Follow this topicFollow this topic Knowledge » Gas and electricity

How I saved £175 by switching energy provider

Donna Ferguson
by Lovemoney Staff Donna Ferguson on 27 October 2012  |  Comments 12 comments

At the end of her current tariff and with a price rise to come, Donna Ferguson went shopping for a new energy supplier.

How I saved £175 by switching energy provider

What a coincidence. In the month that the energy companies start announcing price hikes, my cheap energy tariff – which was the market-leading tariff at the time that I and many thousands of other people were switching due to the last round of price rises – is expiring on the 31st October.

Hmm, is it me or is that terribly good timing for the energy companies? And, to add insult to injury, my current supplier, Scottish Power, is automatically going to move me onto its expensive Standard Tariff when my existing rate expires. How kind. Especially considering that this tariff just got even more expensive with the latest announcements.

Grrr! It makes me so cross. Just like ISA and mobile phone providers, all of the big six energy firms seem to rely on the fact that most of us will fail to find the time and, ahem, energy to keep switching tariffs. That’s how they can lure us in, offering ultra competitive tariffs in the first place. Because they really make their money when our competitive rate expires and we’re automatically moved onto their massive rip-offs... sorry, I mean their Standard Tariffs.

If energy prices happen to go up at the same time, well, that’s even more reason to celebrate. As long as you’re an energy company shareholder. If, on the other hand, you’re a time-poor, cash-strapped loyal customer, then you might find you get a very nasty shock indeed when your next bill arrives.

(Incidentally, this practice is particularly something you need to watch out for when you move house, when most energy companies – even the one you were with at your previous address! – will start you off on the Standard Tariff by default.)

Working out my bill...

So how much is Scottish Power planning to increase my bill by? To figure this out, I needed a spreadsheet and, I have to admit, a glass of wine.

First, I had to remember my log in details for my online energy account.

Second, I had to try to find out the name of my current energy tariff. You see, I’m the kind of crazy, fly-by-night girl that doesn’t learn that sort of information by heart. Shocking, I know but I had assumed it would be on my latest bill. Unfortunately, here is what it said:

“Current Service Package: WWW SVR11 D DF”

Oh dear. No wonder Ofgem wants bills to get simpler!

Anyway, eventually, I found an old email showing the name of my tariff to be, not gobbledegook, but Online Saver 11.

Then I had to search hard to find, tucked away in a unobtrusive link, an actual breakdown of the Kwh I have been using and the name of my current energy tariff. That way, I could figure out how much I am currently being charged..

...and what I would pay in future

Finally – and this is when I needed the wine – I tried to work out exactly what I will be charged on the Standard Tariff when the price changes come into effect. I knew from the announcements that the average bill will go up by 8.7% but I wanted to know exactly how the changes would affect me. Scottish Power has put a link on its homepage to explain its price changes, but – helpfully – the link detailing the changes to its standard tariff prices was wrong, and so didn’t work. So much for transparency, eh?

However, even when eventually armed with the correct link (PDF), it was difficult to work out the price increase. With most tariffs, you pay a higher rate for the first chunk of gas and electricity you use, then a lower rate after that. With a Standard Tariff, however, you may be expected to pay a daily service charge, then a standard rate for all your usage. So this is where a spreadsheet comes in handy. (But if you can’t be bothered to figure it out for yourself, the lovemoney.com energy comparison service will actually do it all for you.)

So, finally, I had my answer: when I am automatically moved to the Standard Tariff, my bill will increase by a whopping £180 a year!

Ouch. Of course, there is no way on earth I am sticking with Scottish Power if that is what is going to happen. The next question is: which supplier should I switch to?

Time to compare energy tariffs

As a first step, I decided to compare energy tariffs to see which one would be the cheapest.

The iSave Dual Fuel V12 from First:Utility came out top, offering me a saving of about £280. But I’ve heard this firm has a poor reputation for customer service. Next up was nPower’s Energy Online January 2014 tariff, offering a saving of around £250. But again, I have had poor customer service with this company, and so wouldn’t touch it again with a barge pole. Plus, both these tariffs are variable, and in this climate, I think I would prefer the security of a fixed rate.

Neck and neck in third place were Sainsbury’s Price Check January 2014 and Ovo Energy’s New Fixed deal, with savings of approximately £175. I liked the Ovo Energy deal best. Not only is it fixed for 12 months, unlike the Sainsbury’s deal, but it got some great customer service ratings from Which? (do let me know if you disagree) This tariff also has greener credentials than its competitors, donating £60 on your behalf to the charity Cool Earth to plant Amazonian rainforest as a reward for switching. It also promises to generate 15% of the electricity you consume from renewable sources.

So, although it is not the cheapest tariff I could switch to, it will provide me with peace of mind that my tariff won’t rise again during the expensive winter months, and I like the sound of the company.

What do you think? Are you planning to get a fixed rate? Or have you got anything – good or bad – to say about customer service you’ve received from energy firms? Please share your experiences using the Comments box below!

Compare gas and electricity tariffs now and see if you could save

More on energy

EDF announces biggest energy price rise yet

Is British Gas telling the truth?

Ten ways to save on energy

How to get free cavity wall and loft insulation

Simpler energy bills won't mean lower prices

Enjoyed this? Show it some love

Twitter
General

Comments (12)

  • GaryDean
    Love rating 56
    GaryDean said

    This word saving is misused. No matter how many times we go on comparison sites or mess around in any which way we still end up paying more.........and more as each year goes by. Supermarkets totally misuse words such as 'SAVE' 'ONLY' etc etc while our food prices go up & up & up & up at an alarming rate. We NEVER save, we only spend!

    Report on 27 October 2012  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • Tes
    Love rating 5
    Tes said

    So Donna, how much more expensive is the tariff you are switching to, than the tariff you are on , the one that's about to end?

    You aren't saving anything as you weren't on standard tariff to begin with. What you are doing is merely reducing the prospective INCREASE in your bills.

    Even those of us who switch often, or as often as the companies' switching taxes, sorry 'early cancellation fees' allow, find that the price still goes up by the time you near the end of your tariff. The company will have brought out 3 or 4 newer versions of that tariff, each one more expensive than the last, or may have even stopped using the tariff name in order to bring out a new 'replacement' tariff series, again, with a higher price.

    Report on 28 October 2012  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • oldhenry
    Love rating 265
    oldhenry said

    I think everyone needs a spreadsheet to work outthier best deal. use tehactual usage of you home too, not a hypothetical house.

    I am with OVO and find their admin very good indeed. Obviosuly the prices goes up each year as they are allin it together, only manycompanies make much more profits than OVO.

    Do not forget that a good chunk of your increase bills are going to teh weathly types that install windfarms and solar panels. It is a transfer of funds from the poor to the rich and was instigated by teh Labour governmnet. They once represented the 'poor' but not since Blair came on the scene and stole teh party for the capitailsts. There is no one representing the poor now- tough.

    Report on 28 October 2012  |  Love thisLove  1 love
  • silkycat
    Love rating 37
    silkycat said

    As has been pointed out Donna's switch is actually a damage limitation exercise in hopping from one fixed rate to the next. It would be a real saving if the new rate were actually lower than the previous one. It's just not as high as it might have been.

    I am with EDF and have just gone on to their new fixed rate Blue + Price promise until 2014 replacing their previous fixed rate deal. Not lower of course (see a pattern here) but better than their new standard rate with its 10% hike.

    They promise to tell me if a competitor has a rate that would be more than £1 a week cheaper for me. That still gives them a £52 a year cushion, and all of the competing rate have gone up too - how convenient. As far as I'm aware my new rate, which only came into force on 1st October, has already been withdrawn. I wonder what the next one will be - don't hold your breath for a lower one, you could end up very blue in the face!

    Is this connected with the usual seasonal increase in demand or preparation for David Cameron's simplified and transparent rates? Guess who pays the fuel bill for 10 Downing Street - you and me of course.

    Report on 28 October 2012  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • nickpike
    Love rating 270
    nickpike said

    We've got more to do with our lives than keep checking energy prices and swapping. It's got intolerable now. This country has become a mad house.

    Report on 28 October 2012  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • Donna Ferguson
    Love rating 130
    Donna Ferguson said

    Fair comment about the word 'save'. I guess i should have said 'how i avoided a £175 increase in my bill' but it seemed a bit wordy. Bear in mind that I couldn't switch before the end of this month, and if I didn't switch my bills were going to go up by £180. So I do perceive it as a saving, personally, and was well worth doing anyway.

    Report on 28 October 2012  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • cdsmith
    Love rating 1
    cdsmith said

    We had the same experience with an online tariff with Scottish Power a couple of years ago. They announced a general price increase of, say, 8%, but the four individual tariffs on our bill (the first n units and subsequent n+1 units at normal and Economy 7 rates) increased by between 28% and 56%! We have now bundled electricity, gas, phone and broadband with Utility Warehouse for reasons of cost, customer service and getting away from the big energy suppliers.

    Report on 29 October 2012  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • isobelsgrandma
    Love rating 35
    isobelsgrandma said

    Donna, couldn't you just have requested the cheapest tariff with your current supplier? I've switched companies 3 times in the past and it's not the simple exercise that they all claim. Also switching at this time of year means that you haven't built up the credit to take you relatively painlessly through the expensive winter months. I'm with British Gas and, yes, I know it's not the cheapest. I manage my account completely online so can change to the cheapest tariff at the press of a computer key when they automatically change me back to their standard tariff (annoying but they all do it) and, as the latest round of price increases has shown, they all jump on the bandwagon once one of them increases their prices.

    Report on 29 October 2012  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • Donna Ferguson
    Love rating 130
    Donna Ferguson said

    Good point Isobel's grandma. I thought is go for a switch this time as I liked the sound of ovo energy and it offered the cheapest fixed tariff. However I too have suffered from poor customer service when switching in the past (from npower). I will report back on the switch if I can, and let lovemoney readers know how it goes. Here's hoping they don't mess it up.

    Report on 29 October 2012  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • LastChip
    Love rating 92
    LastChip said

    First things first.

    I too am with OVO and have been from near the beginning. Their customer service in my experience is excellent and is a huge chunk of my desire to stay with them for the coming year. Their rates whilst competitive, are no longer market leading. But their service (for me) is worth a little extra.

    Ofgem and the excuse we've got for a government, needs to get to grips with tariffs. When it comes to comparing energy companies, is it reasonable to expect everyone to sit down with a spreadsheet to work out the best deal? They should mandate the culling of different rates/usage and standing charges. Ideally, you should be able to look at each supplier and see (for example), supplier "A" is going to charge me 10p per Kwh and supplier "B" is going to charge me 11p per Kwh. End of story. Complete transparency that everyone can understand. They all spout about it, but no one bites the bullet and mandates it into law.

    These suppliers, whether it be energy, mobile phones or any other type of service industry confuse the hell out of people, by making their tariffs confusing in the extreme. OVO is probably better than most, but still uses daily standing charges plus unit charges and of course, we mustn't forget the dear old VAT stuck on the end! Rip off Britain reigns supreme.

    Report on 03 November 2012  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • fortitude24
    Love rating 17
    fortitude24 said

    Absolutely agree with LastChip. These companies ought to be mandated yes mandated to quote completely transparent prices IE price per unit so that comparison is simple.

    I am a qualified Accountant and it takes me ages to compare prices.

    Why should they have Standing Charges? Make your money on the unit prices please and let us compare.

    I have switched to First Utility i Save V4 from Eon and so far no issues (the switch has occured on 7/10/2012) but Eon, bless them have sent me an estimated bill to beyond this period so I have canceled the Direct Debit. Still waiting for First Utility to set up the direct debit. The only thing I am apprehensive about is to give monthly readings but perhaps it will help me monitor the usage better.

    Report on 03 November 2012  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • GrandOiseau
    Love rating 0
    GrandOiseau said

    You have to be a little bit careful in respect of "customer service". Some people have unrealistic expectations.

    Also in respect of simplified tariffs. These companies don't have a broad product range. Finding ways to "package up" what they have is one of the few ways they can differentiate themselves. If you simplify it too much you will remove competition. That said I agree you shouldn't need a degree in maths. They need to get the level right.

    Report on 08 November 2012  |  Love thisLove  0 loves

Post a comment

Sign in or register to post a reply.

Our top deals

Credit card
company
Balance transfers rate and period Representative
APR
Apply
now

Barclaycard 27Mth Platinum Visa

0% for 27 months (3.5% fee) Representative 18.9% APR (variable) Apply
Representative example: assumed borrowing of £1,200, representative 18.9% APR (variable). Purchase rate 18.9% PA (variable). BT fee is reduced from 3.9% to 3.5% (T&Cs apply).

Barclaycard 25Mth Platinum Visa

0% for 25 months (2.4% fee) Representative 18.9% APR (variable) Apply
Representative example: assumed borrowing of £1,200, representative 18.9% APR (variable). Purchase rate 18.9% PA (variable). BT fee is reduced from 3.5% to 2.4% (T&Cs apply)

Halifax BT 25 Month MasterCard

0% for 25 months (2.5% fee) Representative 18.9% APR (variable) Apply
Representative example: assumed borrowing of £1,200, representative 18.9% APR (variable). Purchase rate 19.0% PA (variable).
W3C  Thank you for using CGWEBLIV4