A warning sign for inflation

Ed Bowsher
by Lovemoney Staff Ed Bowsher on 03 September 2009  |  Comments 5 comments

I'm becoming slightly less sanguine about the threat of inflation.

As soon as central banks started to aggressively cut interest rates at the end of last year, some commentators were worrying about the threat of renewed inflation. Those worries were strengthened when the Bank of England started to 'print money' via its Quantitative Easing (QE) programme.

The inflation hawks reckon that if the supply of money increases rapidly in an economy, then inflation will inevitably start to rise quickly too. So, according to this view, if we're not careful, price rises could get out of hand and we would face a new inflation-driven economic crisis.

Now although I've never completely ruled out the above scenario,  I have been relatively sanguine about the inflation threat over the last year. The level of demand in the economy was seriously damaged by last autumn's crisis and given that background, deflation seemed a greater threat to me than inflation. I've not expected inflation to be a problem until 2011 or later. If at all.

What's changed?

I read a very interesting article yesterday on the breakingviews website (sadly, subscription only) which highlighted an early warning sign of looming inflation. The piece looked at the August US ISM manufacturing report which records purchasing managers' views of business conditions.

65% of respondents said that prices were rising, compared to 55% of managers a month earlier. Yet only 46% of managers said that employment was rising. So if that trend continues, we might face a 70s-style scenario where prices rise fast whilst unemployment stays high.

It's also interesting to note that gold has been on the up this week. The gold price has risen 3% to $987. Gold is often seen as a good investment to hold in inflationary times so that suggests that some participants think inflation is round the corner.

Now it's early days, and I'm still not convinced that inflation is set to soar in the very near future. But I want to keep an open mind and I'll try to evaluate all new data with a fresh, unjaundiced eye.

Enjoyed this? Show it some love

Twitter
General

Comments (5)

  • Andrrew
    Love rating 0
    Andrrew said

    Gold may be out of the reach of most of us, but in this crowded isle the next best thing is property. Does this mean falling house prices are over?

    Report on 06 September 2009  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • mcb1063
    Love rating 0
    mcb1063 said

    I know there are good reasons why we don't want to see the return of inflation, but inflation can bring advantages too. Those of us with rather large mortgages will see the relative value of those debts fall in an inflationary environment. Those people who had a hefty 20k mortgage in 1970 saw inflation turn it into a very modest 20k mortgage in 1980 (ok, repayments over the decade would have seriously reduced the 20k, but you get my point!) I wouldn't mind a bit of inflation - what do others think?

    Report on 06 September 2009  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • gordonbanks42
    Love rating 11
    gordonbanks42 said

    Current monetary policy will remain non-inflationary only for as long as it continues not to "work" i.e. for as long as the money being lent and printed by the BofE continues to be stashed by banks rather than becoming available to consumers and businesses for buying goods and services. They said it would take 6 months or so before we saw that shift happen and the 6 months is about up. Perhaps it took a bit less than 6 months in the USA and it's taking a little longer here.

    As for inflation being a good thing, I have to disagree. It tends to favour those who consume more than they earn and to "punish" those who save and invest to form capital for the future. It's just a "soft" way of decreasing real wages, debts and asset prices - "soft" in the sense that it appears to be no-one's fault (but even that isn't true if you think about it).

    Report on 06 September 2009  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • LAWR3NC3
    Love rating 9
    LAWR3NC3 said

    Strategists are always concerned to avoid the 'momentum of inflation' (ie the general perception that prices will continue to rise 'significantly') which takes years to control. Once this 'perception' has entered the general psyche there is pressure on wages & all else follows.

    The general view amongst monetarists is that some inflation is good - hence the 2% target for the BoE. I have always assumed that this is because at this level it is generally ignored & it is far more controllable than deflation - something I suspect most Japanese consumers would agree with.

    Just as an indicator a recent Reuters pole concluded that bank rates are probably not due to rise until next June!

    HstG.

    Report on 07 September 2009  |  Love thisLove  0 loves
  • Ed Bowsher
    Love rating 78
    Ed Bowsher said

    Hi,

    There's an interesting discussion here. Thanks for your comments. Keep em coming!

    Anyway, Gordonbanks said:

    'Current monetary policy will remain non-inflationary only for as long as it continues not to "work" i.e. for as long as the money being lent and printed by the BofE continues to be stashed by banks rather than becoming available to consumers and businesses for buying goods and services.'

    Yes, that's absolutely right. I should have said that in my post. So we all need to watch whether the banks are lending the newly-created money or hoarding it.

    Moving on, it's an interesting little debate about whether inflation is a good thing or not. I guess I'm slightly scarred by what's happened in my lifetime. I remember the 70s. I remember it was bad, and I also remember that inflation was high during that period. So on an emotional level, I definitely see inflation as a 'bad' thing.

    On a more logical level, I agree again with Gordon's points. Inflation can be good for borrowers, but it's not good for savers. It's especially hard on pensioners who may be relying on level annuities for their income. It can be good for people with large mortgages who can see the value of their debt inflated away.

    The point about perception or inflationary expectations is also interesting. As you suggest, once expectations are high, you may need a big sledgehammer to change those expectations. Which is what happened in the 80s. And yes, there is a danger that central bankers could let things get out of control and then we'd have a problem.

    But I'm still more worried about choking off a very early-stage recovery rather than creating a climate where inflationary expectations are embedded in the mind of the person on the street.

    Ed

    Report on 07 September 2009  |  Love thisLove  0 loves

Post a comment

Sign in or register to post a reply.

Our top deals

Provider & account name Credit rate (AER)
Based on £1
Overdraft
rate

Based on £1
Apply
now

Santander 123 Current Account

0.0% 0% plus £1.00 per day usage fee Apply

first direct 1st Account

N/A 0% Apply

Nationwide BS FlexPlus

3.0% 0% plus £0.50 per day usage fee Apply
W3C  Thank you for using CGWEBLIV3