Inflation is up but base rate won't move just yet

Ed Bowsher
by Lovemoney Staff Ed Bowsher on 19 January 2010  |  Comments 2 comments

Inflation has jumped 1% which is bad news for savers. But the news isn't a huge surprise and I suspect the base rate won't rise in the very near future.

Inflation has jumped by 1%. The Consumer Price Index (CPI) - the government's favourite measure of rising prices - bounced from 1.9% in November to 2.9% in December. That's a chunky rise and no doubt some observers will see it as a harbinger of inflation taking off in 2010. 

However, I'm not so sure. Most people - including me - were expecting a rise around now. That's because inflation was exceptionally low in December 2008 due to: 

  • VAT reduction from 17.5% to 15%
  • Sharp falls in the price of oil
  • Pre-christmas sales following the economic crisis

So when you compare prices in December 2009 with a year earlier, you're comparing with a low base. So it's not that surprising that price rises were relatively high last month. OK, I wasn't expecting the rise to be quite as high as 2.9%, but it's only a bit higher than I thought. I also expect inflation to be high for January 2010 thanks to VAT going back up to 17.5% and higher energy prices. 

But going forward, my prediction is that inflation will fall back later in the year. The economy is still pretty sluggish and may well slow down again once the next government starts increasing taxes and cutting public expenditure. Reduced demand in the economy will keep the lid on inflation. 

So if I sat on the Bank of England's Monetary Policy Committee (MPC), I'd see no need to raise the base rate in the next three months. My decision wouldn't just be down to the benign inflation outlook for the second half of the year. I'd also know that the Bank's money-printing programme - Quantitative Easing (QE) - will probably stop in February. Stopping QE will be a counter-inflationary move in itself, so that reduces the need to increase interest rates. 

What about savers? 

This is all bad news for savers. Higher inflation accompanied by a static base rate is just what savers don't need. It means that it becomes even harder for savers to keep up with inflation. If you're a basic rate taxpayer, you'll need to get at least 3.63% to keep up with inflation. 

Sadly, there's no easy access savings account that pays as much. The top easy access account - the Coventry 1st Class Postal - only pays 3.3%. (And you could argue that it's not really an instant access account as you're only allowed four penalty-free withdrawals each year.) 

You could beat 3.63% with some fixed rate bonds, but then you're tying your money up for several years and your current inflation-beating rate might not look so good in two or three years' time. 

Still, if I'm right and inflation does fall back in a few months, things won't be quite so bad for savers. But they weren't exactly be good either.....

Enjoyed this? Show it some love

Twitter
General

Comments (2)

  • ThatLindseyGuy
    Love rating 114
    ThatLindseyGuy said

    Good points made as usual. However, I'm inclined to believe energy price rises are something of a red herring and that the blame for rising inflation can be laid firmly at the door of the expansion of the monetary base, which most recently has been caused by QE.

    My theory is that if the amount of money in the financial system stays constant, a rise in the price of one essential good (e.g. food or fuel) should correspond with a fall in the price of other goods, ensuring that inflation stays relatively constant, possibly even falling if people start to expect further price rises and cut back sharply on non-essentials.

    Chart

    The chart linked above shows year-on-year UK CPI inflation since 1999. Going back to that year, while oil prices rose 150% (from $10 to $25) in 1999, CPI actually fell from 1.6% to 1.1% over that same year.

    The reason being that the monetary base remained fairly constant, ensuring that a sharp rise in the price of a non-discretionary good such as oil would necessitate a corresponding fall in the price of other consumer items, helping keep CPI low.

    In fact inflation only really started to gain momentum during 2004-2008, when the effect of huge consumer credit issuance (mortgages/equity withdrawal in particular) had the effect of expanding the monetary base such that consumer prices rose across the board, which is the same effect QE is having now.

    Report on 19 January 2010  |  Love thisLove  1 love
  • Ed Bowsher
    Love rating 76
    Ed Bowsher said

    Hi Lindsey,

    Good to hear from you. I'm delighted that you take the time to comment on my posts....

    I can see your point. I do think that monetary policy has a very big impact on inflation. And I can understand why people are worried. QE is unprecedented and, yes, all other things being equal, a big rise in the money supply should trigger inflation.

    But all other things aren't equal. Yes, there's been a big rise in the money supply, but has there been a rise in money velocity? I doubt it. I think money is sitting in bank vaults doing not very much. Yes, we've seen significant asset price inflation (from a low base), but I'm still not convinced that retail prices are going to zoom upwards this year. Especially since demand in the economy will be low.

    So, for me, I'm 95% sure that QE will end in Feb, but I think that a base rate rise may be further off. And I don't think we need to start panicking about inflation just yet.

    I could, of course, be wrong. I hope I'm not. Not out of pride. It's just that we could all do without an inflation crisis...

    Ed

    PS. I no longer have access to a Bloomberg screen. I'm jealous that you have one.....

    Report on 19 January 2010  |  Love thisLove  1 love

Post a comment

Sign in or register to post a reply.

Our top deals

Provider & account name Credit rate (AER)
Based on £1
Overdraft
rate

Based on £1
Apply
now

Santander 123 Current Account

0.0% 0% plus £1.00 per day usage fee Apply

first direct 1st Account

N/A 15.9% EAR Apply

Halifax Reward Current Account

N/A 0% plus £2.00 per day usage fee Apply
W3C  Thank you for using Lock, Stock and Two Smoking Barrels