

Not highly regarded on the used market.

Source: Which?

So now you know you should stay well clear of these cars, unless you want to lose thousands of pounds! But what are the alternatives? Are there any cars that hold their value a little better?

The cars that hold their value best

The table below highlights the best car for each of the categories used above.

Category

Car

List price

Discounted price

Resale value

Other info

Superminis

Mini Cooper SD Chili/Sport/Media Pack

£23,110

£21,261

£14,097 (66%)

This car holds its value better than any other on the market.

Medium cars

Honda Civic 1.8 i-VTEC Ci 5-door

£14,610

£12,126

£7,451 (61%)

Highly sought-after second-hand.

Large cars

Mercedes-Benz C220 CDI BlueEfficiency Sport

£30,975

£28,342

£14,868 (52%)

Very popular car when used.

Luxury cars

Mercedes-Benz E63 AMG 4-door

£73,415

£70,478

£35,973 (51%)

Another popular car on the used market. Be warned though, there are big running costs.

MPVs

Ford S-Max 2.0 TDCi 163 Titanium X Sport

£28,695

£24,678

£13,774 (56%)

Automatic diesels are in big demand second-hand.

4x4s/SUVs

Land Rover Discovery 4 3.0 SDV6 GS Auto

£36,745

£34,540

£19,842 (57%)

Still in big demand on the used car market.

Sports cars

Audi TT Coupe 2,0 TFSI Sport

£27,130

£24,417

£14,650 (60%)

Holds its value very well.

Source: Which?

If you’d prefer an estate car, the best car here is the BMW 320d (184bhp) Touring Sport Plus Edition. The listed price is £31,720, while the discounted price is £26,101 and the residual value is £14,272 (55% of its original price).

So if you are after a new car, the sensible decision would be to choose one of these cars as at least they hold onto their value more than others. That said, given the price of many of these vehicles, you may need to win the lottery before purchasing one!

Tips for buying a new car

If you are planning to buy a new car, make sure you follow these top tips to ensure you’re getting the best deal.

1. Do your research

Before buying a car, you should always take the time to research what price you should expect to pay so that you don’t get ripped off. Check out sites such as AutoTrader to make sure you are paying the best price.

Rachel Robson takes a look at which car brands come out best in terms of value for money.

2. Set a budget and stick to it

Work out exactly what you can afford to spend on a new car. Sit down and work out a budget to help you assess this.

Once you’ve decided the maximum limit you can go up to, ensure you don’t go over this amount. If you’re not getting the price you want for the car, walk away and don’t be tempted to pay more.

3. Test drives

You may not be able to test drive the actual car you’re buying, but you should be able to test drive a similar one. So ask the dealer to let you test drive a car that’s as similar as possible to the one you have your eye on.

Once you’re in the car, don’t just drive it around the block. If the dealer will let you, see if you can borrow the car for an evening to give you more of a feel for what the car would be like to drive regularly.

4. Think about additional costs

Don’t forget to keep in mind the cost of car insurance and tax. The cost of these will depend on what type of car you have. Generally, the larger the engine size on the car, the more you’ll be paying in insurance. Meanwhile, tax is charged according to CO2 emissions.

If you’d like to know which car insurance group your chosen car will fall into, take a look at the Association of British Insurers’ Database. For tax bands, check out this page on the Directgov website.

Related how-to guide

Buy a car for less

A car is a significant purchase. Take your time and ensure that you get the best possible deal.

5. Consider your needs  

Before you sign on the dotted line, you should also think about your needs. After all, what do you really require the car for? How many people will be in the car on a regular basis? Do you want to go for petrol or diesel?

There’s no point plumping for something completely unsuitable just because it looks flashy. So consider these points carefully. This handy cost calculator may also help you to decide whether getting a diesel car is more cost effective than petrol or vice versa. (It ultimately depends on how far you drive.)

6. Consider payment options

You also need to think about how you’re going to pay for your car. The most obvious and most sensible way is to pay for it out of your savings.

However, if your savings aren’t sufficient, you could also consider a personal loan, dealer finance, a hire purchase agreement, personal contract hire, or personal contract purchase! If you’re confused, take a look at Seven top ways to pay for a new car.

Good luck!

More: The 10 cheapest cars to run | Earn cashback on your car

Enjoyed this? Show it some love

Twitter
General

Comments (18)

  • oldhenry
    Love rating 274
    oldhenry said

    You need to actually find one of those cars ,however. You will find that teh second hand market is flooded with ex hire cars from Ford and Vauxhall. These are the sort of discounted cars you will get after a year old. They are generally good buys with service records- if many drivers.As for Protons- i did not know they were still made!

    Also keep you car more than three years and smooth out the inevitable losses in value. You only profit the dealers by switching cars too regularly.

    Report on 11 July 2011  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • KeithJGreen
    Love rating 0
    KeithJGreen said

    Of course if you're not a badge snob this means you can buy a 3 year old car for less than £2k.

    Report on 11 July 2011  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • electricblue
    Love rating 653
    electricblue said

    What's in a badge these days?

    If you didn't know that Protons were still made you must either drive with your eyes closed or have zero vehicle recognition skills, Oldhenry. Either way, why are you commenting on a subject you have little knowledge in? Lotus are owned by Proton and the latest generation Protons have proven very reliable. In the hands of Humberside Police, who use the cars exclusively for their smaller beat vehicles, Protons have saved the force a huge amount of money due to low running costs. Proton UK also have vast experience with dual fuel conversions, as most of the Police vehicles run on LPG. Some of the deluded car snobs who comment on here make me laugh, with their pitiful knowledge of the motor industry, but it does mean that for the more clued-up drivers there are always bargains to be had with vehicles which are either little known or have an undeserved bad reputation. The latest generation Nissan Micra imported into the UK is made in Thailand/ India, but I'm sure most owners are still boasting about their 'Japanese reliability' - from a company mostly owned and controlled by Renault.

    Report on 11 July 2011  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • CuNNaXXa
    Love rating 373
    CuNNaXXa said

    My Jeep cost me £5,500, which is a saving of around £25,000 over the new price, plus because it came in before the newer tax threshold, only costs £245 a year to tax rather than the £400 that a newer vehicle in the same class would attract.

    As for reliability, it has proven very reliable, but we must remember that each vehicle is different, and that even brand new vehicles can have issues (like my mates brand new Astra that already had rust forming on the A Pillar).

    The second hand market is still very much a pot luck gamble, and sometimes you will find a right bargain, or a right pup.

    Report on 12 July 2011  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • sodit
    Love rating 129
    sodit said

    Landrover V8? Does anybody actually drive petrol Landrovers in this country? When I bought mine it was a BMW, then it turned into a Ford, and now its a Tata. Where next?

    Report on 12 July 2011  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • nickpike
    Love rating 277
    nickpike said

    You only live once. Buy a new car. Far less hassle and you can believe the mileage.

    Just about every second hand car is clocked, even from the main dealers. Nearly all new cars are company vehicles, so will generally clock up a lot of miles.

    Report on 12 July 2011  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • hughclinton
    Love rating 0
    hughclinton said

    If you do buy that new E 63 Mercedes it will be costing around £11,000 per year in depreciation - about £30 per day just in depreciation, add on to that Tax, insurance and petrol and you'll be lucky to spend less than £40 per day- so it may be less hassle but it is a huge price to pay.

    If you "Love money" which, after all, is what the article is about, then you'd be a fool to pay so much for the dubious benefit of a new car - which often as not come with faults that the first owner will get rectified under warranty.

    The second owner who buys wisely gets between 40 to 60% more value and a nicely run in (in this case) high quality car.

    Never buy new if you value your cash.

    Report on 12 July 2011  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • essexeddie
    Love rating 5
    essexeddie said

    Best to buy a highish mileage late car [year old] as said before all the problems have been sorted, the car is run in. If you keep it for a few years the mileage will have evened up.

    A lot of money saved.

    Report on 12 July 2011  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • electricblue
    Love rating 653
    electricblue said

    10% of cars in the UK are company vehicles, not 'Nearly All'. 'Just about second-hand cars is clocked'. ?? Get life! - it would not be worth anyone's time on the vast majority of vehicles.

    If the pub bores want to post on here perhaps they could try and stick to factual information instead of sharing their lack of knowledge.

    Report on 12 July 2011  |  Love thisLove  2 loves
  • spider589
    Love rating 4
    spider589 said

    Of course, there is also the option of buying a well looked after, much older car, at the virtual bottom of its depreciation curve! You need to know what you are doing, but for example I had a V12 convertible XJS a few years ago, for which I paid £6000. It was well in excess of 50k new. I kept it for 2 years, putting 26000 miles on it, then sold it for £5750. OK, the insurance and fuel consumption were higher, but if you calculate the overall cost it was still cheaper than driving round in a mundane saloon!

    Report on 13 July 2011  |  Love thisLove  1 love
  • sodit
    Love rating 129
    sodit said

    One of the best films I have ever seen is "The Bank Job" (2008). However, I have spotted 3 errors in the film. Two of these are that the registration letters of cars used postdate the setting of the events in the film. The third involves someone clocking a car. He is holding the electric drill as he does so. No one ever held the drill while clocking a car. It takes hours to wind the odometer back any significant distance. One had to suspend the drill above the speedometer and leave it to do its work.

    Report on 15 July 2011  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • Mike10613
    Love rating 600
    Mike10613 said

    @sodit - can you take 10,000 off my clock for me? :) I polished it yesterday and so it looks like new today, very shiny in the rain! It's now 14 years old and has never broken down - I'm not sure why I'm in the AA but if I cancel it will probably break down! It pays to have it serviced and I'll have a new cam belt this month. It's cost me about £300 a year in depreciation so far - less than £1 a day and I haven't finished with it yet! I'll stay thrifty - http://wp.me/194MF

    Report on 16 July 2011  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • tuttogallo
    Love rating 83
    tuttogallo said

    I believe that owning a new car is aspirational i.e it looks good to have this year's number plact visible on the drive.

    There are people living nearby who change their two cars very year without fail (I knew that the economy was in trouble when in 2008 they kept the same cars for 2 years, but in 2010 normal service was resumed, whew the economy is OK now!).

    This way of doing things which is very common in our area (you are noone if you haven't got his and hers Mercedes round here). Must be seriously damaging their wealth and I would never do it. Maybe this is another case of "big hats, no cattle" i.e. no real wealth.

    When buying a new car there's not only the depreciation, but the opportunity cost. In effect this is the interest you are foregoing in order to buy the car. So for a £20k car this would be 3% of 20K less marginal tax rate = £360: approx £1 per day, so not huge. If interest rates were nearer their long term average it would be more significant.

    Report on 16 July 2011  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • jonnie2thumbs
    Love rating 95
    jonnie2thumbs said

    I paid double what I paid for my last car on my rotovator - anyone's car help them grow food?

    Report on 17 July 2011  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • Duparc
    Love rating 3
    Duparc said

    When I could afford it, I purchased new cars but, today, being on pension the secondhand market is my level. I appreciate the larger luxury saloons which can be bought for a song and I enjoy those just as much as I did when driving new cars. The difference between the new and old is that there is no maintenance costs with new models which pays for their depreciation. I would still settle for a new car if I had the ready cash. Clearly new cars are a status symbol and if there were less purchases of new cars the costs of secondhand models would be extortionate so let us appreciate those new car buyers!

    On one occasion the main dealer phoned to remind my late wife and I that our car was due for its service. My wife answered and the female at Reception queried what kind of model it was as my wife was arranging a suitable date for uplifting. There was a hushed silence when my wife was trying to remember the model, then she blurted out, "Its square with wheels on each corner". The receptionist replied, "Yes, I know exactly the model!"

    Report on 17 July 2011  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • yocoxy
    Love rating 137
    yocoxy said

    Mike, thrifty, bloglink (again).

    Nick, Nick, Nick, so cynical.. but where would these comments be without you? ;-)

    "Just about every second hand car is clocked" That's a bold (or some might say, ill judged) statement.. but fully in character..

    ...and Sodit is an expert on clocking cars..!

    ...wow, the bright light of revelation is shining on this comment stream!

    Report on 18 July 2011  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • Bozwell
    Love rating 2
    Bozwell said

    "Just about every second hand car is clocked"

    Seriously. What idiot would believe such a statement. I'd be amazed if as many as 2% of 2nd hand cars are clocked, and even then not by much. Winding the clock back is only part of it. How do you also change the car's MOT history to support the new figure? Anyone who buys a 2nd hand car and doesn't check this for a small fee is asking to be conned.

    As for buying new or 2nd hand, I bought my last car as a nearly new from a dealer at about 6 months old. It cost me about 30% less than if I had bought it new and as far as anyone who saw me knew I had owned it from new, so it still had the pose factor. For me this is the best of both worlds.

    Report on 19 July 2011  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • pthep
    Love rating 7
    pthep said

    I bought my 2001 Alfa 166 whan it was just short of 3 years old. Someone had paid £32000 for it new - I got it for £10250 from a main dealer. It's now worth maybe £2k if i'm lucky, it has cost me a few bob in tyres and as a 3 litre it's a bit thirsty ....... BUT!, Italian stlye, full momo leather, power everything and it sounds bl**dy glorious (Novitech stainless exhaust fitted new, still going strong). Would I ever buy a new car? Nope! In fact, i doubt I'll ever sell this one.

    Report on 19 July 2011  |  Love thisLove  0 loves

Post a comment

Sign in or register to post a reply.

Our top deals

Credit card
company
Balance transfers rate and period Representative
APR
Apply
now

Barclaycard 27Mth Platinum Visa

0% for 27 months (2.98% fee) Representative 18.9% APR (variable) Apply
Representative example: assumed borrowing of £1,200, representative 18.9% APR (variable). Purchase rate 18.9% PA (variable). BT fee reduced from 3.9% to 2.98% (T&Cs apply).

Barclaycard 26Mth Platinum Visa

0% for 26 months (2.47% fee) Representative 18.9% APR (variable) Apply
Representative example: assumed borrowing of £1,200, representative 18.9% APR (variable). Purchase rate 18.9% PA (variable). BT fee reduced from 3.5% to 2.47% (T&Cs apply)

NatWest Platinum MasterCard

0% for 26 months (2.65% fee) Representative 18.9% APR (variable) Apply
Representative example: assumed borrowing of £1,200, representative 18.9% APR (variable). Purchase rate 18.95% PA (variable).
W3C  Thank you for using Three Kings